Lettres magiques au père Noël

Loved this holiday movie. The story was not an easy topic to address but it was handled very well.

The acting was terrific. Each and every character was totally believable. I really felt that the characters struggle. The children were amazing actors. It was so enjoyable to see how They interacted so well with the adults.

I found the entire story to be very heartwarming. As a hallmark movie, you expect a happy ending and that's exactly what you got. Nonetheless isn't that what we all hope for.

I'll definitely watch this movie over again.

I also loved the cultural diversity.

Definitely not a typical hallmark movie but definitely one that everyone can relate to.

This is a slightly unusual Christmas movie in that the lead couple is already married but experiencing a time of separation. The two kids are freely exchanged between their home where mom is living and grandmother's house where dad is living. This makes for an interesting mix of tone and emotions. There is some serious friction between the couple but they seem to care about each other and neither has reached the point where they really want a divorce. One source of their friction is that each is busy and stressed by their work worlds. We find out fairly deep into the movie the truth about another important source of their friction (although I agree with another reviewer that it doesn't make sense that this was a secret.)

The movie deals with a lot of family issues. The struggle by the kids is an obvious one. Money is another. Enrique's mom is a bit of a meddler. Enrique is helping his mom maintain the family restaurant after the passing of his dad. Rebecca is not used to the tight knit family that Enrique has especially given that he has a strong family loyalty. Opposite sex relationships at work is an issue.

The movie also has some light moments with some humor. The kids get a "magic pen" from Santa. Grandma starts reading their letters to Santa and tries to fulfill some wishes. There are lots of misunderstandings often humorous. Another factor that leads to some of the lighter moments is Rebecca's children's book which she is late delivering and has writer's block. Later in the movie, Rebecca starts to put some of the family's personal experiences into the book and the parallels are interesting.

I like the family tradition where one person can make a statement beginning with "True or False" to confront the true feelings of the other person. Even the kids do it. I would have expected a family with this tradition would resolve many problems before they get serious because of the resulting honesty and openness.

I am an avid Christmas movie fan but I find it easy to get angry at someone or something early or be turned off by a less than jolly tone. Somehow in this movie I avoided both and was able to enjoy a good story.

Letters To Santa (2023) -

If you're going to make a film about separated parents at Christmas I believe that it really should be a full on comedy and not a blend of emotional distress and humour, because the subject matter is never a pleasant topic.

Perhaps it shouldn't even be a trope that's used for seasonal films at all.

It did need to be heartfelt, but not this hodge podge mix of sad and farcical, which from the beginning put me off quite a lot.

Add to that the shoddy camera work and the incredibly obvious outcome and it really wasn't the best.

The only reason it had made it to my final cut of the Christmas films I chose to watch this year (Because there were so many and just not enough time) was due to Rafael de la Fuente as Enrique looking so good and peaking my interest and my trousers.

He really was hot, but not the best actor and quite gay seeming (Turned out he's a gayer in real life). And there was no way anyone could be as bad at throwing as his character either, which didn't help his cause, but he was the one I felt for the most.

Rebecca (Katie Leclerc) was definitely the one causing the majority of the problems in their relationship and certainly the least flexible. I didn't really want Enrique to get back together with her, except for the sake of the kids, who really weren't that bad for a change. Perhaps a good story would be to show how families can separate and still be happy in two homes, as is quite often the case today? Present a situation where the biological parents realise that they are better as friends and can work things out amicably whilst showing the grieving children the benefits of having four parents. Make one of the couples gay and give one of the kids a wheelchair to make sure to cover the bases and you've got a winning formula. It probably sounds like I'm joking, but I would watch that.

One of the things that I can't get to grips with in these situations is how families can struggle to find time for each other. If I had kids they would be my whole world, heck if I had a cat the same would be true. My parents made a point to give my sister and I time as a child and I never wanted for a Grandparent, Aunty or Uncle, although the sister and cousins were frequently annoying. It's such a shame that families have become so fractured.

And another thing. How are the restaurants depicted always sooo busy that the characters do lose touch with their families and spend too much time at work? I also can't work out how writing a children's book is sooo stressful. I've written three, although none are yet published, but there really shouldn't be any of the pressure that this film made out there was.

Ultimately the plot was as you'd expect - The magic of Christmas helped two struggling separated parents find their way back to each other via the various tick list items of cookies, trees, decorations and so on. It's been done before and better and as I've said I really don't think that it's the right topic to deliver seasonal messages, but this interpretation wasn't so bad that I turned it off. I will state once again that Rafael de la Fuente may have had something to do with that and I wouldn't mind seeing him in the gay parent role described above either, because I think he could deliver that better.

As for the other bits and bobs that I observed in the film, I felt that the Counsellor, Dr Eaton (Liliane Klein) was highly unprofessional and way too much. Liam, played by Harry Aspinwall, was over the top British in his performance too, while Vanessa (Mariela Hill) was just a lousy actor. Laura Cerón as Enrique's Mother Camilla was good, but the other supporting cast members weren't brilliant.

The dog was adorable however, but for some reason became surplus to requirements far too quickly and was hardly ever shown afterwards.

As has happened before, it felt like the story had been rushed to fit the 1.5 hour time frame and not to really do it justice, which is why the kids looking after the puppy and the positive effect it would have had on the household were probably edited down and the overall feel of warmth at Christmas time might have seemed lacking.

The last note I had was that the drawings for the "Oh so stressful" book were awful and really old fashioned and the storyline for it a real cop out, especially as there wasn't any real magic involved in the films actual narrative, which could have potentially made this film more enjoyable to tone down the upset in their relationship.

The kids "Magic" pen told their parents what they really wanted, but I honestly didn't see the marriage lasting more than another year at most. Perhaps Enrique's coming out and their amicable separation could be the sequel?

Not the worst film I've ever seen, but it needed more newness and a bit of extra polish.

5.35/10.

I disagree with the idea the mother in law is some kind of savior to the couple. She is a big part of the problem. She gets in the way for her own needs and wants.

The husband is putting his birth family ahead of his family with his wife and expecting her to just go along. It's not fair to anyone. Even the sister tries to explain to her brother the dad that not everyone is used to always putting your birth family first. She talks about how they tried to name the baby before it was born . All the husband could say I was in trouble with my mom about that. The mother in law finally gets it half way thru the movie . She finally stops meddling.

It was a good idea to discuss real issues in a Christmas movie. The holidays often brings out real conflict that really about other things.

When I started to watch this I thought, "this must be a fan-favorite series, since this was number 5". I hadn't seen or heard about it's predecessors, but I would like to assume they continued the saga due to popular choice. It is daring to tackle the subject of marital-strife, and especially, its damaging effects on the security of children, especially centered around a Christmastime theme. This is definitely a more serious tone than a vast majority of Hallmark's holiday movies, and it may have been heartwarming (with better execution) if it didn't devote almost three-fourths of its time to the bickering, misunderstanding, and pettiness between the parents, Rebecca and Enrique. The redemptive moral is the wonderful mother-in-law, Camilla, who Rebecca, somehow, mostly fails to recognize . Of the three of them, Camilla is the only selfless one, who truly exemplifies the spirit of giving. Only when the children (pure of heart) contribute to Rebecca's book, does Rebecca affirm the extra-efforts that Camilla had undergone to lighten the heavy hearts of the children attributable to her and Enrique's separation. Camilla also illuminates Rebecca of Enrique's selfless investment, and personal sacrifice to save their family restaurant business. This is, unfortunately, a fact in many marital disputes - that the spouses are blinded by resentment, and only a bystander can illuminate the problem. Unfortunately, by the time Rebecca and Enrique resolve their differences, it's so late in the movie, that you're deprived of any deep emotion or gratification.