Finding Michael
- 2023
- 1h 40min
NOTE IMDb
5,9/10
2,2 k
MA NOTE
L'équipe de Spencer Matthews part en direction de l'Everest pour tenter de retrouver son frère Michael, disparu il y a 23 ans.L'équipe de Spencer Matthews part en direction de l'Everest pour tenter de retrouver son frère Michael, disparu il y a 23 ans.L'équipe de Spencer Matthews part en direction de l'Everest pour tenter de retrouver son frère Michael, disparu il y a 23 ans.
Avis à la une
It started out as a sympathetic story, and of course, it is a family tragedy. As we watched, my husband and I were wowed by the spectacular houses the family lived in as much as the Everest climb. What do these people DO for a living? We wondered how they carved out the time to plan and make the trip. Do they work?
The real story came out well into the movie, when they shared that their 22-year-old son climbed Mt Everest wearing a Rolex watch. And the real story is the tone-deafness of the family and filmers. The movie is silent on the subject of the family affluence set against the poverty of the Sherpas. It's no sin to be rich but own the privilege! Talk about the cost of the expedition, the Sherpa's compensation, the risks they took -- make the story about the Sherpas as much as the other characters -- they are the real heroes here.
The "well, as long as we're up here" return of the Sherpa body was distasteful. Filming weeping children. Honestly.
The real story came out well into the movie, when they shared that their 22-year-old son climbed Mt Everest wearing a Rolex watch. And the real story is the tone-deafness of the family and filmers. The movie is silent on the subject of the family affluence set against the poverty of the Sherpas. It's no sin to be rich but own the privilege! Talk about the cost of the expedition, the Sherpa's compensation, the risks they took -- make the story about the Sherpas as much as the other characters -- they are the real heroes here.
The "well, as long as we're up here" return of the Sherpa body was distasteful. Filming weeping children. Honestly.
This doc film charts Spencer Matthews' quest to find the body of his brother who dies near the peak of Everest. There's a lot that's beautiful - particularly the footage of the mountain and the story of Michael who seems like a wonderful human. What lets it down is Spencer's lack of emotional depth, as he seems nearly throughout to see this as an exciting &wide-eyed adventure, not a deep, personal experience it ought to be. Moreover, watching Nims bounce across the mountain 'body-hunting' just feels in really bad taste, and disrespectful to all that die there. Left a sour taste, if I'm honest.
Bit apprehensive after reading some of the reviews, but thought it was worth the watch. Some people need to calm down about the "priveledge" aspect - of course they couldn't afford to attempt this without financial/media backing, and at the end of the day the sherpas traverse mountains for a living - their whole career has inherent risk, they are paid to fulfill other people's wishes.
I think it conveys the risks of extreme mountaineering well, and shows the devastation that the loss of a loved one in such a circumstance can have on the family left behind.
Spencer does have a bit of a cold soulless exterior, which can be a tad hard to warm to. Good cinematography.
I think it conveys the risks of extreme mountaineering well, and shows the devastation that the loss of a loved one in such a circumstance can have on the family left behind.
Spencer does have a bit of a cold soulless exterior, which can be a tad hard to warm to. Good cinematography.
Spencer Matthews has 0 emotion throughout. What should be an emotional search for his brother, comes across as staged and narcissistic. I enjoyed all the parts that didn't include him. There is a running theme of privilege, he has paid others to risk their lives, while he says at the bottom in his nice tent eating a hot meal, stressed that his Walky Talky isn't working. He didn't do anything! Then returns home stating he now know what it's like to reach the summit, in his multi million pound holiday home.
If this followed the Nepalese guy and the search for his brother, this would be a much more well recieved documentary.
If this followed the Nepalese guy and the search for his brother, this would be a much more well recieved documentary.
So you go on an expedition to find the body of your brother after 20 years based in a picture and you do not even check with the people which have the most knowledge??
The documentary is just bizarre and completely nonsensical poorly written and with things said which are not accurate ......this is clearly just done for visibility ...the 2 star is only because of some sporadic nice pics of the mountains.
Poorly portrait situations and the whole documentary just is has this vibe of fake or strange ...the narration is also very subjective on things which are not .
All in all a completely waste of time and towards the end stopped listening all together.
The documentary is just bizarre and completely nonsensical poorly written and with things said which are not accurate ......this is clearly just done for visibility ...the 2 star is only because of some sporadic nice pics of the mountains.
Poorly portrait situations and the whole documentary just is has this vibe of fake or strange ...the narration is also very subjective on things which are not .
All in all a completely waste of time and towards the end stopped listening all together.
Meilleurs choix
Connectez-vous pour évaluer et suivre la liste de favoris afin de recevoir des recommandations personnalisées
- How long is Finding Michael?Alimenté par Alexa
Détails
- Durée
- 1h 40min(100 min)
- Couleur
- Mixage
Contribuer à cette page
Suggérer une modification ou ajouter du contenu manquant