La Sorcière dans les airs

Bob the Moo (whose reviews on IMDb I adore) described this movie as "Slight but enjoyable family animation" and I couldn't have said it any better myself. The short film is a wonderful thing for kids and parents to watch with them--and I'm sure they'll enjoy it immensely. But, I was perplexed that it was nominated for the Oscar for Best Animated Short. It's good but nothing more. Plus, while I normally like to root for the shorts made by young filmmakers, the Disney film "Get a Horse!" is just light-years ahead of the pack--and I don't see how "Room on the Broom" could offer it any serious competition.

"Room on the Broom" plays like a kid's book because apparently it IS from a kid's book. This British production reminds me a lot of another nominee from the UK--"The Gruffalo". It also was a wonderful film for young kids (they'll adore it) but artistically I couldn't understand the nomination.

The story is of a nice witch who is flying about with her cat. Through the course of the film, she picks up several new friends--a dog, a bird and a frog. But how can she carry them all on her broom--especially when it breaks?! Cute, fun and a treat for kids. But not a film that says anything more to me.

Beautifully told, animated and implemented. Simply a wonderful film for children but also adults with a big heart for the little details.

While it is definitely aimed at a younger, more easily pleased audience, this is a very charming animation with cute characters that you can't help but find appealing.

It doesn't really take you anywhere, despite being a story about a journey, but I don't think that it was aiming to. It's just meant to be an easy and simple tale to entertain children and in that it succeeds.

I don't think it was worth paying for Gillian Anderson for the few lines she had though.

I have to say that I resonated with the cat, because I don't like to share my human either, but occasionally I can make an allowance to let others in.

I actually don't know any of the Julia Donaldson books from my own childhood, so these TV film shorts are my only reference to the stories and they seem to show what a great storyteller she is.

664.15/1000.

The witty words of Julia Donaldson and the wonder of Magic Light Pictures once again give us a delightful film. Brought to life by a treasure of voice talents from Britain's best (Gillian Anderson, Simon Pegg, Ron Braydon, Timothy Spall, Martin Clunes, Sally Hawkins, David Walliams) and the brilliant musical characterizations of Rene Aubrey, the story garners critical and award attention (Oscar, Cristal, Annie, Magnolia, TIFF). I give this film an 8 (delightful) out of 10. {Family Animation}

Having read the book many times to my Julia Donaldson obsessed daughter it was great to see it brought to life in this action packed short animation. I'm abit confused by some of the adults in the comments touching on its lack of appeal for a older audience... Its for children... Seeing the happiness on my little girl's face was good enough for me. Maybe try family guy.