NOTE IMDb
6,1/10
1,9 k
MA NOTE
Solution ou malédiction ? Des médicaments anxiolytiques communément prescrits sont évalués par des patients et des scientifiques dans ce documentaire révélateur.Solution ou malédiction ? Des médicaments anxiolytiques communément prescrits sont évalués par des patients et des scientifiques dans ce documentaire révélateur.Solution ou malédiction ? Des médicaments anxiolytiques communément prescrits sont évalués par des patients et des scientifiques dans ce documentaire révélateur.
- Réalisation
- Scénario
- Casting principal
Avis à la une
On the positive side, this "documentary" does establish "Be careful what drugs you take and how you take them." Thanks for that bit of unique wisdom that everyone already knows.
The film does try to present a balanced view of Xanax, displaying both beneficial and negative experiences in using the drug. But people are different. The guy that had to withdraw from Xanax over years using microdoses is an extremely rare case; the focus on him was excessive. Most people can withdraw in a month or two, some faster. People who take a prescribed maintenance dose may have no need to withdraw. For many people this medicine is essential to function in a normal manner.
They did discuss doctors over-prescribing these drugs and not doing proper follow-up. Their presentation of the medical community is quite accurate in regard to the "corporate doctor" situation we see so much today.
The young blonde who took a regulated dosage of Xanax daily due to serious panic attacks and properly balanced her life with that dosage-- that is more what the drug is intended for. Again, they touched on but didn't even name PTSD-- a condition which is more common than most people realize, and which may absolutely require treatment with such drugs for the person to even survive. When the brain is totally out of sync with their body, heart, lungs and hormones, Clonazepam (another form of Xanax) is almost a miracle cure for such people-- and taking it is not an "option" if they want to live a normal life.
Largely this film just touches the surface of issues but doesn't really establish anything. At the end, viewers are left knowing no more about the drug, its benefits, its dangers, and proper administration or use than they did when the documentary began. It's an hour and a half of non-accomplishment in which they discuss a wide variety of viewpoints, with no real solutions or even suggestions. Oh, except smoke weed. That can be a viable alternative.
This is basically a non-helpful, uninformative non-documentary. A person can learn more by simply browsing the Internet and reading about Xanax. The only thing to take away from this is the obvious: Don't take Xanax recreationally or in excess. Don't "get hooked" on it. That's for those of us who need that "duh" kind of information.
The film does try to present a balanced view of Xanax, displaying both beneficial and negative experiences in using the drug. But people are different. The guy that had to withdraw from Xanax over years using microdoses is an extremely rare case; the focus on him was excessive. Most people can withdraw in a month or two, some faster. People who take a prescribed maintenance dose may have no need to withdraw. For many people this medicine is essential to function in a normal manner.
They did discuss doctors over-prescribing these drugs and not doing proper follow-up. Their presentation of the medical community is quite accurate in regard to the "corporate doctor" situation we see so much today.
The young blonde who took a regulated dosage of Xanax daily due to serious panic attacks and properly balanced her life with that dosage-- that is more what the drug is intended for. Again, they touched on but didn't even name PTSD-- a condition which is more common than most people realize, and which may absolutely require treatment with such drugs for the person to even survive. When the brain is totally out of sync with their body, heart, lungs and hormones, Clonazepam (another form of Xanax) is almost a miracle cure for such people-- and taking it is not an "option" if they want to live a normal life.
Largely this film just touches the surface of issues but doesn't really establish anything. At the end, viewers are left knowing no more about the drug, its benefits, its dangers, and proper administration or use than they did when the documentary began. It's an hour and a half of non-accomplishment in which they discuss a wide variety of viewpoints, with no real solutions or even suggestions. Oh, except smoke weed. That can be a viable alternative.
This is basically a non-helpful, uninformative non-documentary. A person can learn more by simply browsing the Internet and reading about Xanax. The only thing to take away from this is the obvious: Don't take Xanax recreationally or in excess. Don't "get hooked" on it. That's for those of us who need that "duh" kind of information.
They did try to show a motley group of people with different experiences with the drug. The results ranged from great success to driving a person to suicide.
It seems the person who fared the best was the woman who tries to take it ONLY a few times a month when she is feeling at her worst.
What I didn't like was offering SSRIs as an alternative. I took Paxil for a while and the side effects were unbearable and getting off them was no picnic. They might not be technically addictive but you cannot stop cold turkey.
A few of the people they profiled were unbelievably IRRITATING. You couldn't help but wonder of THAT was their real problem in life.
My sympathies to anyone dealing with depression and anxiety. The world is a tough place for anyone intelligent and sensitive. Now if we could really make the world an easier place, we wouldn't have to dope ourselves, would we?
It seems the person who fared the best was the woman who tries to take it ONLY a few times a month when she is feeling at her worst.
What I didn't like was offering SSRIs as an alternative. I took Paxil for a while and the side effects were unbearable and getting off them was no picnic. They might not be technically addictive but you cannot stop cold turkey.
A few of the people they profiled were unbelievably IRRITATING. You couldn't help but wonder of THAT was their real problem in life.
My sympathies to anyone dealing with depression and anxiety. The world is a tough place for anyone intelligent and sensitive. Now if we could really make the world an easier place, we wouldn't have to dope ourselves, would we?
Well balanced history and overview of Xanax, the pros and the cons. I'm unclear why so many reviewers are angry about this. It in no way villifies benzos or patients. The stories / case studies represented a broad demographic of patients. The clinicians from the mental health community were very careful and succinct in their language. The only segment discussed that did not fare well was the medical community (regarding the patient who was misdiagnosed at Mayo Clinic). It doesnt go terribly deep but it does cover a lot in an hour. I also appreciated the history of anxiety treatment as well as the advertising that was discussed.
So, it starts out by saying we live in a society where everyone thinks they can solve all their problems by taking a pill. Then towards the end it says " Oh, dont take that pill. Take this one" You cant make this stuff up. Did I just watch a commercial for Lexapro, Celexa and Prozac? Because that's exactly what it felt like. And then the hypocritical " Therapist " Start yamming away at how bad Xanax is when they are the ones who prescribed it to begin with . If they were such great therapist their patients wouldnt need drugs to begin with. This is simply a hit piece paid for by the makers of the other drugs.
This documentary has the message of a '90s after school special. I expected to see Nancy Regan as the director in the credits. As just one example of the blind fear-mongering and rejection of science advancements that can truly help people and change their lives for their better, this documentary conflates SSRIs with BENZOS. Those are two entirely separate drugs with significantly different risk factors. SSRIs like Zoloft have been life saviors for countless people with no side effects. These are the same people who were forced to suffer in silence for decades unnecessarily because of tragic messages like this documentary.
Meilleurs choix
Connectez-vous pour évaluer et suivre la liste de favoris afin de recevoir des recommandations personnalisées
- How long is Take Your Pills: Xanax?Alimenté par Alexa
Détails
- Durée
- 1h 19min(79 min)
- Couleur
Contribuer à cette page
Suggérer une modification ou ajouter du contenu manquant