To be perfectly honest, this feels like a hard sell. I love cats more than my own life; that's what drew me in to 'The cat,' or 'Goyang-i: Jug-eum-eulboneun dugaeuinun' - and when all is said and done it may be the best thing the movie has going for it. At the same time, there's a lot of imagery of dead animals, or animal cruelty or neglect, and there's a lingering question in my mind as to how some scenes were filmed. Cats don't growl, hiss, or pin their ears back out of fear or agitation without provocation; I can only hope instances of cats in this state were simply very advanced CGI, and not the result of abuse to capture a shot. The line of text "no cats were harmed in the making of this film," that begins the end credits, isn't sufficiently reassuring.
Equally troubling, and arguably more substantially, much more so than not this feels like a very conventional and unremarkable horror flick. We get jump scares, grotesque makeup work, creepy and unnatural presences or movement, sometimes questionable special effects, and a protagonist with a troubled past and a personality trait that puts her at a disadvantage. As I watched I kept hoping for something to leap out and be more grabbing and deserving of my attention, but I'm sad to say this just doesn't really make a big impression.
Sure, 'The cat' is well made. The direction is fine, and lighting, cinematography, sound design, shot composition, acting (in purely common genre roles), sound design, blood and gore, and so on. The writing is broadly serviceable. Only - excise the further feline factor, and there's nothing about this to let it stand out in a crowd. There's no meaningful suspense, or thrills, or fright, and the best this feature can actually inspire is mild unease. Love them or hate them, horror movies should elicit a visceral reaction from audiences, or heightened feelings. 'The cat' does not. So what, then, is its worth?
There may be one thing: I do quite like the core of the plot, the underpinnings of the course of events that are revealed in the last third or so of the runtime. While protagonist So-yeon's anxieties fit too neatly into the course of events, feeling contrived, there are some good ideas here. Why, though played off with a very different tone, there's a similar theme to outstanding 1977 horror anthology 'The uncanny.' 'The cat' could have been a suitably compelling horror-thriller as it presents, with a terribly sad, tragic beat at its center. But it's clear that from every angle the production was geared toward being a straightforward fear factory, and in that capacity it's just too ordinary to work.
This isn't outright bad. There was definite potential. Yet as a horror film it's just too common to be noteworthy, let alone frightful as is intended, and though it's the emphasis of the story, the animal cruelty on display is far too prevalent and graphic to sit well with me. I don't altogether dislike 'The cat,' but it doesn't succeed in its goal, and is too unsavory to otherwise enjoy.
Not truly bad. Not really recommendable.
