Outcasts

I just watched the first two episodes on playback. you're all spot on. It really is utter tripe. I agree that there was a certain schadenfreude to be had from laughing AT it, well in episode one anyway. By episode two the joke had run dry and I was just bored. I mean where do you start with this tripe?

The actors are terrible. Even the good ones. In fairness how do you act clumsy and bungling lines of dialogue like "Your baby is very ill.. and if it doesn't get better soon... it's going to die" The rest is just meaningless techno drivel and insulting exposition.

On top of the incompetent script writer, the director is obviously inept too. He seems to have given them all the same subtext note before each scene "Remember you have a migraine and its pissing you off, action!" oh except for Hermione Norris who had an extra instruction of "Hermione you can smell burning s**t, action!" and Liam Cunningham who had the note "Liam you just really would rather be sleeping, you are so tired and bored oh and don't forget the migraine, action!"

I laughed out loud in the scene with the president (of what? the whole planet? or that bunker?) he is just stood in a corridor with his arms folded, and some faceless other character giving him a hard time, and he says "Look I haven't got time for these questions, okay!".. err you're just stood in an empty corridor staring at a wall, mate... Again the constant stream of feckless moments like this are not the actors fault. This is shoddy directing pure and simple. If you have a character saying he's busy, then you make him look busy!! Jesus! It's not brain surgery!!

other than two old timers looking very much like they have realised they are damaging their reputations every minute this c**p on screen, the rest of the 'younger' cast are just bottom of the barrel Hollyoaks and Holby City quality actors who are just happy to have a job on telly. They don't have the slightest idea how to deliver a performance for a genre piece like this.

The biggest problem of all though and the one that will bury this show is

THERE ISN'T A SINGLE LIKABLE CHARACTER... NOT ONE!

You literal despise every one of them and want them to die, know its worse, you DON'T CARE whether they live or die or not!

This is a rookie mistake for drama. Every good writer and director knows you need to root for at least one of the characters.

Where are the standards at the BBC now? is there anyone working there who has any experience in delivering quality drama? or is it just university graduates with a masters in accounting and media? you could weep to think about the salary of the person who commissioned this amateur hour mess

I really enjoyed this series and was rather surprised, and a little disappointed, to find out that the BBC has decided not to make a second series. It is particularly annoying when a series develops an unresolved theme and then is canceled, without the story coming to a full conclusion. You feel rather cheated! I noted (elsewhere) the comments of the writer - to the effect that the series took a while to develop its storyline. I tend to agree and feel that the decisions to firstly move it to a late night time slot (in the UK - not in Australia) and then to can it completely, were both premature and self-serving. I hope there is some consideration made to making another series, or at the very least a one-off episode to bring series one to a full conclusion.

After a friend of mine suggested I watch this, I decided to play catch-up on BBC iplayer a few weeks ago. The first 15 minutes of it and I thought "OMG - this is like an updated Blake's 7 I can't watch this!!" Recently the same friend complained I hadn't given it a chance and told me it was "getting good". So I gave it another go ... I thought "I'm gonna sit through this and REALLY try to like it".

Okay - the first episode was PAINFUL. The characters seemed boring, the kid that kept repeating his "tiger tiger" poem almost put me off watching ... but I struggled through. First episode felt very long. However I persevered and watched a second episode ... then a third ... then a fourth ...

It's actually turning out to be quite interesting in certain respects but doesn't have me completely hooked as yet.

I think the characters could be improved - they are currently REALLY difficult to warm to - they have no spark. They feel a bit like cardboard cut-outs at the moment, stilted and awkward - and certainly need a bit more depth.

Looking past the stilted characters are the predictable character relationships ... just a bit boring and uninspiring - again no SPARK.

The story is somewhat intriguing in parts but with the lack of charismatic characters or interesting dialogue it just makes it difficult to wade through.

The jury is still hung for me on this.

This show COULD be better, but needs a whole lot of fine-tuning if it ever wants to become a really good show.

I don't normally write reviews but I was compelled to do so for this series in light of many of the general downbeat comments. I have to say that I am enjoying this show. Like anything new, I believe it is important to give it a chance and by the third episode I was finding it to be quite a good series, for what it is - light evening entertainment. It's filled with plot holes and the characterisation is a little light, but when you have an 8 episode series character development probably isn't going to be a major factor of a show, particularly in action dominated sci-fi. The concept is interesting, and hopefully more questions about what happened on earth and why there is no military presence in the colony will be answered over the series. The acting is good, as are the set pieces and most of the FX, particularly in episode 3. Script wise it is at times a little clunky but I think the actors have done a respectable job with what they have to work with.

A note now on all the "one star" reviews. Writing a negative review and brandishing one star ratings is unfortunately a way for people to excercise a little bit of the power that is lacking in their life. I do not believe this series is a one star show, but that is my opinion. I think people can state if they truly feel something is poor without resorting to some of the vindictive things being said here. No one deliberately sets out to make a bad show just to ruin your day. Many people have worked very hard on this series (and no I am not one of them or affiliated with anybody involved). Ultimately it is about entertainment, and if people do not like it, don't watch it. Why waste your time writing such horrid things. There are zillions of channels to choose from now. Often the comments people write online are things they would never dare say to someones face, and are a complete overeaction to what is in reality just a TV show. All that negative energy could be channelled into something much more constructive.

So, soldier on Outcasts. I for one am enjoying the ride, and grateful to the BBC for trying something new in sci-fi.

OK, so I've read some negative comments from a lot of you guys but I think this series has so much potential. Just give it a chance!

I live in Cape town, the series was filmed about an hour away from where I live and I think they have made an amazing effort so far, it's only the 4th episode and I want more!

I agree that there is much more scum on TV at the moment that shouldn't be there, but seriously, I'd love to see where this series will go in the future. Characters are interesting and I honestly want to see what happened with the AC's. I think so far episode 4 has been the most intense, with action and suspense and all that goes alongside a good sci-fi.