Le secret de Chanda

(2011) Life, Above All/ Le secret de Chanda (In South Africa with English subtitles) DRAMA

At the first few minutes has 12 year old Chanda (Khomotso Manyaka) picking a coffin for her baby sister. We don't know how she had died, except to say that deaths over there are a common occurrence. She later finds out that her worthless step dad stole money so that he can drink more, intended for the coffin, forcing Chanda to go and take the money back. After burying her baby sister, the movie then dwells on Chanda having to take care of her mother without viewers understanding what she's diagnosed with, with critics I've read, saying that her mother's contacted the aids epidemic. As a result of her mother suffering of something created a rift within her neighbors eager to drive her away. In this movie, we also get to witness, rituals practiced if people can't afford medicine, treatment or proper health care. There's also zero criticism about how it's gov't treats it's own people. Many of the things shown on this movie are absolutely nothing new to anyone who keeps up with the news, since much of what's shown here are usually shown in documentaries and whatnot. Why watch the movie one may ask, it is to say that nothing's still being done about anything and that children should not have to carry this kind of responsibility when it's the governments job.

Le secret de Chanda (2010) The South African/German film Le secret de Chanda was shown in the U.S. with the title, Life, Above All (2010). It was co-written and directed by Oliver Schmitz.

The movie stars Khomotso Manyaka as Chanda, a young woman trying to hold her own in a South African township. Her father is dead, her stepfather is feckless, her mother is sick, and she has two half-siblings about whom she worries.

Manyaka is a brilliant actor. Without a superb performance from her, the film could not have been so successful. Her role--and her skill--reminded me of Jennifer Lawrence in Winter's Bone. She's beset on all sides, but she refuses to give up.

Many of Chanda's problems arise from the fact that saving face is more important than almost anything else.

We saw this movie at Rochester's wonderful Dryden Theatre in the George Eastman Museum. It will work well on the small screen as well. It's a great movie-don't miss it!

It takes quite a while for the central conflict (and hence themes) to emerge in this story of a 12-year old African girl and her family. For a while, it seems to be one of those movies in which the protagonist is challenged by a series of apparently unrelated hardships -- misery for its own sake -- and hence it touches the viewer less than it might. Once the story takes shape, though, it becomes very powerful. It is absolutely worth experiencing the seemingly episodic first half to get to the film's payoff. Recommended, and highly so if you are interested (as I am) in the struggle between the rational, modern worldview and the religious. (7/10 for me, means B+, highly recommended).

The world celebrated the end of apartheid in South Africa in the early 1990s. Unfortunately, many of the problems created by the system of institutionalized racism persist to this day. "Le secret de Chanda" ("Life, Above All" in English) gives us an example. The movie reminded me of a book that my fifth grade class read about a pair of black South African children having to travel to Johannesburg during apartheid. Here we see the difficulties faced by the country's black population all these years after the racist laws got repealed.*

Spoken mostly in Northern Sotho and filmed mostly with a handheld camera, this movie tests your attention span. In my opinion, that's an extra incentive to see it. After all, how often do you get to see the day-to-day lives of people anywhere in Africa? It might not give you a full insight into the lives of most South Africans, but it's a start.

*In his autobiography "Born a Crime", Trevor Noah noted that the establishment of apartheid in 1948 merely codified what was already the status quo

This movie should be compulsory viewing for all budding film students. In fact all film makers, everywhere, should be locked in a small, locked room, strapped down and forced to watch this. For in the hour and a half it takes to watch this movie you will learn more about what movie making is truly all about. Here is a movie with a heart, a soul and perhaps most importantly, a point. It will rip your heart apart and along the way make you feel infinitely guilty that you have the couple of bucks to rent this movie, let alone enough money to own a television set to watch it on. Yet this is not the "message" this is simply a consequence of telling a real life story, of people with nothing and who just get on with life. It is indictment on the human race that we live in such inequitable times, yet again, that is not the message, just the backdrop. The actors in this movie are simply magnificent. Not only is the "lead" actor who plays Chanda stunningly good but also those who play small, almost minute parts. Amongst a truly outstanding cast the young girls who play 12 year old Esther and 6 year oldish Iris are simply phenomenal, these tiny children conveying more in a smile or the tiniest wrinkle of their faces than a veteran actor of 60 years. How they even understood what they had to do amazes me, how they actually did it astounds me.

This is a "simple" story but then again the best things in life are simple. This is a movie mostly about humanity, and sometimes about the lack of humanity. It is about personal strength, about love, about the triumph (at least in this case) of compassion over everything the world can throw at you. OK, 100,000 movies have already been made about this stuff, and 100,000 more are still to be made. But this one actually works. See it and be amazed.