NOTE IMDb
6,3/10
4,4 k
MA NOTE
Ce portrait cinématographique d'une crise humanitaire montante raconte les histoires poignantes de sans-abri sur la côte ouest des États-Unis.Ce portrait cinématographique d'une crise humanitaire montante raconte les histoires poignantes de sans-abri sur la côte ouest des États-Unis.Ce portrait cinématographique d'une crise humanitaire montante raconte les histoires poignantes de sans-abri sur la côte ouest des États-Unis.
- Nommé pour 1 Oscar
- 1 nomination au total
Avis à la une
" In the darkness before the dawn
In the swirling of this storm
When I'm rolling with the punches and hope is gone
Leave a light, a light on..."
- Coldplay's Midnight
This a very serious topic that I was very happy to see someone made a documentary on. However, it was a really terrible "film." It's like someone got a drone and a right to some good music, and made a 40 minute trailer/montage.
It was so disjointed with zero depth. They even had some great stories in front of them, but didn't follow any of them in any coherent way. What's worse, there was zero exploration of the causes or what can be done.
It was like a trailer for a more in depth documentary series where they dive into the situation, but there isn't a series. It's just this. I genuinely don't know if this helps or hurts the problem of homelessness.
It was so disjointed with zero depth. They even had some great stories in front of them, but didn't follow any of them in any coherent way. What's worse, there was zero exploration of the causes or what can be done.
It was like a trailer for a more in depth documentary series where they dive into the situation, but there isn't a series. It's just this. I genuinely don't know if this helps or hurts the problem of homelessness.
This was an interesting look into homelessness. It doesn't glamorise or glorify it. It shows it's hard and cruel. Once again it shows that people are just people and that bad things happen to anyone.
It humanises them.
It humanises them.
Other reviewers criticised the lack of depth or storytelling. For me, that was the beauty of this documentary. It was an honest example of the huge difficulty that faces people who are homeless, and the community workers trying to provide support. Solutions are rarely easy and we are often left with many questions to be answered and unmet needs. Perhaps those who didn't like the doco were left feeling like the situation wasn't resolved. Perhaps that was the point. An extra 20 minutes sharing the interviewees solutions to the crisis would have made it a 10.
Way too short this is basically one interview and a little to no follow up on any of the homeless. This is just an "art" piece done in haste. You see better documentaries about homeless on youtube.
Le saviez-vous
- ConnexionsFeatured in Subject (2022)
- Bandes originalesMidnight
Written by Chris Martin, Will Champion, Jon Buckland, Guy Berryman and Jon Hopkins
Performed by Coldplay
Meilleurs choix
Connectez-vous pour évaluer et suivre la liste de favoris afin de recevoir des recommandations personnalisées
Détails
Contribuer à cette page
Suggérer une modification ou ajouter du contenu manquant
Lacune principale
What was the official certification given to Des vies sans toit (2021) in Japan?
Répondre