Fellow Travelers

At 81 years old (born 1942) I'm younger than the characters portrayed (a WW II vet in 1950's to '80's) - but can relate. In 1954, with the Army-McCarthy hearings being broadcast on all 3 networks (that's all we had in those days) at 12 yrs. Old, the young question is - "why are we fighting amongst ourselves " and why can't we get regular programming? (and "why are they after me ?"- even then I knew I wasn't attracted to the opposite sex). So - many years later -having survived, thru those years that you could be arrested for being gay - until now - and having Matt Bomer and Jonathan Bailey bring to life those years - well - that's extraordinary. Thank you! You can quibble about production values, acting (all great), factual accuracy (and I did), but overall - it was great. I've seen all episodes - some good, some great (2nd to last) - wow. Thanks Matt Bomer (always loved you since "Chuck" and especially "White Collar") - but I also have a new love - Jonathan Bailey. Let's have some wine.

Amazing story which reminded me of my youth in the 1960s and onwards through a military career (don't ask don't tell) and 17 years in a corporate job always hiding my sexual identity. Fellow Travelers could have been written by me. I lived through all the drama, aids, loves...what in incredible telling of history: the sadness and fear in the gay culture because of aids and the government's refusal to recognize it! This drama goes behind the scenes to show the real stories behind the headlines of that period in American History which caused so many to suffer and be treated as lepers, outcasts, not worthy of being Americans.

I'm a straight female who resides in an area with a very small LBGQ population. I do not have much exposure to gay culture, but I do believe in to each their own. I have always been a fan of Matt Bomer so I tuned in for him. I did not expect to become so invested and overwhelmed with their love story. The story was very compellingly and extremely well acted. I didn't particular like Hawk or Marcus as people, but they were brilliantly portrayed. Tim (Skippy) absolutely broke my heart. I have to say, I was initially a little shocked by the explicit sex scenes, but it wasn't anything worse than what I've seen between heterosexual couples on series like Sparticus, GOT, etc. This is definetly one of the most impactful series I've seen in awhile.

My Review - Fellow Travelers Streaming on Paramount My Rating 9/10

It's so encouraging when quality stories of our LGBTQ history like this screen adaptation of Thomas Mallon's highly acclaimed novel Fellow Travellers are transferred to the screen with great skill and integrity.

This is an impressive 8part series produced with great style and sensitivity.

Impressive performances from the entire ensemble cast plus memorable and intimate performances from the 2 main stars Matt Bomer and Jonathan Bailey who play the lovers Hawk Fuller and Tim Laughlin.

Matt and Jonathan certainly got to know each other on this television project but raunchy as some of their lovemaking scenes are they are crucial to show the passion of their on again off again romance that lasted over three decades . This story begins in the 1950's McCarthy witch hunt era that included hunting out closeted homosexuals or sexual subversives as they were referred to back then when monsters like Joel McCarthy, Roy Cohen and J Edgar Hoover caused many a gay man to live lives of desperate and misery that often lead to suicide .

Enter the handsome Washington Department official Hawkins Fuller or Hawk who frequents the underground gay bars of the city for brief sexual liaisons to satisfy his true nature .

The charismatic Hawk is a master of the art of concealing his sexuality even managing to fake a lie detector test in an effort to hold on to and advance his political career.

He meets young eager Timothy Laughlin, a recent Fordham graduate and devout Catholic eager to join the crusade against Communism.

Their passionate encounters lead to Tim's first job in D. C. and his first love affair.

As the climate and pressure in Washington hots up it becomes clear to Hawk that he can have his cake and eat it if he does the expected thing and find a suitable bride.

He marries the very eligible Lucy Smith played by Allison Williams they have what looks like the ideal Washington marriage with children a fabulous lifestyle and a country house . Hawk eventually distances himself from Tim or Skippy as he calls him by his Pet name and goes back to brief occasional encounters.

We then travel forward and back through each episode to observe what has happened over the years to the two lovers .

First to 1986 SanFrancisco where AIDS is ravaging the city and its gay population. Hawk when finding out that Tim who is now an activist and Social Worker is ill wants to be by his side and his wife Lucy who over the years finds out the truth about her husband reluctantly gives him her blessing to go as she knows by then the true nature of her husband.

We see through snapshots of the earlier years like 1968 when Tim who is now an anti war protester then decides to join the priesthood and while on the run from the authorities reconnects up with Hawk needless to say he doesn't become a priest.

Then forward to 1979 when their passion reunites on Fire Island as Hawk takes Tim on a tour of the Gay Paradise .

I really felt that this series was very similar in its emotional intensity and intent to the 1973 movie The Way We Were.

Executive Producer Matt Bomer delivers a career defining performance as Hawk in a series that was obviously a labour of love for him and it deserves to be seen by all audiences over 18 would suggest .

I watched it drip fed over 8 weeks and can't wait to binge watch it now that all 8 episodes are available.

Each of the 4 Directors Uta Briesewitz, Destiny Ekaragha, James Kent and Daniel Minahan have skilfully bought Fellow Travellers to the screen.

Fellow Travelers isn't for those who know nothing about history nor much about the struggle and plight of gay men in the several eras this book-to-screen adaptation recounts. I mention this because I've seen some comments berating the creators for showing the power imbalance between the two leads and it's generally coming from people who were born into a world where it wasn't illegal to be gay, the world they arrived in was one where LGBT equality was at the fore and gay marriage was starting to become legal in many countries around the world, coupled with the introduction of anti-discrimination laws in the workplace and hate crime laws in many modern societies.

So, for those people who don't get this story about the paranoia and hatred stemming from a government of the day, a government steeped in the mire of a cold war and itself paranoid beyond reason, it's principally because they are shocked and expect every gay story to be like Heartstopper or Red, White and Royal Blue, both very enjoyable in their own right, but equally unrealistic and cuddly.

For my part, I like the cuddly stories but I also like the grit, and Fellow Travelers has plenty of grit: from the underground gay-scene to the dom-sub dynamic between the two leading men and then on to the paranoia of McCarthy-ism and the horrendous persecution and witch-hunts of gay men and all that that entailed. Then onwards through the 60's and 70's it goes to the height of the AIDS crisis in the late 80's, spanning the lives of the cast and the struggles of being gay at that time, and is it no wonder that the shying flowers who've never had those same struggles believe it's made up or inappropriate to convey. Well, I have news for them, that was the harsh reality even if they don't want to believe it.

It's a reality that's conveyed so very well in Fellow Travelers, with lavish production values from sets to costume and script. To top it all, we get to see two actual out gay actors give amazing performances and I must say that there is a realism to the sex scenes and an animalistic intensity which I don't believe two straight actors could quite achieve so convincingly. Although it shouldn't matter, if an actor is good, wheter he's gay or not and I've not seen love making as convincing since Free Fall, the German gay film, and that was a straight cast as far as I know. Nevertheless, there's something special going on between Matt Bomer and Jonathan Bailey in Fellow Travelers and perhaps it's the fact that we know they're both gay men that helps us to buy into it more.

Amid other reviews here taking of ratings bombing and social media with various moaners who want cuddly stories I felt the need to write a review and point out that this production and story is top notch, it's special and it's a rarity to find two out gay men playing two gay characters in a serious drama.

This is without question, one time where it would be very remiss to believe any of the reviews, including this one, and just simply make up your own minds after watching this outstanding show. If you like it, it deserves your support, if you don't, please remember that there was a time when a story like this one wouldn't even be considered for production and it is books that have made these TV series possible. More importantly it's about remembering the persecution and then writing about it, it's those stories that have liberated gay men to the extent that they now have the luxury of watching themselves, and lives which went before, portrayed on screen by two out gay actors. That alone is remarkable. If we want more real gay stories, the equation is simple: lend your support, it will be rewarded by a great story and excellent acting such as that of Fellow Travelers.