Chekhov's and Shakhnazarov's mental institution
Karen Shakhnazarov's "Palata No. 6" ("Ward No. 6" in English) is an adaptation of an Anton Chekhov story. Having never read Chekhov's story, I can only comment on the movie. At first I was reminded of Christopher Guest's mockumentaries, as the characters describe their predicaments (filmed in a naturalistic style). But then the story begins, as one of the doctors begins to question his profession. To be certain, what this movie portrays is no laughing matter.
The movie might seem slow to some viewers. It's like that for a reason. It gives the patient time to explain his philosophy to the doctor. The movie poses the question of which people can be considered insane in a rotten-to-the-core society (much like how "A Clockwork Orange" does). Most of the movie takes place indoors, emphasizing the feeling of imprisonment.
I don't know that I would call it a masterpiece, but it's worth seeing. It not only addresses the issue of insanity, but also shows the horrible conditions in the mental institutions. I'd say that it was the right choice for Russia's submission to the Academy Awards that year.
The movie might seem slow to some viewers. It's like that for a reason. It gives the patient time to explain his philosophy to the doctor. The movie poses the question of which people can be considered insane in a rotten-to-the-core society (much like how "A Clockwork Orange" does). Most of the movie takes place indoors, emphasizing the feeling of imprisonment.
I don't know that I would call it a masterpiece, but it's worth seeing. It not only addresses the issue of insanity, but also shows the horrible conditions in the mental institutions. I'd say that it was the right choice for Russia's submission to the Academy Awards that year.
- lee_eisenberg
- 11 janv. 2017