Avis des utilisateurs

The Sharpe series is a very enjoyable piece of historical fiction. Sean Bean is excellent as Sharpe. He is one of the finest actors of modern times. Everything he is in is great. His great strength is portraying flawed (and very human) characters either heroic or evil. The other actors in the show are also very good- with some going on to greater fame.

The stories range from very good and gripping to the somewhat silly but even the worst will keep you watching. The best part of the show is the dialog and the interactions between the characters. The worst is the combat action which is quite laughable in some instances ( with the classic pick up the enemy soldier and toss him over your shoulder scene). Everyone is killed, few are wounded except our heroes.

Also particularly annoying is the two main characters, Sharpe and Harper constantly running around outdoors with out some form of headgear. At that time, a man was considered indecent and in a state of undress to be out of doors with his head uncovered. Most of the other characters follow this convention, so I'm not quite sure why this is the case with Sharpe and Harper.

But overall a enjoyable and fun " guys soap opera" as the wife of my best friend calls it.

Something awesome to follow the leader of a small bataillon of men during Napoleonic war, Sharpie charismatic and physical lead representation by Sean Bean with a perfectly cast support that grow as each episode progress.

The soundtrack is well appropriate, the vilains are nasties, many outdoor scenes, it accomplished well under its budgets i presume.

I guess this is a series about valors, dramatic, some social classes and geographic commentaries. Advemtures and mortal dangers, outdoor locations, and decent soundtrack.

This and Horatio Hornblower are totally well cast and well preesented with good soundtrack and operatic at time sutuations.

Maybe more of a guy men type of series.

Fantastic tale of a sgt rising through the ranks whilst being gritty and heart warming.

Watching in 2021, this is just an amazing film series. The movie, or long episode, series type used in the UK is king. Many web-based shows are using this method nowadays. A method that hasn't been used much in the US. The old Stephen King (and others) "made for tv" series types shows, many times based on books Sharpe's Rifles is an amazing example of such. The acting is great, history is great, and just enough action. This is a hard 8-10 rating show. I'm happy tp have come across it.

Bernard Cornwell is my favorite writer of historical fiction. He does meticulous research and gives a sense of time and place, but also never forgets to tell a rip-roaring good story. The 20-plus Richard Sharpe series is his masterwork - a land-based counterpart to the naval stories of C. F. Forester and Patrick O'Brian. This series of sixteen feature length TV movies simplifies the Sharpe saga somewhat but lovingly recreates its major plotlines and characters. You don't have to read the books to enjoy the series, but readers will appreciate some of the detail even more. The casting is mostly spot-on, with Sean Bean near perfect in the title role.

(In fact, Sean Bean is so perfect that I was surprised to learn that Richard E. Grant was originally cast in the role and that Bean was a last minute replacement after Grant injured himself. From what I have seen of Grant, he is pretty good but I think Bean turned out to be a much better choice for Sharpe.)

The entire series is now streaming on Britbox, which at seven bucks a month is a treasure-trove of classic and contemporary British TV. Do what I did and drop that 14 buck Netflix in favor of Britbox - if you love British TV you won't be sorry. Be aware that not all of the Britbox offerings show up on the menu on your smart TV. You have to drill down a bit in the website and click the "see all" buttons to see everything.

I saw a couple of the early Sharpe films on DVD years ago, and they were in 4:3 ratio. However, the versions streaming on Britbox are all in 1:33 widescreen and don't appear to me to be cropped. So I am assuming they were filmed in widescreen and cropped to 4:3 for broadcast back in the nineties before widescreen TVs were common. In any case, the versions streaming on Britbox look teriffic and have optional English subtitles which may help you follow the characters and plotlines.

Long before Alec Trevelyan, Boromir or Ned Stark it was the role of Richard Sharpe that made Sean Bean famous. In recent years Bean's portrayal of Sharpe has unfortunately been largely forgotten and overshadowed by his later roles which is unfortunate because it is arguably one of the greatest roles of his career.

Sharpe is based on the book series of the same name by Bernard Cornwell and just like the books, the show tells the story of the fictional working class British rifleman as he fights in the Napoleonic Wars, rising in the ranks and facing off against his prejudiced superiors.

Despite being produced on a 90s British TV budget, the show is beautifully shot on location in Ukraine and manages to feel cinematic in places, though if you're expecting to see epic large scale battles then you will be left disappointed.

Where the show really shines is in it's excellent cast of actors. In addition to Sean Bean as Sharpe, there is Daragh O'Malley as Sharpe's patriotic Irish right hand man Patrick Harper, Jason Salkey as well spoken bookworm Harris and John Tams as singing sharpshooter Hagman making up the supporting cast. The show also has a revolving guest cast of top tier British acting talent, some of whom were unknowns at the time but would later go on to have illustrious careers of their own, including Brian Cox, Daniel Craig, Pete Postlethwaite, Mark Strong, Philip Glenister, Douglas Henshall and Paul Bettany to name a few.

Some stories are noticeably weaker than others (most notably Sharpe's Honour and Sharpe's Gold) but overall Sharpe is a very strong series with great acting and writing despite the budgetary limitations of the time and is definitely worth checking out if only to see Sean Bean shine in this forgotten early role.

During the Peninsular War Sergeant Richard Sharpe is promoted to Lieutenant after saving the Duke of Wellington's life. He is given command of a squad of riflemen, the best shots in the army. He soon earns a reputation for being the man to entrust a dangerous mission to and Wellington regularly finds tasks for him.

An excellent war-drama series. Based on the novels by Bernard Cornwell and starring Sean Bean as Sharpe, this is as a series of rollicking adventures, often set against the background of actual historic battles in the Peninsular War.

Not perfect: the action scenes can be a bit gung ho at times and the plots aren't always 100% plausible. This is more than made up for by the sheer pace and momentum of each episode and the solid performances from the cast.

Sean Bean IS Richard Sharpe, the British rifleman whose career mirrors that of Sir Arthur Wellesley, the Duke of Wellington through the British campaigns in Europe against the French forces under Emperor Napoleon Bonaparte.

Even though Bernard Cornell originally had his most famous character sporting black hair, I personally can't read Sharpe and not think of Sean Bean. That's how well he owned the role. Same with Daragh O'Malley as Sharpe's constant companion, the big Irishman Patrick Harper.

All but the last two instalments in this series were based on Cornwell's books, and even Sharpe's Challenge, the penultimate TV movie, was loosely based around Cornwall's trio of books where Sharpe is in India. I only wish these had been big screen productions, with a larger budget for extras and such. As good as the ITV production is - and it is very, very good - it could have been better with larger battle scenes.

That said, there is great Napoleonic action in each episode, and brilliant acting. Hugh Fraser is sensational as Wellington, and Pete Postlethwaite as Sharpe's sworn enemy Sergeant Obadiah Hakeswill deserves special mention. A better villain, you will struggle to find. And lots of guest starring roles from famous British actors like Daniel Craig and Liz Hurley.

Amazing to go back and watch this after thirty years and see all the now famous actors at the start of their careers. Sean Bean, Daniel Craig, Brian Cox, Pete Poselthwaite, Emily Mortimer, Julian Fellowes, Mark Strong....... I could go on.

They episodes are a great watch and it is fun to follow the progress of Sharpe and his band of men through the Napoleonic War.

Has to be said that there are some problems. The scripts are quite hammy. Some of the plots are very samey. It becomes easy to see who the bad guys are, who the traitor is and guess when will Sharpe sleep with the damsel in distress in each episode whilst wondering how many times Sharpe will be injured and miraculously shrug off mortal wounds to save the day in the end.

A really great series. I've not read the books so this was my first introduction to Sharpe. Each episode is quite long but they're well paced and good fun. The villains are proper villains, treacherous, wicked and delighting in their misdeeds. Sharpe is introduced as a hard but decent man raised from the ranks, from humble beginnings, now commanding a company of loyal misfits with his right hand man ever at his side. The costumes and attention to detail are good, you can tell they filmed it abroad, most episodes are set in Spain and Portugal. The modern score works quite well, they took a brave risk including electric guitar but I was surprised how well it worked. Some of it is pretty low budget but some pretty ladies turn up luckily throughout the series for Sharpe to flirt with. A lot of the fighting is actually very brutal and real, not lots of slick acting and fast editing but generally much more realistic with men grappling, wrestling, grunting, going for a low blow. Towards the end it Sharpe starts to seem like he's blessed with nine lives. There's another interesting episode where the war is over and Sharpe is working for the local yeomanry, but his sympathies lie more with the common people than the mill owners he's paid to protect. I like this one because we get to see Sharpe out of his comfort zone while we explore the poverty of Yorkshire in the 1810s. There's also a running gap in the series about Sharpe often being mistaken for a common solider rather than an officer. Many people are astonished to discover this rough mannered low born man is in fact an officer. Many of these men though lack his battle readiness and skill. Not that Sharpe is perfect, he has a weakness for women, he sometimes struggles to control his temper and he can occasionally be quite blind about certain things.

The casting is spot on, especially Sean Bean. Themes of social class, army life and justice/injustice, betrayal, jealousy and loyalty run throughout the series.

"Review of 14 out of 16 episodes"

Sharpe is a mixed bag of adventures, but all run with themes of honour, self respect and leadership set among the smoke and violence of warfare and bravery. The overall production values vary but is frequently let down by lacklustre camerawork and poor control of lighting/colouration leading to a cheap looking production.

Sean Bean is fantastic, and out of many of the roles he has done, it feels like he enjoyed this one the most.

Daragh O'Malley gives a more stoic performance, but with the right director and writing has many amusing and passionate moments.

John Tams is wonderful and charming but has little to do and his character is largely repetitive exposition.

Jason Salkey is fantastic with warm charm followed by a great smile.

There are some weak links. Hugh Fraser is a poor Wellington, and has only one memorable scene of note, David Troughton is far more convincing. Abigail Cruttenden is overused and horribly misfitting for too many episodes. Michael Byrne is wasted as a rudimentary and bland intelligence officer, as is James Laurenson and to a less extent Brian Cox.

Many episodes have a starting problem, initially struggling to get the movie rolling in a meaningful way, and usually the middle acts are more engaging. The show struggles to interconnect each movie to its larger world building, and it's difficult to care about anyone outside of the chosen men. Sadly these issue only perpetuate as the later seasons move away into different genres.

What works better is the style and sense of humour, which creates touching, heartfelt and emotional moments. In addition the violence, blood and horror is done with respect and dignity, and they have done well in many of the episodes despite obvious budgeting issues.

" EACH EPISODE REVIEW "

Sharpe's Rifles 7 / 10

A strong start, with powerful and emotional introductions to the characters by exploring the themes of loyalty and trust. Credit to the interior shots which feature strong rays of sunshine on the actors faces.

Sharpe's Eagle 6 / 10

Although a bit slow and unwise with its pacing, intense dramatic exposition from David Troughton and Michael Cochrane brings fire, although the latter's character is a bit too vicious and cruel for me to completely adore him. The final conflict feels a bit rushed and lacks tension.

Sharpe's Company 3 / 10

Distinctively weaker and less fun, the overall direction is hampered badly by poorly conceived and sometimes repetitive dialogue. Despite a good performance Pete Postlethwaite's character is horrible to the point of vomit and the whole atmosphere has a mean and unlikeable spirit to it that isn't thrilling. 'Sharpe's Company' just isn't doing anything in a manner which is clever or followed through well. Credit to the acting chops of the remaining 'gentleman' who seem jolly but just as confused as the audience is by the sheer lack of adventure.

Sharpe's Enemy 6 / 10

Much better and more enthralling, this episode returns to tried and tested action adventure with great cinematography within the violence. In addition we have two splendid new characters portrayed by Nicholas Rowe and Philip Whitchurch whom bring a huge degree of charms and spirit to their scenes. Overall the production values create more immersion and Pete Postlethwaite is given a fantastic send off with a much cleaner and fun villain. Jeremy Child is a weak link and the female characters don't get anything massively interesting to do.

Sharpe's Honour 4 / 10

The idea behind this movie seems well intentioned but the compromise is that it requires a rather unfun and slow first couple of acts. Unfortunately the payoff is weak with a muddled and slightly confused script featuring a wonderful Matthew Scurfield who is wasted. There some exceptional scenes, one in particular being on the best in the series featuring the lead actor swinging a chicken, and a fantastic standoff scene between him and the villain played beautifully by Féodor Atkine, but a less than adequate performance from Alice Krige and a sense of mediocrity bring it down.

Sharpe's Gold 6 / 10

A thrilling and well directed episode with a thrust of adventure and some of the best landscapes of the series. The guest actors and actress all put in memorable and wonderful performances with good pacing and a chilling score with touches of horror and the macabre. The sense of companionship is strong here and the fight sequences are better realised.

Sharpe's Battle 4 / 10

A difficult and unlikeable first act paints a sour mood as Sharpe is conveyed as an unforgiving madman and Ian McNeice bumbles around the screen pointlessly as poor comic relief. The overall direction and cinematography is mundane and even has errors showing production crew. The second half is much better with a focused energy and greater sense of snap. However it's easily noticeable that sets from the first film are present and the overall reason for Sharpe's predicament is badly and meanly represented by his hierarchy. Credit to secondary cast Jason Durr for his captivating and amazing performance and to Allie Byrne for her emotionally convincing if rather uninteresting love interest.

Sharpe's Sword 8 / 10

An astonishingly good episode with masterful direction and a terrific sense of emotional gravity and grief to the violence and war. Almost every scene is deeply interesting and the language used is convincing and thoughtful. The new locations and sets are also welcome while the return of Michael Cochrane is unexpected but dutifully twisted. In particular a major credit to Daragh O'Malley whom encapsulates the best in this episode, and it is also nice to see Jason Salkey having more to do. The final fight at the end has the suffering and pain of real exhausted combat.

Sharpe's Regiment 4 / 10

A pointless and obnoxious episode that does nothing to enhance Sharpe and instead demoralises the English army as a whole. Directed clearly in a way in an attempt to have a laugh but its done too harshly and without fun or intrigue. The first act is awkward, and from there Julian Fellowes presents a truly stupid rendition of high royalty along with Michael Cochrane returning unfittingly among an already overcrowded array of unlikeable caricatures. There is some tension in the second half but overall it's just not the show we signed up for. Credit to the set and costume designers for making this episode look better than its content. The ending is unsatisfactory however and the overall payoff is weak.

Sharpe's Siege 5 / 10

Again the initial opening act is not impressive, but once the momentum begins to start the quality improves. There are a couple of really good scenes here, including good action choreography and violent dental removal. Christopher Villiers is well balanced and more believable than other officers depicted throughout the series, however there is a major annoying script issue with his character that dismisses his bravery in the second act leading to a sour and stupid ending.

Sharpe's Mission 3 / 10

Poorly written and tedious, with sloppy unprofessional editing and amateurish camera work, in addition to some bad lighting and colouring. The initial opening scene is excellent, and the feature is complimented by some great sets and props, but ultimately is wasted with an awful and stupid plot with random cuts to an overly sexualised Abigail Cruttenden and back to the bland and cliché Mark Strong. Also the creepy Warren Saire disturbs throughout with a pathetic attempt at a character for exposition.

Sharpe's Revenge 2 / 10

A trash, stupid and uninteresting story that feels copy and paste to 'Sharpe's Honour' but has no competent and original direction. Philip Whitchurch, who overcomes the bad material given to him, is the best of the returning guest actors, but the female returning cast are tacked on. The whole plot is a convulsed mess with zero believability and it is obvious they just wanted to pump out another Sharpe with minimal effort.

Sharpe's Justice 3 / 10

Misguided and woefully lacking in relevant dialogue that is meaningful to the overall story, this episode fails to make use of its fresh and interesting ideas despite some moments of realisation. The female cast return from previous movies and offer nothing of value and are even misused to construe the plot. Philip Glenister makes a tremendous effort with a great performance and steals his scenes despite awful writing. Tony Haygarth also elevates his scenes and provides the film's only emotional grounding. The costumes, new sets and cinematography are quite appealing, but only dress up a truly dull and foolish non adventure.

Sharpe's Waterloo 4 / 10

A better, more balanced and almost thrilling adventure with some great scenes and beautiful locales. The editing, particularly in the action sequences, is excellent with the most stunts in the series. In addition there are touches of great humour, particularity in the middle act. Unfortunately the writers failed to properly implement Sharpe as an important and meaningful character, and the plot becomes very muddled and unsatisfactory in its last act. Credit to Paul Bettany for his convincing and fun portrayal.

Story, adventure, action, drama. The film adaptation of a series of novels about the shooter Richard Sharpe by the English writer Bernard Cornwell. The author of this review has the honor to state that he is not familiar with the original book source, and considers the film adaptation as an independent work. Moreover, after watching the series, the desire to open the original source does not arise at all, but more on that later. The author of this review has heard many flattering words about this series, and therefore, deciding not to shelve it, he got acquainted with it with interest - and as a result, the series caused conflicting feelings. And here's a brief opinion - A good English adventure series. He had both advantages (which do him honor) and disadvantages (which sadden him). And this should end this introduction and proceed to the analysis.

So, the advantages: 1. The Adventures of Richard Sharpe - the main character of this work (the series itself and two separate paintings) is a sergeant (in the future, a colonel) Richard Sharp is a royal marksman who saved Lord Wellington's life in Spain, after which his career crept up. Throughout the series, the hero, along with loyal and devoted companions, will participate in famous battles (Waterloo, Vitoria, Talavera), will visit India, Spain, Portugal, France, England, Belgium. Richard will also participate in covert operations, protect his spies and catch enemy ones, fight duels more than once, and confront other English (and not only) officers, who are all nobles with pedigree like a poodle, and Sharpe is from the common class. The screenwriters will not forget about the personal life of the hero. Well, eroticism is present in the series, although there is not much of it, but it clearly arouses interest in watching. In fact, there is no final, but we will not be upset, I am sure of it, because what was filmed is quite enough.

2. Richard Sharp performed by Sean Bean - he is the main character, you follow his fate and career from the first to the last frame, because Richard showed a living man - he can be beaten, he can be injured, more than once he will be on the verge of death, but loyal companions and the love of beautiful ladies will save every time He's out of the clutches of death. Sharpe is straightforward, and can calmly hit an officer for insulting (for which he will be punished more than once, and even from Lord Wellington himself), he will not leave a woman in trouble, he trusts his intuition, you can take an example from him. And actor Sean Bean himself is pulling out the whole series here. Charisma, talent, confidence, the ability to keep yourself in the frame, a military uniform going to the image - it all works great here and you just have to shout "Bravo!". There are practically no such heroes in modern cinema anymore, which is sad.

3. Costumes and scenery - almost the entire series was filmed in the Russian Crimea (although at the time of filming it was not yet in our jurisdiction, but this annoying misunderstanding was corrected in 2014), which is good news, because when watching, familiar landscapes kept surfacing that could not be confused with anything. And, of course, Crimea portrayed Spain here, because the series is very budget-friendly, and it was just cheaper to shoot here. And the writer Bernard Cornwell liked it here. But the costumes were a success. And if there are some shortcomings, then they do not play a significant role against the general background. The uniform "sits" on the heroes and extras as if poured in, soldiers on the march look like soldiers on the march, deserters look like deserters, the British like the British, the French like the French, the Spaniards like the Spaniards. The weapon also looks like smoothbore muskets of the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries.

So, the disadvantages: 1. Comicality - some minor characters look and behave extremely comically, and if it looks good in a children's cartoon, then not in a serious adventure series. It's annoying, like Sergeant Obadiah. Well, I can't believe that this is a living person, and not a joke by a screenwriter.

2. The British do not miss, but everyone else does just that - that the French, that the Indians, that the bandits - in general, everyone who opposes Sharpe and the British simply have to miss and at the crucial moment, the weapon must misfire (although, by chance, they get into Sharpe too), but Sharpe and the British almost never miss. Well, what kind of nonsense is this. And it even works during battles. In short, it all looks extremely ridiculous.

3. Boring and protracted - the series is monstrously stretched and insanely boring. Especially adding here both of the above disadvantages. I do not know how the series looked in the nineties or the noughties, but now it does not represent an outstanding work - rather, it is a good series with good costumes and excellent acting by Sean Bean, Hugh Fraser as Lord Wellington, Dara O'Malley as Sergeant Harper. This is exactly what the author of this review was talking about at the very beginning, because after this boredom, the desire to read the original source does not arise. Quite the opposite - you want to keep as far away from him as possible (unlike Officer Hornblower, whose books are still waiting in the wings, as well as their film adaptations in the same time period as the filmed "Sharp") , the author of this review may have unnecessarily scolded this series, but the advantages were not forgotten. For the author of this review, the series turned out to be passing and insanely boring, but maybe for you it will turn out to be at least excellent? Judge for yourself, fellow viewers and readers.

The score is 7 out of 10. As for the recommendation, see for yourself, but history buffs should definitely rate it.

I watched the first two seasons. I thought it was engaging and well-done. I appreciated a glimpse into the history of the time. However, the story is harsh overall and difficult to watch. These kinds of shows hurt my soul. The war violence is expected, but there is also murder, sexual assault, etc. - I don't enjoy watching these things. Also, a couple scenes were too salacious for my taste.

Having said that, it appears this TV version of Sharpe might be more admirable than in the books - in the books he apparently has more of a criminal and a rogue personality. And I don't doubt the actual events were even worse in many cases than portrayed in this show.