NOTE IMDb
6,2/10
1,6 k
MA NOTE
Hong Kong est secoué par de multiples meurtres horribles, et la police forme une équipe spéciale pour enquêter. Ils apprennent que les victimes sont toutes suspectes d'affaires non résolues ... Tout lireHong Kong est secoué par de multiples meurtres horribles, et la police forme une équipe spéciale pour enquêter. Ils apprennent que les victimes sont toutes suspectes d'affaires non résolues par un personnage connu sous le nom de The SleuthHong Kong est secoué par de multiples meurtres horribles, et la police forme une équipe spéciale pour enquêter. Ils apprennent que les victimes sont toutes suspectes d'affaires non résolues par un personnage connu sous le nom de The Sleuth
- Réalisation
- Scénario
- Casting principal
- Récompenses
- 6 victoires et 28 nominations au total
Ching-Wan Lau
- Lee Chun
- (as Sean Lau)
Kevin Kam-Yin Chu
- Chu Kin Yau
- (as Kevin Chu)
Avis à la une
The storyline is good, with great level of depth as well as twists and turns. It's easy to understand and NOT confusing at all.
The pace is fast and compact! Things happen here and there to keep you going, without a sense of boredom from the beginning to the end!
An appropriate level of action was inserted to enhance the visual excitement, e.g. Gunfights and typical HK car chasing scenes. All these action sequences work well to keep the momentum going. And the clues unfolded one by one to facilitate audiences' understanding towards the cases and reasons for murders! All the main casts performed well to make it a good show!
However, two main pitfalls were picked up as follows: Firstly, the pace is far too fast that it doesn't allow the movie to breathe and the audiences to think through what is going on!
Secondly, each clue is unfolded too quickly! It should allow audiences to process each clue and piece together the puzzles to guess who is the SUSPECT! In fact, this is a psychological thriller, it should thus confuse audiences more, especially Lau Ching Wan's role with his paranoid delusion and multiple-personality disorder, and challenge our ability to unfold the clues. Yet, it's made to look more like an action movie, revealing all things abruptly!
I gave 8/ 10. Overall, it's a great movie! I would highly recommend you to watch it in the cinema, to enjoy the tension and dynamic action, which you will NEVER get from your laptop or home TV. It's definitely worth your ticket money! Take my words! Go, Go, Go..!!
The pace is fast and compact! Things happen here and there to keep you going, without a sense of boredom from the beginning to the end!
An appropriate level of action was inserted to enhance the visual excitement, e.g. Gunfights and typical HK car chasing scenes. All these action sequences work well to keep the momentum going. And the clues unfolded one by one to facilitate audiences' understanding towards the cases and reasons for murders! All the main casts performed well to make it a good show!
However, two main pitfalls were picked up as follows: Firstly, the pace is far too fast that it doesn't allow the movie to breathe and the audiences to think through what is going on!
Secondly, each clue is unfolded too quickly! It should allow audiences to process each clue and piece together the puzzles to guess who is the SUSPECT! In fact, this is a psychological thriller, it should thus confuse audiences more, especially Lau Ching Wan's role with his paranoid delusion and multiple-personality disorder, and challenge our ability to unfold the clues. Yet, it's made to look more like an action movie, revealing all things abruptly!
I gave 8/ 10. Overall, it's a great movie! I would highly recommend you to watch it in the cinema, to enjoy the tension and dynamic action, which you will NEVER get from your laptop or home TV. It's definitely worth your ticket money! Take my words! Go, Go, Go..!!
The movie sucks, and the characters talk and act like fools.
"We don't want to hurt anybody, we're just here for revenge!" What kind of criminals speak like that to calm the crowd? Maybe he should explain well on how he would like to do the revenge, by serving the enemy a massage maybe?
The movie is full of awkward paradox likewise in talks and actions, on every character, which distracts you from the story itself and make you curse.
The movie makers need to know a simple affair, that if you want to tell a detective story, just don't make it a story of idiots.
The rhythm of the story telling is chaotic too.
And the mixture of Beijing accent against mandarin amongst the actors of Hongkong and mainland makes no sense even in nowadays.
"We don't want to hurt anybody, we're just here for revenge!" What kind of criminals speak like that to calm the crowd? Maybe he should explain well on how he would like to do the revenge, by serving the enemy a massage maybe?
The movie is full of awkward paradox likewise in talks and actions, on every character, which distracts you from the story itself and make you curse.
The movie makers need to know a simple affair, that if you want to tell a detective story, just don't make it a story of idiots.
The rhythm of the story telling is chaotic too.
And the mixture of Beijing accent against mandarin amongst the actors of Hongkong and mainland makes no sense even in nowadays.
I was very into this movie for a while. The mystery is set up well and takes you on an intricate journey. Some of the action is pretty good and exciting. The lead actor gives a great performance. And I was invested in the main characters.
But the flaws killed it for me. The action becomes tedious and stale while also becoming outrageous and not believable. All the bullets miss. Early on I forgave this a couple times. But it keeps happening, and worse every time. Hundreds of bullets are shot and they keep missing.
Then you have other things like hilariously fake-looking blood spatter. Or other times when people get shot with no blood whatsoever. Or unrealistic CG fire.
I thought this was pretty good for a while and still has a lot of positives, but the negatives brought it way down for me. (1 viewing, 1/16/2023)
But the flaws killed it for me. The action becomes tedious and stale while also becoming outrageous and not believable. All the bullets miss. Early on I forgave this a couple times. But it keeps happening, and worse every time. Hundreds of bullets are shot and they keep missing.
Then you have other things like hilariously fake-looking blood spatter. Or other times when people get shot with no blood whatsoever. Or unrealistic CG fire.
I thought this was pretty good for a while and still has a lot of positives, but the negatives brought it way down for me. (1 viewing, 1/16/2023)
Instead of saying this is a detective story, it would rather be described as a creepy nonsense and full of shet talk.
The story writer focus too much on shaping a physical mad detective but completely ignore the basic reality of crime fiction presentations. For example, you would ask me to believe an female police officer would perform her job in crime scene where she have to chase, gun fight and building climbing when she is nearly at a stage of a childbirth? And you expect me to believe that Li Jun could be allowed to engage official crime investigation when he suffer severe mental health problem and risk all citizens and officers in life danger? Such nonsense just appeared all over the screen time and made people literally wonder what's going on with this movie.
Most of the character's motivations are simple, easy-predicated and some even ridiculous, which made people more easily to find that how unbelievable flat the character is. This is the kind of the story that you whish you never heard of. This is so....exhausted to watch. Once again, a new tip for myself: DO get out of it even in the middle of screening, when you find something funny is in the film. Instead of a crime fiction that you can enjoy, its more like those ridiculous Late talk show meme for spoof.
The story writer focus too much on shaping a physical mad detective but completely ignore the basic reality of crime fiction presentations. For example, you would ask me to believe an female police officer would perform her job in crime scene where she have to chase, gun fight and building climbing when she is nearly at a stage of a childbirth? And you expect me to believe that Li Jun could be allowed to engage official crime investigation when he suffer severe mental health problem and risk all citizens and officers in life danger? Such nonsense just appeared all over the screen time and made people literally wonder what's going on with this movie.
Most of the character's motivations are simple, easy-predicated and some even ridiculous, which made people more easily to find that how unbelievable flat the character is. This is the kind of the story that you whish you never heard of. This is so....exhausted to watch. Once again, a new tip for myself: DO get out of it even in the middle of screening, when you find something funny is in the film. Instead of a crime fiction that you can enjoy, its more like those ridiculous Late talk show meme for spoof.
Not a booring movie so it should be watched atleast once who likes thriller or detective story.
Story is good.
Action is ok.
Actors are good.
Character are in good set.
Just a bit too fast for Viewers who do not know Cantonese language.
The main character has fast thinking and speech is also too fast as per the story. So when you rely or have dependency on Subtitles than you loose some scene or either how the story is connected.
If possible than Viewers are advised to watch atleast in their understanding language i.e. Dubbed version.
I am sure even dubbing artist will face challenges in dubbing for the main character.
Story is good.
Action is ok.
Actors are good.
Character are in good set.
Just a bit too fast for Viewers who do not know Cantonese language.
The main character has fast thinking and speech is also too fast as per the story. So when you rely or have dependency on Subtitles than you loose some scene or either how the story is connected.
If possible than Viewers are advised to watch atleast in their understanding language i.e. Dubbed version.
I am sure even dubbing artist will face challenges in dubbing for the main character.
Le saviez-vous
- AnecdotesThe film was first announced its production in 2018 and commenced the lengthy principal photography in August that year, and finished in April 2019 due to screenplay changes by Ka-Fai Wai. The post production has undergone more than 2 years until its release in April 2022.
- ConnexionsReferenced in The Popcorn Show: "Detective vs Sleuths" Movie (2022)
Meilleurs choix
Connectez-vous pour évaluer et suivre la liste de favoris afin de recevoir des recommandations personnalisées
- How long is Detective vs. Sleuths?Alimenté par Alexa
Détails
Box-office
- Montant brut mondial
- 1 906 153 $US
- Durée
- 1h 41min(101 min)
- Couleur
- Mixage
- Rapport de forme
- 2.35 : 1
Contribuer à cette page
Suggérer une modification ou ajouter du contenu manquant