Aperçu de l'année qui a conduit à l'assassinat du Premier ministre israélien, Yitzhak Rabin, du point de vue de l'assassin.Aperçu de l'année qui a conduit à l'assassinat du Premier ministre israélien, Yitzhak Rabin, du point de vue de l'assassin.Aperçu de l'année qui a conduit à l'assassinat du Premier ministre israélien, Yitzhak Rabin, du point de vue de l'assassin.
- Réalisation
- Scénario
- Casting principal
- Récompenses
- 2 victoires et 9 nominations au total
Yehuda Nahari Halevi
- Yigal Amir
- (as Yehuda Nahari)
Amitay Yaish Ben Ousilio
- Shlomo Amir
- (as Amitai Yaish)
Hadar Cats
- Demonstrator
- (non crédité)
Avis à la une
7Nozz
Like the Kennedy assassinations, the Rabin assassination is surrounded by a lot of unanswered questions. But this dramatization adheres closely to the accepted theory of Yigal Amir as lone killer. The English-language title, "Incitement" (unlike the Hebrew title) hints at the tirelessly repeated accusations that the political right in general, and Bibi Netanyahu in particular, stirred up the deadly animus against Rabin. However, the movie makes a point of accurately showing a couple of incidents that the accusations commonly distort. It shows that a particularly nasty poster of Rabin (dressing him in an SS uniform) was distributed by agent provocateur Avishai Raviv and wasn't really a poster at all but a handbill; and it shows that a coffin carried in an anti-Oslo demonstration was not a symbol threatening Rabin with death but a symbol lamenting the supposed death of Zionism. Where the depiction does go overboard, I'd say, is in emphasizing the tacit support by the religious establishment for an attack on Rabin. Bar-Ilan University, which has a Jewish religious atmosphere but also has secular Jewish students and even Arab students, is portrayed as entirely religious and plastered with anti-Rabin posters on every wall. Rabbis are shown one after another stopping short of disapproval with respect to Amir's intention to kill Rabin.
Despite not spending important time bashing Bibi, the movie does bother at the end to grumble that when he took office, his inaugural speech didn't mention Rabin.
But how is the movie as a movie? you ask. Apart from stating its point of view on the murder (and being released in Israel half a week before an election), it doesn't seem to have much of a message. As an exercise in recreating episodes that are only 25 years old and well remembered from the news, it works well. It blends recreations with authentic footage elegantly. The filmmakers did not employ well-known actors who would have made disbelief difficult to suspend, but the actors handle their parts well. The music is spare and appropriately ominous. But if the movie breaks forth from its narrow focus to imply any larger statement about the human condition, I missed it.
Despite not spending important time bashing Bibi, the movie does bother at the end to grumble that when he took office, his inaugural speech didn't mention Rabin.
But how is the movie as a movie? you ask. Apart from stating its point of view on the murder (and being released in Israel half a week before an election), it doesn't seem to have much of a message. As an exercise in recreating episodes that are only 25 years old and well remembered from the news, it works well. It blends recreations with authentic footage elegantly. The filmmakers did not employ well-known actors who would have made disbelief difficult to suspend, but the actors handle their parts well. The music is spare and appropriately ominous. But if the movie breaks forth from its narrow focus to imply any larger statement about the human condition, I missed it.
All right, I am hot an historian and don't want to polemic about the point of views of some people who dissagree with the character. The fact is that I still learned many things about this drama, no one is spared in this story, it looks more like a 'Watch it and make your own opinion' film, wich suits me well.
But imo Neva is a casting error, she was supposed to be 'The most good looking girl in the university', come on shes ugly and with her annoying indecisive character, any smart guy would have dumped her in a second.
Good casting and pace, I recommend.
But imo Neva is a casting error, she was supposed to be 'The most good looking girl in the university', come on shes ugly and with her annoying indecisive character, any smart guy would have dumped her in a second.
Good casting and pace, I recommend.
I thought this movie was excellently well acted and directed. It was seemed very close to the truth about this disturbed individual and the events that caused him to act as he did. Having lived through this period in Israel, I came out of the theater very disturbed and upset. An important movie which the powers at the top tried to prevent larger circulation.
The world got shocked on the 4th of November, 1995, when Israeli PM Yitzhak Rabin got assassinated.* While Rabin did not set out to change the foundation of Israel's relations with the Palestinians, he nonetheless wanted to grant them some autonomy. This enraged Israel's far-right religious community, who saw him as a traitor. His assassin, Yigal Amir, came from this community.
Yaron Zilberman's "Yamim noraim" ("Incitement" in English) focuses on Amir and his radicalization. Israel's submission to the 92nd Academy Awards for Best Foreign Language Film depicts the religious establishment as the ones who drove Amir to murder Rabin, even if they didn't tell him to do so. They put up posters of Rabin depicting him as Israel's enemy. Either way, these are some scary individuals; it's almost as if they inspired the Taliban. We saw similar depictions of Obama from the far right (many of them evangelical Christians) in the US. Regardless of the religion, fundamentalists are no one to trust.
Overall, this is a fine movie. In keeping the focus on Yigal Amir, it shows his evolution from typical Orthodox person to full-on fanatic. Frightening stuff. Definitely see it.
*I was approximately the same age at that time that my parents were when JFK got assassinated. As Mark Twain put it, history doesn't always repeat itself, but sometimes it rhymes.
Yaron Zilberman's "Yamim noraim" ("Incitement" in English) focuses on Amir and his radicalization. Israel's submission to the 92nd Academy Awards for Best Foreign Language Film depicts the religious establishment as the ones who drove Amir to murder Rabin, even if they didn't tell him to do so. They put up posters of Rabin depicting him as Israel's enemy. Either way, these are some scary individuals; it's almost as if they inspired the Taliban. We saw similar depictions of Obama from the far right (many of them evangelical Christians) in the US. Regardless of the religion, fundamentalists are no one to trust.
Overall, this is a fine movie. In keeping the focus on Yigal Amir, it shows his evolution from typical Orthodox person to full-on fanatic. Frightening stuff. Definitely see it.
*I was approximately the same age at that time that my parents were when JFK got assassinated. As Mark Twain put it, history doesn't always repeat itself, but sometimes it rhymes.
10schles-1
Very well-made and difficult to watch, this film does justice to its topic. As a potential assassin Igal Amir needed only a few (but powerful) motivators to lead him to a gun and help him pull the trigger. In doing so he changed the course of history. With great restraint this film delves into both Amir and the influences around him leading eventually to the murder of Prime Minister Rabin. The direction and acting are on a very high level and anyone wishing to gain insight and learn lessons from this horrific event should invest the time in seeing this film. It provokes thought as well as feeling, thus qualifying it as an important piece of film making.
Le saviez-vous
- AnecdotesDuring the film's world premiere at the 2019 Toronto International Film Festival, the screening was stopped roughly five minutes in and the audience had to evacuate due to a security threat. The screening was resumed when it was determined that there was no longer a threat and the screening concluded without incident. An unattended backpack in the cinema was the reason for the evacuation. It had been left by someone who had gone to get popcorn.
- Citations
Yigal Amir: You people only act on desire like animals. The mind must always prevail.
Meilleurs choix
Connectez-vous pour évaluer et suivre la liste de favoris afin de recevoir des recommandations personnalisées
- How long is Incitement?Alimenté par Alexa
Détails
Box-office
- Montant brut aux États-Unis et au Canada
- 140 306 $US
- Week-end de sortie aux États-Unis et au Canada
- 22 437 $US
- 2 févr. 2020
- Montant brut mondial
- 143 159 $US
- Durée2 heures 3 minutes
- Couleur
Contribuer à cette page
Suggérer une modification ou ajouter du contenu manquant