Avis des utilisateurs

When her father falls into a coma, Heere ends her self imposed exile from her family to return and see him. She finds her sisters planning to turn off the life support machine and take over the family business. When Sharma recovers, Heree tries to make her peace but she and her white fiancée are rejected by him. Heree falls in with an old lover, Sam, while the rest of her family continue to be deceitful and manipulative behind each other's backs as secret dirty laundry is aired.

I taped this miniseries rather than watch it in two parts as I felt three hours would be an OK sit time. As it was the film surprised me because the time went quite quickly. The main reason for this was the fact that the film had quite a complex thread of relationships and characters to follow and there was never really a moment where it really dipped. The main plot is weak by itself and actually gets annoying in the way we are constantly given blurry flashbacks from Sharma. However the many other threads feed off this one and support it.

The problem sadly is that the plot has not been delivered as well as it deserved to the screen. The first thing that hit me was just how clunky the dialogue was at times. Words didn't always sound natural and too much of it was lacking a real touch or a genuineness to it. This was quite a big issue for me as the complex character issues didn't work as well when I wasn't able to accept the characters as real. Of course part of this lies with the actors but some of them are hampered by words while others just do badly. Nagra is good but her lines don't sound right out of her mouth at times. Puri has almost a cameo role in the film, but Simpson is quite awful. He has no character to speak of and simply bops round the place beaming and being so angelic and kind that I never fully understood why he and Heere had split up in the first place.

It's a shame, because the family plot had been designed quite well and was complex and interesting enough to hold me for three hours without me every really feeling like it was dull. However the dialogue is not as natural and flowing as it needed to be – it needed to convince me that these were real people, often it didn't. This may be to blame for some performances not being all that they should be, but even with this excuse they are mostly good. Not a fantastic miniseries but one with a good plot at it's core – blurry direction, flashbacks, poor dialogue and some iffy acting don't kill it but they do take a lot away.

Loved this drama. Om Puri was wonderful as usual as was my favourite Amita Dhiri. Christopher Simpson is beautiful, just a pity that they couldnt actually get an Asian Actor to play his role instead as there are quite a few promising young Asians around.