Avis des utilisateurs

This is more than a film about English Vs Germans. The nationality does not matter. Its a film about young men who have the same hopes and dreams caught up in something that is nothing to do with them.

Even though this is a cartoon I found it more moving than other films.

It allows you to get to know the characters and see how they turn from boys to men without loosing their boyish perception of life.

It also gives you an insight to the propaganda at home and albeit very brief insight of what it was like for the families at home.

In a short space of time it really takes you on a fantastic journey with a very moving conclusion.

It is 1914 and a pair of brothers are happily working on their family farm and spending spare time playing football for the village in the county league. However the war with Germany means that both sign up to fight for their country and soon find themselves in the trenches on the front line. The tension is high and the conditions are poor but for one brief moment on Christmas Day, 1914, something wonderful seems to just happen.

This animation caught my eye in the crowded TV schedule and it looked quite interesting because, although I knew about it, I have never seen or really read anything about the football "match" between the two warring sides played in no man's land. This film follows our couple of characters to the trenches, showing the family's pain as they go away, the nature of life in the trenches, the peace and ease of the match and finally the sheer bloody pointlessness of the whole thing. This is all well and good but, by aiming for a family audience (I assume) they have stayed away from the reality a bit too much and have produced something that is more about introducing children to history rather than being of greater value. This can be seen in several areas but mostly it is in the animation. It looks very like The Snowman in style – big round faces, smoothed surfaces and nice colours. This seems to feed into the story because everything is a bit like that and it reduces the emotional impact it can have. Credit for a last scene attempt at showing the horrific pointlessness of the front line but this was too little, too late.

The voice talent wasn't. The presence of Kate Winslet in the top billing is praiseworthy but she doesn't add much – she has a small role and she is asked to produce emotion from nothing (and she can't). The rest of the cast are all a bit too cheery and "chappy" and they never for once convinced me as real people. In that regard they matched the animation by being suitable for families but being too "nice" to do anything else.

Overall this is an OK way in for families but is not dark or real enough to satisfy adults being told the story. It is all a bit too nice and soft and the dark conclusion can't cover up for how bland it had been up till that point. It does still produce an emotional reaction and it does make one shake one's head and wonder if the men could get along why their superiors couldn't, but these feelings are more to do with the story being told rather than the manner of telling.