NOTE IMDb
8,6/10
2,9 k
MA NOTE
Ajouter une intrigue dans votre langueCompiled over two years, an 'on-camera oral history' of Easy Company, told by the veterans themselves. Accompanies the mini-series Band of Brothers.Compiled over two years, an 'on-camera oral history' of Easy Company, told by the veterans themselves. Accompanies the mini-series Band of Brothers.Compiled over two years, an 'on-camera oral history' of Easy Company, told by the veterans themselves. Accompanies the mini-series Band of Brothers.
- Réalisation
- Scénario
- Casting principal
- Nommé pour 1 Primetime Emmy
- 1 nomination au total
C. Carwood Lipton
- Self
- (as Carwood Lipton)
Avis à la une
Excellent interviews that detail the 101st's European tour and lay the foundation for the marvelous miniseries.
Screenplay...................................... 8 / 10 Interviews........................................ 10 Visuals................................................ 9 Sound................................................... 7 Editing................................................ 7 Music....................................................... 5 Timeless Utility................................. 8 Total.................................................... 54 / 70 ~= 7.7 (which I rounded to 8) Verdict................................................. Recommended.
Screenplay...................................... 8 / 10 Interviews........................................ 10 Visuals................................................ 9 Sound................................................... 7 Editing................................................ 7 Music....................................................... 5 Timeless Utility................................. 8 Total.................................................... 54 / 70 ~= 7.7 (which I rounded to 8) Verdict................................................. Recommended.
One of the things that set Band of Brothers apart from other war- based mini-series was the inclusion of interviews with the actual surviving members of Easy company. This 80 minute (when shown on BBC) programme allows us to get to know the real men behind the story and what they did with their lives after the War. So in a very real sense, this is the 11th episode in the series. The interviews were very moving. Almost 60 years on, the men involved are still very deeply affected by their experiences. Well worth watching. My one small complaint was that I found it difficult to associate the men being interviewed with the characters in the series. It might have been nice if some brief clips had been included, or a photo of the actor had been displayed. But that would probably have detracted from it.
10Pavel-8
"We Stand Alone Together" serves as an epilogue of sorts for the nonpareil mini-series "Band of Brothers." While it is best appreciated having seen "BoB," this sublime piece of work also functions well as a stand-alone (no pun intended) documentary.
Watching "Together" captures the essence of being a young boy, listening at the knee of your grandfather as he relates war stories. If the doc consisted of nothing more than showing the men reminiscing, it would have been great. But overlaying the men's tales is remarkable archival footage of the events they describe, along with a few necessary slides that provide pertinent information. Add this to having watched the described events in "BoB," and one has a more vivid account of WWII than anything one's imagination might invent.
Seeing the former soldiers tell their stories provides a fuller appreciation for what they endured. As phenomenal as "BoB" is, hearing the words straight from the men makes the events more personal, because you know that they have survived both the war and life itself in the aftermath. Perhaps most enlightening of all was learning of the respect that the American soldiers had for the Germans. They understood that the Germans were humans too, just in drastically different circumstances.
The documentary further emphasizes a tagline from "BoB." These were ordinary men doing extraordinary things. Listening to them explain that they simply returned to 'normal' life following the war is almost stunning. The modern soldier is still human, but much more trained and honed, often a professional soldier, leading us to think of them as almost superhuman. Most World War II soldiers were common people, which makes their accomplishments all the more head-shaking.
The documentary is also superb technically. The pacing in particular stands out. Shunning the common modern choices of quick cuts or attention-grabbing music, the film proceeds deliberately with quiet undertones. Consistently using fades in and out of footage and interviews, director Mark Cowen allows time for the viewer to absorb the power of what is said and shown.
Bottom Line: Phenomenal stories of phenomenal people related in a exceptional way. 10 of 10.
Watching "Together" captures the essence of being a young boy, listening at the knee of your grandfather as he relates war stories. If the doc consisted of nothing more than showing the men reminiscing, it would have been great. But overlaying the men's tales is remarkable archival footage of the events they describe, along with a few necessary slides that provide pertinent information. Add this to having watched the described events in "BoB," and one has a more vivid account of WWII than anything one's imagination might invent.
Seeing the former soldiers tell their stories provides a fuller appreciation for what they endured. As phenomenal as "BoB" is, hearing the words straight from the men makes the events more personal, because you know that they have survived both the war and life itself in the aftermath. Perhaps most enlightening of all was learning of the respect that the American soldiers had for the Germans. They understood that the Germans were humans too, just in drastically different circumstances.
The documentary further emphasizes a tagline from "BoB." These were ordinary men doing extraordinary things. Listening to them explain that they simply returned to 'normal' life following the war is almost stunning. The modern soldier is still human, but much more trained and honed, often a professional soldier, leading us to think of them as almost superhuman. Most World War II soldiers were common people, which makes their accomplishments all the more head-shaking.
The documentary is also superb technically. The pacing in particular stands out. Shunning the common modern choices of quick cuts or attention-grabbing music, the film proceeds deliberately with quiet undertones. Consistently using fades in and out of footage and interviews, director Mark Cowen allows time for the viewer to absorb the power of what is said and shown.
Bottom Line: Phenomenal stories of phenomenal people related in a exceptional way. 10 of 10.
Very good documentary. Especially if you are a fan of the Band of brothers. We stand alone together is kind of a recap, an encore..
The story of Easy Company told by a number of veterans.
As good a job as the dramatised series 'Band of Brothers' did at telling the story and recreating numerous events for the screen, there is nothing more powerful than hearing the actual soldiers talk about their memories and what it means to them.
For anybody interested in this period of history and the trauma that people have lived with following such difficult experiences, this documentary is a must watch.
Thankfully these interviews were captured at the time to help preserve memories about such a harrowing life experience and an important part of twentieth century history.
As good a job as the dramatised series 'Band of Brothers' did at telling the story and recreating numerous events for the screen, there is nothing more powerful than hearing the actual soldiers talk about their memories and what it means to them.
For anybody interested in this period of history and the trauma that people have lived with following such difficult experiences, this documentary is a must watch.
Thankfully these interviews were captured at the time to help preserve memories about such a harrowing life experience and an important part of twentieth century history.
Le saviez-vous
- AnecdotesThis feature-length documentary is featured on the DVD for Frères d'armes (2001) (mini).
- Citations
William Guarnere: I never thought I'd get through D-Day, let alone the next phase or the next phase. I thought I was gonna get killed instantly. The chances of survival is very very slim... extremely slim.
- ConnexionsFeatured in History Buffs: Band of Brothers (2017)
Meilleurs choix
Connectez-vous pour évaluer et suivre la liste de favoris afin de recevoir des recommandations personnalisées
Détails
- Date de sortie
- Pays d’origine
- Langue
- Aussi connu sous le nom de
- Estamos solos pero unidos
- Lieux de tournage
- Sociétés de production
- Voir plus de crédits d'entreprise sur IMDbPro
Contribuer à cette page
Suggérer une modification ou ajouter du contenu manquant