Julie Walking Home

This is a drama about beliefs and how these can change based on necessity and fear.

At the beginning of the movie the Jew husband (the always excellent William Fichtner) doesn't believe in miracles, but after his son gets better from a "miracle man", he changes his mind and begs that same miracle man --who has also slept with his wife in the meantime-- to come and help his son. The necessity of his son win the battle with cancer is more important than his own prejudices and fears.

The movie starts a bit slowly, then it gets a bit of a more interesting pace, but overall it's not a movie that will have you see it again any time soon. Performances are good, photography is not too bad, but the pace is slow.

'Julia Walking Home' is a movie in which too many sensible themes as faith, marriage troubles, religiosity, supernatural events and the fear of death are put together in a bundle by director Agnieska Holland. Maybe the great circle of matters is a problem to the final outcome but, in fact, the movie and its narrative are not conducted with sufficient strenght to make the viewer really involved with the drama. All the time the movie goes on and on and the story seems to be restrained and underdeveloped. There's too much artificialism in some points, like the relationship between Julie (Miranda Otto) and the miracle guy (Lothaire Bluteau, in a strange performance) who performs supernatural cures for all kind of diseases. The most strong impression, after all, is that life must be linked with strong morality and family values. In this point, I think Mr. Frank Capra could have been the director of this peasant, conventional and thoughtless little drama. The outocome - maybe - would be much better. I give this a 5 (five).

• Life is complicated.

• There is no clear right or wrong.

• The deeds we hate on other people, may be done by us, when time comes. Humans don't always react in the most obvious ways.

• At many points in life, we have to make choices, where we gain something and we lose something. It is not usually obvious what choice is the best one.

• There is an ongoing tussle between heart and brain, the intellectual self and the emotional self, the worldly desire and larger than life desires...

These are some of things I recall from my experience with the movie. It was indeed an experience. It was a very sensitive movie having complicated characters and their psychologies. It was one of those movies wherefrom anybody could take back anything that he/she relates to, more strongly. For example, one may think it was a movie about a woman's hypocrisies whereas others might that it was a movie on fighting till the last moment. Some might view it as justifying the supernatural. Its just how you view it.

Although BASED ON A REAL LIFE STORY, and I never thought real life stories could be that surprising, its not the story that matters. Don't try to view the film based on the short story description. If you are into meaningful cinema which involves reflections from real life, a thought behind the movie, something that lets you ponder for quite sometime, this is the movie for you. And don't worry it will not be hard on you. Its softly told movie that will surely have an impact on you, positive or negative, who knows!

"Julie Walking Home" is about a woman coping with a rocky relationship with the father of her children, her son who has cancer and may or may not be healed by a faith healer, and her feelings for a man who believes he has mystical healing powers. Though the film's storyline is nothing new, the sheer reality of the drama, the wonderful performances Holland wrests from some relatively unknown actors, and Otto's tour-de-force makes this film eminently worthy. Not unlike "Behind the Red Door" (2002), "Hysterical Blindness" (2002), or "Unfaithful" (2002) this film is a "sleeper" which will be of greatest interest to the discerning drama enthusiast into film's about women in turmoil. (B+)

Julie, the main character, is living in a failed relationship with a Biologist dad in an apartment in America.

When her son Nicholas has terminal cancer. She finds herself going to the other extreme, which is contrary to her beliefs and her enlightened worldview, in search of hope for him, when she meets a Polish therapist with special powers.

The story is quite consistent, and believable in a certain way. The characters' acting is great. The music is the Achilles' heel of the film. It is oppressive, and takes over the entire film.

It could say that the film is about a family that undergoes a change in the dynamics surrounding Nicholas' illness, and that the illness is the cause of the healing that the family needed.

The film also made me think about the role of faith - what is faith? Is it prejudice? Is it a person's helplessness in the face of their ability to control their destiny and the need for a certain attachment? Or is it actually the agreement to surrender and let go? Is faith the complete opposite of science, or are they simply two different ways of organizing reality, and does science merely prove faith?

In conclusion: Worth watching but long and tedious.