Une étude approfondie de la guerre civile américaine.Une étude approfondie de la guerre civile américaine.Une étude approfondie de la guerre civile américaine.
- Récompensé par 2 Primetime Emmys
- 14 victoires et 3 nominations au total
Parcourir les épisodes
Résumé
Reviewers say 'The Civil War' by Ken Burns is acclaimed for its immersive portrayal of the American Civil War, praised for archival photos, compelling narration, and evocative music. It is lauded for making history accessible and engaging. However, some critics argue it lacks live footage and personal interviews, potentially diminishing emotional depth. A few reviewers note it may not fully represent all perspectives, particularly women and African-Americans. Despite these criticisms, it is generally regarded as a monumental documentary achievement.
Avis à la une
When The Civil War first aired in 1990, it became a phenomenon. I
was a little kid, but I remember "Ashokan Farewell" and the
intriguing black and white images and voiceovers from the screen,
and people talking about it all over the place. To be sure, the
intimacy of the film eventually made me a Civil War buff, as it has
for tens of thousands across the country.
The fact is, Ken Burns created a monumental piece of television
that chronicled, if not in a general fashion, by far the most defining
moment in our history and an incredibly groundbreaking way.
The film is simple, yet is so profound in it's simplicity and style,
using just pictures and accounts and music and some bursts of
color from modern cinematography. For the first time, we heard the
accounts of real soldiers and people, and instead of taking sides,
it gave a sense of humanity to both sides in a war that is riddled
with political and social posturing, but was ultimately all slaughter.
was a little kid, but I remember "Ashokan Farewell" and the
intriguing black and white images and voiceovers from the screen,
and people talking about it all over the place. To be sure, the
intimacy of the film eventually made me a Civil War buff, as it has
for tens of thousands across the country.
The fact is, Ken Burns created a monumental piece of television
that chronicled, if not in a general fashion, by far the most defining
moment in our history and an incredibly groundbreaking way.
The film is simple, yet is so profound in it's simplicity and style,
using just pictures and accounts and music and some bursts of
color from modern cinematography. For the first time, we heard the
accounts of real soldiers and people, and instead of taking sides,
it gave a sense of humanity to both sides in a war that is riddled
with political and social posturing, but was ultimately all slaughter.
Not only is "The Civil War" Ken Burns' best documentary, it is one of the best out there, also. It easily mixes emotions with facts, while keeping an eye on narration.
It doesn't go for cheap "recreation" moments; in other words, we don't see a redo of the tale told with about five soldiers who look like they're dressed for Halloween; we instead see real pictures while listening to vivid narrations by such actors as Jason Robards, Laurence Fishburne, Morgan Freeman, Jeremy Irons, M. Emmet Walsh, Pamela Reed, and more.
If you haven't seen this four hour epic yet, then go find it at a video store right now.
It doesn't go for cheap "recreation" moments; in other words, we don't see a redo of the tale told with about five soldiers who look like they're dressed for Halloween; we instead see real pictures while listening to vivid narrations by such actors as Jason Robards, Laurence Fishburne, Morgan Freeman, Jeremy Irons, M. Emmet Walsh, Pamela Reed, and more.
If you haven't seen this four hour epic yet, then go find it at a video store right now.
For someone who lives outside the United States of America and has an interest in it's history 'The Civil War' for me delivers everything that I'm unable to get here in the UK.
History books don't even come close in highlighting the lives and stories of the those involved in this watershed of America history, it's effects not only felt in North America but eventually the world.
Outstanding.
History books don't even come close in highlighting the lives and stories of the those involved in this watershed of America history, it's effects not only felt in North America but eventually the world.
Outstanding.
10jpellino
Contrary to the only other comment so far, I found this inspiring and elevating. I understood the civil war in a way nothing else in 17 years of formal education did. Burns was trying to tell what is perhaps the most compelling story since this country was founded. He had no footage, and was not interested in dramatizing the battles (which is notoriously difficult to to without boosting one side). Instead, he found a way to take the still images and remnants of the war and the stories of individuals and make them more real than any movie could do. Eleven hours of reenactments would have been interminable - and silly - as vaunted as the reenactors are, they get away with it because they are romanticized - can you imagine reenacting Ardennes or Khe Sanh? In a world where TV viewership is measured in 5-minute chunks if you're lucky, Burns kept viewers' attention for 11+ hours - and with no commercials - quite a feat.
I'm 13, and I learned more about the Civil War in these videos than I have in my entire life! It might just be that my teachers don't teach it well, but I think it's something else! When I first started watching them with my parents, I was doubtful of their quality. How is a guy going to make a documentary about a time when there were only still photographs? I thought it wasn't possible to keep the audience interested, especially in a 12.5 hour long documentary. Well, I was wrong.
Ken Burns is actually an amazing film maker. He not only gave information in his documentary, he told a story. And not just any story, he told the story of one of the worst wars in the history of the world. By using still photographs mixed with voice overs and quotes, he brought the world of the Civil War to life.
A great documentary!
Ken Burns is actually an amazing film maker. He not only gave information in his documentary, he told a story. And not just any story, he told the story of one of the worst wars in the history of the world. By using still photographs mixed with voice overs and quotes, he brought the world of the Civil War to life.
A great documentary!
Le saviez-vous
- AnecdotesShelby Foote became a celebrity after the success of this mini-series. Foote's phone number was listed in his local phone book, and he received frequent calls from fans. He never removed his number from the phone book, and received calls whenever the mini-series aired for the rest of his life.
- GaffesContrary to this documentary (and many historians) Winfield Scott never recommended Robet E. Lee for anything more than a "significant command" nor did Lincoln offer Lee command of the Union Army.
An advisor to the President, Francis P. Blair, DID offer Lee command of the Defenses of Washington, via letter, but there are NO records that Lee. An Lincoln ever met in person.
- Citations
Abraham Lincoln: As a nation, we began by declaring that "All men are created equal." We now practically read it, "All men are created equal, except Negroes." Soon, it will read "All men are created equal, except Negroes, and Foreigners and Catholics." When it comes to this, I should prefer emigrating to some country where they make no pretense of loving liberty. To Russia, for instance, where despotism can be taken pure and without the base alloy of hypocrisy.
- ConnexionsFeatured in Entertainment Weekly's the New Classics: TV (2008)
Meilleurs choix
Connectez-vous pour évaluer et suivre la liste de favoris afin de recevoir des recommandations personnalisées
- How many seasons does The Civil War have?Alimenté par Alexa
Détails
Contribuer à cette page
Suggérer une modification ou ajouter du contenu manquant