Un fusil pour l'honneur

My review was written in April 1990 after watching the movie on Nelson Entertainment video cassette.

"Blood Red", a saga of oppressed Sicilian winegrowers in 19th century California, is an unsuccessful throwback to earlier forms of filmmaking. First-time screen teaming of siblings Eric and Julia Roberts makes this a definite curiosity item.

Project was announced in 1976 by producer Judd Bernard, filmed in 1986 and given a pefunctory release last summer by Hemdale.

Future film historians will ponder why this wasn't a Paramount picture, since it conforms to the themes and mood of "The Godfather", "1900" and Eric Roberts' first staring pic, "The King of the Gypsies". All that's missing is the late Sterling Hayden.

A robust Giancarlo Giannini is patriarch of one ot two families in Brandon, California, and soon is warring with robber baron railroad magnate Dennis Hopper (fitted with an unconvincing Scottish brogue here determined to get his land for his railroad's right of way.

Giannini's rebellious son, Eric Roberts, is in love with the beautiful daughter (Lara Harris) of another winegrowing clan. Hopper hires Burt Young (miscast) and his gang of mercenaries to convince Giannini and the other growers to clear out, resulting in violence. Pic ends in boring fashon with a whimper.

Ron Cutler's utterly predictable script is mainly to blame for draining "Blood Red" of interest. It emerges as a depiction in black hat/white hat terms of history in the mode of "Heaven's Gate" but without that film's controversial (but awesome) production values. Peter Masterson's direction is flat, and though there are some pretty shots, the love of the land and specifics of winegrowing are not developed.

Eric Roberts is more subdued than usual as the script fails to develop a three-dimensional character for him. His scenes with real-life sister Julia, cast as his sister, are intriguing because of the visual match. She doesn't get much chance to emote, but that nascent star quality already is evident.

Alexandra Masterson is a good match as the third sibling, while helmer's wife, Carlin Glynn (previously featured in Masterson's "The Trip to Bountiful") is solid representing the local gentry in supporting the Sicilan's just cause.

Carmine Coppola delives a romantic musical background that underscores the genre connection.

This is playing On-Demand and is presented in its original 1.85:1 aspect ratio for the first time on home video.

The Good: The acting talent speaks for itself: Eric and Julia Roberts, Burt Young, Giancarlo Giannini, Elias Koteas, Michael Madsen... The cinematography by Toyomichi Kurita is beautiful. Themes: Late 19th century California, the beginning of wine culture, immigrant vs. business interests, William Jennings Bryan populism vs robber baron statism. All the tools are there for a great film.

The Bad: The screenplay is the problem. It needed a page one rewrite from someone who could write dialogue, and who could write scenes to emphasize the political, religious, and economic issues of the period. The characterization is almost non existent, with only Giannini's part getting some depth. There is so much wasted talented in this film. Usually Eric Roberts is criticized for overacting, but this picture could have definitely benefited from his passion. Also the music by Carmine Coppola is so old-fashioned and silly that it borders on soap opera cues.

The first half will keep your attention. After that, it becomes boring. Bad dialogue, bad music, and pedestrian mise-en-scene kill the movie. I was actually rewriting the scenes in my head as I was watching the film.

Sebastian Collogero (Giancarlo Giannini) is the patriarch of a Sicilian family farming and making wine in rural California. His roguish son Marco (Eric Roberts) pursues neighbor Antonio Segestra's daughter Angelica. They are an immigrant community proud to be new citizens. Land baron William Bradford Berrigan (Dennis Hopper) is looking to take over the valley to build his railroad. Sebastian Collogero leads the farmers in opposition. Mr. Berrigan brings in Andrews (Burt Young) and his thugs to kill Collogero. Devoted daughter Maria Collogero (Julia Roberts) witnesses the lynching and Marco leads a war against Berrigan.

Eric Roberts has his fluffy flowing hair and struts around while overacting. The release was delayed and this is actually one of the first acting roles for Julia. That's probably the only interesting aspect of this movie. It is visually more align with a TV movie although director Peter Masterson obviously is shooting higher. The overall quality is not good and its higher aspirations only make it worst.

This was obviously a low budget film. It shows in every scene. What is nice to see is where it was made. A lot of the film was shot in Columbia, CA, in the Sierra Nevada Mountains near Sonora, CA. Some of the film was also shot in Jamestown, CA, very near Columbia. There is a railroad museum in Jamestown and they used some of the old trains in the picture. "High Noon" was also shot in Jamestown, as was "Back to the Future III".

When a friend told me about this film, I looked up "Blood Red" on IMDB and was shocked to see that it the pathetic overall score of 3.8. This would seem to indicate that the film is garbage, as even films like "Plan 9 From Outer Space" (once named the worst movie ever made) has a score of 4.0! To earn a 3.8, the film would have to be truly horrible in every way...which, oddly, it isn't. Now I am not arguing that the film is great or even really good....but the only thing about this film that should earn a 3.8 is Eric Roberts' ridiculous and anachronistic hairdo!

The story is set in the late 19th century. The main characters in the film are generations of Italian-Americans who love the land and its healthy vineyards. However, a greedy railroad tycoon (Dennis Hopper) is intent on running his trains right through their farms...whether they like it or not. And, when the farmers won't leave, the railroad responds with violence. But because the railroad has bribed local officials, it looks as if the farmers will have to take care of business themselves.

I have no idea if this story is based on facts or if it's all fiction. But it's an interesting story...and is in some ways like a western in style and plot. In old westerns, a rich bully trying to take everyone's land is among the most common themes.

So why do I think it earned a 3.8? Well, actually, I am not exactly sure. While it's not among the best acted or paced films, it's not boring and kept my interest. The ending, I admit, was handled poorly...and made little sense. It's also a rare film because you can see the siblings Eric and Julia Roberts in the same movie...though Julia's part is quite small.