Hanna K.
- 1983
- Tous publics
- 1h 51min
NOTE IMDb
6,6/10
1 k
MA NOTE
Une avocate israélienne assure la défense d'un Palestinien inculpé par le tribunal militaire dans les territoires occupés. C'est une affaire difficile en raison de l'épineux contexte politiq... Tout lireUne avocate israélienne assure la défense d'un Palestinien inculpé par le tribunal militaire dans les territoires occupés. C'est une affaire difficile en raison de l'épineux contexte politique.Une avocate israélienne assure la défense d'un Palestinien inculpé par le tribunal militaire dans les territoires occupés. C'est une affaire difficile en raison de l'épineux contexte politique.
- Réalisation
- Scénario
- Casting principal
- Récompenses
- 2 nominations au total
Mohammad Bakri
- Selim Bakri
- (as Mohammed Bakri)
Dalik Wollinitz
- Sergent 'check point'
- (as Dalik Volonitz)
Avis à la une
Costa-Gavras has superbly captured the mood and atmosphere of Jerusalem and its diverse people in this sombre work. It's an intriguing film for that reason alone. But he also has set a complex story with fascinating characters on that unique stage. You have to work at watching it a bit, but the effort is worthwhile. It's also one of Jill Clayburgh's best roles
A daring movie that hits the truth, goes against the stream, and explore the tragedy. The film is well worth watching, especially for those who are only familiar with one side of the conflict. I recommend it for people seeking understanding of the middle east. Hope you enjoy it.
Without going into details the movie explore an era that is sadly has gotten worse since, daring and telling the truth and going against what is said on the stream .
The acting would be a bit cold in certain scenes nevertheless it still delivered the message in a perfect way.
The atmosphere in Jerusalem feels so vivid and the scene when one of the protagonists walks in the street of and in the allee it felt really genuine how the people are selling, smithing and just walking or talking
The movie contain a lot of figurative scenarios that try to deliver a really nice message enjoyed the movie and I really wished it would last a bit longer .
The acting would be a bit cold in certain scenes nevertheless it still delivered the message in a perfect way.
The atmosphere in Jerusalem feels so vivid and the scene when one of the protagonists walks in the street of and in the allee it felt really genuine how the people are selling, smithing and just walking or talking
The movie contain a lot of figurative scenarios that try to deliver a really nice message enjoyed the movie and I really wished it would last a bit longer .
Far from successful movie makes some distinctly weird artistic choices, right up to the last scene The rather adventurous underlying structure (Hanna's emotional confusion and attempt to forge a workable life and career, while poised between a politically and ideologically adventurous mix of men) needs a far more dynamic, less portentous telling than is employed here. The movie is mostly tedious and arbitrary and seems like a very odd way of approaching the undoubtedly important underlying issues. Clayburgh isn't a very exciting presence, and the men around her just float in and out - the forging of oppositions and conflicts leads us not to a heightened appreciation of the broader politics but just to melodramatic excess (for example, D.A. Byrne opposes her in court with particular enmity, but later - despite little apparent chemistry - she has a child with him even though their differences remain largely unreconciled : you just stare blankly at all this...)
Costa-Gavras raises some interesting and valid points here that are just as relevant today as they were 18 years ago.But like all backstage quarterbacks regarding the Arab-Israeli conflict he doesn't offer any suggestions to solve the problem.The real problem with this film though lies in Jill Clayburgh's performance.It never rises above a "TV Movie" level and she drags the whole cast and the story down with her.I think if somebody like Meryl Streep had starred in this picture,it would have been a completely different movie.
Le saviez-vous
- AnecdotesThe film was restored in 2014 by KG Productions with the support of the CNC under the supervision of Costa-Gavras by Éclair Group.
- Citations
Victor Bonnet: Do you say Shalom all the time?
Hanna Kaufman: Yes, it means Peace.
- ConnexionsReferenced in Troupe d'élite - L'ennemi intérieur (2010)
Meilleurs choix
Connectez-vous pour évaluer et suivre la liste de favoris afin de recevoir des recommandations personnalisées
- How long is Hanna K.?Alimenté par Alexa
Détails
Box-office
- Montant brut aux États-Unis et au Canada
- 114 247 $US
- Week-end de sortie aux États-Unis et au Canada
- 14 336 $US
- 2 oct. 1983
Contribuer à cette page
Suggérer une modification ou ajouter du contenu manquant