Bachelor of Hearts

Instead of the usual storyline of a young American's trials and tribulations, while studying at Oxbridge, the director had decided to twist the narrative by casting the young, and then up and coming German actor, Hardy Kruger as the Teutonic, blue eyed and blond exchange student, whose naivety and ignorance about the cultural and esoteric mysteries and nuances of Cambridge University life, ruffles the feathers of the stuffy, snooty middle class fellow students. The major problem here is that Kruger looks as if he's in his thirties, ditto his fellow student, lantern jawed, and plummy voiced Ronald Lewis. Even Kruger's romantic interest, Sylvia Sims, the 1950's 'English Rose' of the Rank film studios, looks less like a young student, but at least her charm and looks kept me awake during the film which was tedious in the extreme. The film is more about highlighting caricatures of undergraduate life, where much boozing and 'wenching' goes on in jazz clubs and where students seem to behave like wayward juveniles as they perpetually get themselves into scrapes with the college authorities. The director presents Kruger and Lewis as undergraduate stereotypes of young men behaving badly as they engage in 'silly antics' in their 'free time' and during the annual bore, the so called 'rag week.' The usual 'ho ho ho' climbing over walls by our two 'Romeo's' after midnight to reach their student accommodation while drunk, is another tick boxing exercise by the director in presenting students as immature and innocent twerps, who find their sole pleasure in extra curricular activities! Yes, there were the delightful views of students punting along the river, but the whole film was yawn inducing. It was definitely a second feature and forgettable film.

This had the bones of a good film but just disintegrated into a poor slap stick.

Wolf Rilla did his best with this film, but it ended up looking like a fluffy cake in the shape of Cambridge, well beyond its sell by date. A few years earlier it may have worked but by 1958 it appeared still looking pretty visually but stale. John Osborne had written ' Look Back in Anger ' and from America ' Blackboard Jungle ' and ' Rebel Without A Cause ' had shaken up the insides of schools. But here in this meandering film the relentless high jinks of privileged youth and secret ceremonies still reigned causing mock havoc. Throwing Hardy Kruger as an exchange student in a mock execution into the relentlessly punting river was still ' fun ' and as the British take a long time in growing up it may still continue. Sylvia Syms is utterly wasted as Kruger's girlfriend ( not that much chemistry showed ) and Ronald Lewis tried to be funny as a fellow student but they all must have known that there was very little to do with their roles. The one plot highlight was Kruger on a hunting search for women for his fellow students to take to a ball, and that should have been cut out or shortened. It was boring and sexist and the ultimate insult was that the ' girls ' once rounded up like cattle seemed to like their moronic companions. I dreaded a joke about the Germans and ' the War ' but Rilla fortunately avoided that, and I give it a 5 for showing a boringly normal German, unlike the usual stereotyped Germans in the endless War heroics cluttering up the British film industry. For that one important element the film was refreshing.

This gentle comedy really scores for me. Hardy Kruger is very good, then again so are all the players in this film. However, I have to admit that one of my favourite actresses, the beautiful Sylvia Syms not only steals the film but also my heart. The Cambridge scenes and scenery are beautiful too, and as someone who lives near that iconic City it really is shown off at it's best. Others have suggested this is a film to watch if you have nothing else to do, I disagree, this feelgood film for me is a joy and as such needs to be watched and appreciated for what it is - a lovely piece of our past when things were simpler, happier and more innocent.

This is a pleasant little film, jam-packed with amusing stereotypes of the English and university life as seen through the eyes of exchange student Wolf Hauser (very young and good-looking Kruger) If this movie had been made even 10 years later I wonder if there would have been a deeper exploration of Hauser's attempts to fit in with his surroundings and his very German presence in a still anti-German post-war England?

As it is, the movie is memorable for the glorious footage of Cambridge (undoubtedly one of the most photogenic places in England) and the lovely Sylvia Sims, who manages to sweetly steal every scene she appears in. She is very reminiscent of Kristen Scott Thomas at times, with her terribly english loveliness. Strong supporting cast including Ronald Lewis and Eric Barker help a lot.

Cute, harmless comedy when there's nothing better to do.