Un jour au cirque

The Marx Brothers burst onto the scene in the 1929 comedy "The Cocoanuts". Over the next few years they starred in some of the all-time classics, namely "Horse Feathers" and "Duck Soup".

Then something happened. I don't know the reason, but they left Paramount (which financed the aforementioned movies) and moved to MGM. By that point, MGM was well established as the domain of happy-go-lucky musicals, and it showed in the Marx Brothers' movies. Far from the biting satire of their earlier movies, these newer movies tended to show them performing antics in various settings: opera, horse racing, and now the circus. "At the Circus" is funny, but it's no "Duck Soup".

Ignoring all that, there's plenty of laughs to be had here (and quite a few hot babes). Enjoyable in that respect. Jerry Maren (Atom) is best known as one of the Munchkins in "The Wizard of Oz" and died only last year, making him not only the last surviving speaking cast member from TWoO, but the last surviving cast member from a Marx Brothers movie.

The decline of the Marx Brothers does not begin with ROOM SERVICE, which is hysterical at it's conclusion, but with AT THE CIRCUS. Groucho always insisted that had Irving Thalberg lived his care would have made the other films in the contract after A DAY AT THE RACES as good as that and A NIGHT AT THE OPERA. This meant that the film had to be taken on the road as a Vaudeville show, and the material tested carefully. But Thalberg was dead, and Louis B. Mayer was quite unsympathetic to these three clowns who were...well clowns, and who had gotten too good a sweetheart contract from Thalburg in terms of profits. Mayer thought of comedians as interchangeable, and could not care about allowing talented ones to test their material - you hand them a script and that was that: they are paid to make it funny. If they don't you fire them.

So it is traditional to blame AT THE CIRCUS, GO WEST, and THE BIG STORE on Mayer's hostility. That hostility played a major role (there is just no denying it), but in the case of AT THE CIRCUS there is another point that is frequently overlooked. In movies by comedians, it was rare for a circus comedy to be really funny. W.C.Fields, YOU CAN'T CHEAT AN HONEST MAN was an exception - a truly funny circus comedy, but it's strength was the film record of Field's radio feud with ventriloquist dummy Charlie McCarthy. Had it been set in a movie studio or a bank or a foreign country it would have been just as successful. But other comedians were not as lucky. Charlie Chaplin worked two years on THE CIRCUS, and while a good film it was not the great film he hoped to make. The atmosphere of a circus should have been inviting to comics - after all, here clowns were really clowns. But for some reason the special needs of movie funny-men were hard to translate into the atmosphere of the big top. Possibly the best use of the big top as a comic background was in Laurel & Hardy's short film THE CHIMP. The first quarter of the film shows how they wreck the circus (which was on it's last legs anyway). But the remaining three quarters of the film deal with the boys problems with a rooming house owned by a jealous Billy Gilbert, and the title "chimp" they hope to sell to a zoo.

With the Marxes the circus just does not absorb them too much. Groucho is there, hired as a lawyer to assist Kenny Baker and his pal Chico. Harpo, as Chico's brother, is a circus roustabout. But there is little example of their involvement in the circus life of the troop or of the animals (Harpo should have been involved with circus horses, anyway). Bits of the film are actually quite good - like Chico and Harpo trying to find papers in Nat Pendleton's (the circus strongman's) room. They manage to turn it into a Christmas nightmare for poor Pendleton. And Groucho certainly has two great moments: the business of trying to get on the circus train without knowing the password (even one of the animals knows the password), and his singing "Lydia The Tattooed Lady".

There were some cuts, apparently. Groucho had a sequence where his trial skills were shown in a court presided over by Edgar Kennedy. One wishes they had kept that in the film. The poor portions, mostly tied to the sickeningly sweet and naive Kenny Baker (fighting the crooked James Burke) are overwhelming. At least Groucho was able to have another session with Margaret Dumont as Mrs. Dukesberry (Baker's aunt), and poor Margaret gets shot out of a cannon in the end. But the drab spots outnumber the good ones. Not too bad, but still just mediocre as a result.

This was my third time watching AT THE CIRCUS and, the characteristically anaemic leads (who somehow always seem to be able to carry a tune) notwithstanding, I've always been kind of partial to this one (even if the end result is, decidedly, a notch or two below their finest work). Plot and setting provide several opportunities for the Marxes to shine, both as a team and individually: Groucho (as always) is the film's trump card, however, especially in his rendition of 'Lydia, the Tattooed Lady' and the separate scenes he shares with befuddled aristocrat Margaret Dumont and scheming circus performer Eve Arden; other highlights include Groucho and Chico's interrogation of the suspicious-looking dwarf, Chico and Harpo's frenzied search for stolen money in the strong-man's room (while the latter is asleep!), and the typically busy climax in which Dumont receives the ultimate humiliation.

AT THE CIRCUS is the Marxes' third best MGM picture (demonstrating a steady decline for them from picture to picture) but it's still inferior to the later A NIGHT IN CASABLANCA (1946), in my opinion – or any of their early Paramount films, for that matter.

Music was an integral part of Marx Brothers movies, showcasing Chico's tickling the keys on the piano and Harpo's harp strumming among other singing acts. In the comedy team's ninth film, October 1939's "At The Circus," a number songs and dances were planned, with a heavy dose of parody lyrics embedded in their catchy tunes. Trouble was, MGM boss Louis Mayer didn't feel music should be part of their repertoire. While in the middle of composing the music for the Marx's, songwriters Harold Arlen and E. Y. Harburg were pulled by Mayer to work on 1939's "The Wizard of Oz." Film historians feel his was a good move since the composers wrote some of cinema's best music for the Judy Garland picture, including its number one hit "Somewhere Over The Rainbow."

Before leaving the "At The Circus" production, the two composed one of the Marx Brothers most famous songs, "Lydia the Tattooed Lady." Sung by Groucho, this became his signature song throughout the remainder of his entertainment life. It has also become a staple of many film and television shows, including in 1976's 'The Muppet Show' and in the ninth and tenth seasons of TV's 'The Walking Dead.' The Marx Brothers, crossing the 50-year-old age mark, were looking to retire from film before they even read the script of "At The Circus." Chico's enormous gambling debts created a financial pinch for him, prompting Harpo and Groucho to agree to bail him out as long as he put half of his salary he earned from the movie into lifetime locked-in investments.

Ironically in "At The Circus" Chico plays Tony, an employee for a financially-distress circus whose owner Jeff Wilson (Kenny Baker) is depending on his wealthy aunt, Mrs. Susanna Dukesbury (Margaret Dumont), to provide funding. Tony recommends to Jeff his lawyer friend, J. Cheever Loophole (Groucho), to investigate the disappearance of $10,000 Jeff had saved to pay off his creditor John Carter (James Burke). The shark Carter wants to foreclose on the loan and own the circus when he stumbles across Jeff's hidden savings. With the help of circus strongman Goliath (Ned Pendleton) and Peerless Pauline (Eve Arden), he's able to steal the money.

Performers from the recently-defunct Hagenbeck-Wallace Circus, the second largest circus in the country who shut its doors after 31 years, were hired as extras for "At The Circus." Buster Keaton, near-bankrupt himself, was hired as a gag consultant for the Marx's. He proposed a number of visual jokes, but the brothers nixed them, feeling they didn't fit their brand of humor. Groucho complained to Keaton one day about his type of jokes. The former silent movie comedian confessed, "I'm only doing what Mr. Mayer asked me to do. You guys don't need help."

This was the first movie the Marx Brothers didn't try out their routines in front of live audiences before filming. One particular scene stands out, showing Eve Arden tucking the pouch of stolen money in her bra as Groucho catches what she's doing in the corner of his eye. He talks to the 'fourth-wall,' exclaiming, "There must be some way of getting that money without getting in trouble with the Hays office," meaning the movie censors. He has her perform her circus act by walking upside down on the ceiling, with hilarious results. "The film is definitely one of their finest comedies in terms of set pieces and gags as well as the willingness to bring in some anarchy into any kind of situation," praised Steven Flores, one of the film reviewers who loved the movie.

Groucho was beginning to lose his hair at this stage of his life, and is seen throughout "At The Circus" with an exaggerated toupee. He recalled years later how a stuntman, sweating profusely in a gorilla suit, cut holes in the rented outfit to make it cooler. Its owner was so upset he took back the suit, causing the prop department to scramble for another monkey suit, only to find just a smaller orangutan outfit. Groucho claims it's easy to tell the difference between the two suits.

"At The Circus" proved to be a mix bag for the critics, with Film Daily heralding "The mad Marxmen have never been funnier, nor have they had a better story in which to cavort," while Harrison's Reports labeled it "about the worst Marx picture seen in years. Children should enjoy it, but hardly any adults." The American Film Institute nominated the song "Lydia the Tattooed Lady" for its Top 100 Songs in Movies.

Middle-of-the-road Marxes, with some good scenes and laughs unevenly weighted down by those ever-intrusive and out-of-place musical numbers that so often plagued these movies. No, I'm not referring to Groucho's spirited rendition of 'Lydia the Tattooed Lady'; I'm talking about hearing those two useless lead lovers crooning their sappy romantic tunes to each other ('Two Blind Loves', which is sung over and over at intervals throughout the picture, is especially grating on the nerves). There is also a song and dance sequence that comes out of left field later in the film that really feels out of place and gets in the way of things.

There are certainly some witty Groucho zingers, as well as vintage Harpo madness, to be found here. It's just that there's not enough consistency and too much of the fluff. It's a pity the filmmakers just didn't realize that it's the Marx Brothers we're here to see; not Kenny Baker and Florence Rice.