Soyons gai

This comedy is very different to what you might expect. Its first ten minutes is the little drama that sets the scene but from then on it's a 1920s style drawing room farce, the type of thing you'd expect to hear the phrase: Anyone for tennis?

Surprisingly, once you get used to its theatrical style - necessary for this type of comedy, you might enjoy this. I didn't think I would but despite my initial reservations (were I around then, I'd have been watching Cagney at the Warner Brothers cinemas), I actually found myself laughing at this.

If someone asked you what 1930s movies were like, this type of picture would definitely not be what you'd think about. Today such gentle, gentile plays would play to empty houses but if you put yourself into the mindset of a 1929 theatre goer, you'll find this quite amusing: it's not what these days you'd call funny but it's not without some charm.

Like all of her films, this is another excuse for Irving Thalberg to say to the world: Have I got a hot wife or what! Inexplicably although Miss Shearer is no classic beauty, she somehow exudes 1.21 Gigawatts of sexuality. Don't know how she does it....maybe it's because she was such a good actress!

In this picture, Mrs T after divorcing her unfaithful husband reinvents herself as the most brazen, sex-hungry man eater you've ever seen outside of a Carry On film. The rest of the cast are the usual stock characters for this type of thing but it's made so well (ok, it's a bit creaky because it was made in 1930) it's a cut above the usual. As long as you know what you're going to get: the acting isn't meant to be naturalistic, it's in the style of a farce - it's actually quite entertaining.

"Let Us Be Gay" is an early sound picture of comedy, romance and drama. Its production quality shows the strains of the first couple of years of the studios, even the big ones like MGM, in adapting to sound and other technical improvements in movies. For instance, there isn't much free movement and discussion among the cast in the few different settings. The confined speaking spaces were due to the stationary microphones. This film can serve as a good study in following the changes in movie technology and methods.

Norma Shearer was pregnant when this film was made, so MGM hurried its shooting - completing it in less than a month. The story is based on a play by American playwright Rachel Crothers. In places, it is melodrama, and in some others, it's silly or sappy. It's a classic use of innuendo regarding morals and loose living. And, it's a picture of marriage, infidelity and tested love. The setting for all of this is in the upper crust of society. One wonders how audiences received this film in the first year of the Great Depression.

The film has much humor - biting in places. The cynicism contributes to some hilarious scenes in which the players crack up among themselves. Those seem to be impromptu and authentic, and one wonders if they didn't happen that way on the set and the director decided to keep them instead of reshooting scenes. They give a sense of reality as something that happens among people in regular life, but that one seldom sees in scripted movies.

Most of the cast do well with one exception. Rod La Rocque is very wooden as Bob Brown. His voice especially seems to be that of a monotone robot. This is so obvious as to be nagging and distracting from any sincerity on his part. This is an instance when one role so affects the whole film negatively. La Rocque looked the part but just didn't or couldn't play it. Any number of other actors of the day would have been suited for that role.

Norma Shearer is Kitty Brown, whose makeup transformation is quite remarkable. Marie Dressler is Mrs. Bouccicault - Bouccy (pronounced, "Boo-see") as Kitty and others call her by nickname. She and Kitty dominate most of the scenes they are in together. Dressler truly was one of the greats of early cinema. Gilbert Emery is superb as Towney Townley, a carefree wealthy middle-aged bachelor who is smitten with Kitty. Hedda Hopper is a hoot as the very exaggerated stuffy and snobbish Madge Livingston. And, Tryrell Davis is very good and funny as the cowering Wallace Granger. Even the main butler and maid contribute to the humor in this film. The rest of the cast are fine

The best part of the film is the witty and cynical comedy in exchanges between Kitty and others, especially Bouccy and Towney. The plot is unique and good, and it has a different but nice ending for a Hollywood production even then. It reflects the undertone of true love, not just romance between a couple.

Here are some favorite lines from the film. For more witty and other dialog, see the Quotes section under this IMDb Web page of the movie.

Mrs. Bouccicault, "Towney, this is Mrs. Cortland-Brown. She's not as sweet as she looks. But, you'll think she is." Towney Townley, "How do you do. I am nicer than I look - much." Kitty Brown, "How could you be?"

Kitty Brown, "How do you do. Oh, you magnificent long-legged Britisher. I've been avoiding you in Paris. But you are wonderful, aren't you?" Towney Townley, "Yes, yes, we, we are, aren't we?" Kitty Brown, "I thought you said he was 'umble." Mrs. Bouccicault, "Hmm, hmm. This isn't the one." Kitty Brown, "Oh! You mean to say I have to say that all over again? Because that's the way I'm gonna begin."

Towney Townley, "Uh, begin what?" Kitty Brown, "Well, you see, uh, Bouccy has a certainly laid plan whereby I have to get a man. Now, would, uh, would that get you?" Towney Townley, "I don't remember what you said, but you have got me." Kitty Brown, "Oh, I like this one. Bouccy, make it this one." Bouccy, "All right, practice on him." Towney, "She doesn't seem to need practice."

Kitty Brown, "You must be a very smart person." Towney Townley, "You found me out."

Kitty Brown, starting a bridge game, "Who's going to pay my losses?" Towney Townley, "I shall be delighted. I love to have beautiful women under obligation to me."

Mrs. Bouccicault, "When you quote me, make it agreeable." Kitty Brown, "No one would believe you said it, lamb." Towney Townley, "One on you, my pet."

Mrs. Bouccicault, while a group is singing around Kitty at the piano, "Towney, is that you making that particularly bad noise?" Towney Townley, "No. I'm making the tenor." Bouccy, "Well, stop it." Kitty Brown, "Don't stop. You make the rest of us sound so good."

Towney Townley, "Kitty, you have the prettiest ears I ever saw. I wanted to kiss the right one all through dinner, especially with the salad." Whitman - 1st Butler, "Oh, Perkins. Mrs. Brown is leaving on the 11 o'clock train. It might be as well for you to assist her." Perkins, "That's just where I'm going, and without any suggestions from you."

I happened to channel surf to Turner Classic Movies just as this one was beginning last night, and once I got past the unlikely opening sequence I couldn't possibly turn away from the unlikely rest of it. It's a romantic comedy with Norma Shearer and a supporting cast that includes a lovely Hedda Hopper and a formidable Marie Dressler. As these things go -- silly rich people playing out a ridiculous "who'll pair up with whom?" plot in a Long Island mansion -- it's amusing and pretty good fun. I guess it's not a movie to recommend per se, but I have to admit I was in the mood to enjoy it last night, especially Marie Dressler's overacting. So if you stumble across it as I did, sure, go ahead, stick around. You won't believe your eyes.

When a dowdy wife (Shearer) loses her husband, she decides to completely make herself over to win him back. Not "politically correct" by today's standards, but still fun to watch, especially the scenes with Marie Dressler and Hedda Hopper.

Norma Shearer dazzles as she is transformed from a frump, addle-brained house-wife to an alluring potential divorcee. Most 1930 films have a creaky edge to them -- the camera work is pretty sluggish at times -- but we must forgive these all-talking pleasures for their thump-a-long "qualities". As a guest of the eccentric globe-trotting Marie Dressler -- Shearer mixes with an odd assortment of lovelorn types, including her long-lost husband. The dialogue is fun, oft-times clever and the performances on cue. Shearer and Dressler shine the most. Shearer even shows off her piano expertise in a musical brevity. Her strange, yet appealing posturing and "affair with the camera" are evident throughout -- and she hits every emotional note, genuinely and on target. For its time . . .a good show.