Un secret bien gardé

I can see how the story itself could have made for a great rom-com ( I heard that it was a beloved book) but this film is so poorly done. The whole things seems low budget, like a cheesy made-for-TV movie. The writing, directing, and acting are all horrible. The supporting characters seem so immature and unrealistic. Then they awkwardly throw in several f-words, silly sexual scenes and lewd references or discussions which just don't play well. It's like they couldn't decide if they wanted to do a sweet rom-com or a raunchy comedy so they fell short on both. I'm not a picky moviegoer but this is just not worth the time In My Humble Opinion!

The book is one of my absolute favorites. I read it a couple times a year so I expected to be disappointed with the movie just because they are rarely as good. That being said, even acknowledging my bias I have to say the movie came off rushed and shallow. Some of the comedic Elements just came across as flat and it felt like they couldn't decide if it was suppose to be American Pie raunchy or a sweet preteen rom com.

Just read the book. It's amazing. The movie? Don't spend money. Wait for Netflix

Good performances and directing, and I enjoyed the humor at the start, but then the story tanked with a sappy romance story and no laughs.

I haven't read the book yet, but considering the most gorgeous Alexandra is the actress, I went for it. The ratings doesn't give justice. It deserves sone early six pointers. It's a complete fun movie gets you going right from the start. Cinematographed pretty well. And the roles played by the two are even better. Having not much to expect from this movie, it still gave a lot - some a many laughs , friendship goals, couple goals. Lot to cheer about. A very happy movie. It's an underrated rom-com though not one of the finest. It's very fast paced and will end sooner than you expect. Not a must watch I say, but not a bad try either. It's just fun loving, she's very cute! 6.75/10

I'm sure people just want to be mad and hate everything, this film isn't that bad but you'd think it was the worst thing ever from some of the reviews.

Yes I've read the book, I think it's unfair to compare the two as the book is always going to be better. I've never seen a film that's better than the book

It's quite clearly a romcom so expectations should be far more realistic. And nit picking about the plot.....it's fiction. Just switch off and let it wash over you and enjoy, that's what films are made for.