NOTE IMDb
6,4/10
1,7 k
MA NOTE
Le beau-frère du nouveau patron de Janne a couché avec elle contre son gré. Elle cache l'incident et continue sa vie comme d'habitude. Mais son silence a des conséquences, non seulement pour... Tout lireLe beau-frère du nouveau patron de Janne a couché avec elle contre son gré. Elle cache l'incident et continue sa vie comme d'habitude. Mais son silence a des conséquences, non seulement pour l'amour qu'elle ressent pour son ami Piet.Le beau-frère du nouveau patron de Janne a couché avec elle contre son gré. Elle cache l'incident et continue sa vie comme d'habitude. Mais son silence a des conséquences, non seulement pour l'amour qu'elle ressent pour son ami Piet.
- Réalisation
- Scénario
- Casting principal
- Récompenses
- 13 victoires et 10 nominations au total
Avis à la une
Shows how a young woman copes with suffering in the aftermath of a sexual abuse by someone from her office. If the viewer expects to experience a fast paced emotional drama this is not the thing as it is implied in the title, in my opinion what they have in mind is how it feels to subdue everything that is bubbling inside which slowly lead to affect the mind and social relations in daily life. Unexpected cut off ending
What a strange movie. I was moderately connected to this story that portrays a woman acting as if nothing had happened, on any occasion: during a rape after a drunken evening, during a game between colleagues at a seminar, ... She is bland and lacks conviction. The actress Aenne Schwarz is extremely beautiful and plays sensitively, but the film lacks coherence, following an imperfect realization. Disappointing because of a feeling of incompleteness.
The decision of Janne to keep quiet about the incident seems to be unusual for a woman. But, it seems, on the face of it that it makes sense if the victim doesn't want to be embroiled in interminable litigation and if she shuns public scrutiny.
Her experience makes me think of the comfort women in Asia in World War II who were abused/raped by Japanese soldiers routinely. They, too, didn't complain because it was futile for them to do so given their circumstances. They didn't have a choice.
But Janne had a choice. She could have pressed charges against Martin. What she did was unnatural and it showed in the debilitating effect on her wellbeing. She tries to convince herself that this is the best way to go but she knows this is farthest from the truth.
Aenne Schwarz delivers a compelling performance as Janne. She understands all the emotions that confront Janne, and she portrays this on a subdued, almost measured, way. She animates her character totally and presents us with a gripping cautionary tale.
This is a disturbing, thought-provoking film. It's something you wouldn't want to miss.
Her experience makes me think of the comfort women in Asia in World War II who were abused/raped by Japanese soldiers routinely. They, too, didn't complain because it was futile for them to do so given their circumstances. They didn't have a choice.
But Janne had a choice. She could have pressed charges against Martin. What she did was unnatural and it showed in the debilitating effect on her wellbeing. She tries to convince herself that this is the best way to go but she knows this is farthest from the truth.
Aenne Schwarz delivers a compelling performance as Janne. She understands all the emotions that confront Janne, and she portrays this on a subdued, almost measured, way. She animates her character totally and presents us with a gripping cautionary tale.
This is a disturbing, thought-provoking film. It's something you wouldn't want to miss.
No previously written or determined way one will deal with a severe ordeal.
The girl was raped and, the minute after, she wishes to dominate it by contention and absorption of the event within herself.
I believe that would be a way for her of not getting dominated by the event or by the perpetrator.
At a certain point, however, she looses it and drops the cool. And then she is the one who dominates and confronts her raper. At this moment, when she finally lost her cool, she has at the same time won. Why not?
Annae's smile and eyes are though out the movie so multidimensional! She smiles but her eyes don't. She looks cool all along but her smile implies something else. As in Mona Lisa.
Great time watching this movie, it really adds to anything else I have seen before.
.... I haven't ever seen anything as dull as this before. That's quite an accomplishment.
Le saviez-vous
- ConnexionsReferenced in Le Monde de John (2021)
Meilleurs choix
Connectez-vous pour évaluer et suivre la liste de favoris afin de recevoir des recommandations personnalisées
- How long is All Is Well?Alimenté par Alexa
Détails
Box-office
- Montant brut mondial
- 84 399 $US
- Durée1 heure 30 minutes
- Couleur
- Rapport de forme
- 2.35 : 1
Contribuer à cette page
Suggérer une modification ou ajouter du contenu manquant
Lacune principale
What is the Brazilian Portuguese language plot outline for Comme si de rien n'était (2018)?
Répondre