2017 was an inconsistent year for Hallmark, which was not unexpected as all of their films from all the years they've been active varied in quality. Expectations were admittedly not massive for 'Romance at Reindeer Lodge', they never have been for Hallmark Christmas films. Nor were they low or was the mentality of wanting to hate it, as that's not fair on anything. The story did not sound very exciting, but Hallmark have proved more than once that they can do Christmas films that are actually above decent.
'Romance at Reindeer Lodge' is one of them, it's well above average and charming despite being a long way from perfect. As far as Hallmark's 2017 Christmas films go, 'Romance at Reindeer Lodge' is one of the better ones. While not a must watch, it is worth seeing and this is coming from somebody who is judging the film, as with every Christmas films seen over the past two years as part of my quest, on its own merits without any comparison to anything else.
Will agree with those that 'Romance at Reindeer Lodge' could have done with more romance. The chemistry is there and sweet, but the relationship itself could have been explored more and taken more time to develop. The father and son relationship also could have gone into more depth, nice idea but near-sidelined.
Had no doubt that 'Romance at Reindeer Lodge' would be formulaic, as Hallmark films nearly always are, but did think that the pace could have been tighter in the early parts and that the ending could have felt less rushed and pat. Like other Hallmark Christmas films, it's all pleasant enough if safe.
Nicky Whelan however plays her refereshingly more grounded character (compared to a lot of female lead characters with Hallmark) with charm and dignity and comes over as very likeable. Josh Kelly is a subtly confident and sympathetic leading man too and while the relationship is not explored enough their chemistry is genuine and low key. Robert Pine and Beth Broderick are solid support.
Production values are quite nice, especially the scenery. The decorations are nostalgic and affectionately festive, not looking cheap. Hallmark Christmas films can be over-scored, but it fitted just about right and wasn't too drab or melancholic even if it doesn't wow. The direction is more than competent. The script isn't stilted, too cheesy or schmaltzy and while the story is far from perfect it has plenty of light-hearted and heart-warming moments and had characters worth caring for (the latter not always the case with Hallmark.
Overall, doesn't wow but a pleasant watch. A small 7/10.
