Le Chant du loup

This movie depicts a topical and realistic situation, with the codes of most major big-budget movie. The cast is well chosen and overall does a good job of portraying what many would expect the French navy to be like. But in my opinion, the most successful trait of the movie is its storyline, stemming from contemporary stakes, which I've rarely seen in military/tactical movies, which instead tend to focus on past historical events or on more far-fetched futuristic scenarios. I think that's the reason the story is so compelling, and why I personally found the movie so immersive.

There's a lot of reviews here making points such as "could not happen".

Ok sure, there's some unrealistic stuff going on.

But there's also a lot of original and thoughtful scenes that are explored. There's a lot of ideas here that feel completely fresh.

The idea that a French submarine, once committed to a nuclear strike, will not receive any orders to abort, is a weak one. Unfortunately a large part of the movie hinges around this concept. The second half of the movie does feel a little silly at times because of this.

I liked the sonar guy as the hero.

Very engaging film. From start to finish it hooked me and there was never a dull moment. Good actors, well thought out plot with excellent follow through in its development.

Will watch again and highly recommend it.

The sub (sub) genre of action movies is a small one, but there have been a couple of good hits. Crimson Tide and The Hunt for Red October may be the only couple of good ones off the top of my head in the last 30 years.

This French language film popped up on Netflix, and I'm glad I watched it. The film follows a sub crew as they confront a realistic crisis of Russian aggression and terrorism. The main character, Chanteraide (François Civil) is a sub listener, and there are tense moments as he must figure out if the sound he hears is a far off whale, or a torpedo coming for the kill. The cast is filled out with a host of French actors, many of who I recognized from other films.

The film is more a suspense than an action film, more Red October, and less Crimson Tide in that sense, but there are some very good action scenes. The plot is not unique, but very well executed, and sets up some very well done moral dilemmas, again similar to Crimson Tide.

These moral dilemmas end up being the best part of the film but unfortunately could have been an even larger part of the film, a rare missed opportunity in the film.

Although it fails to achieve in several areas, it still sets itself apart from the average drone of current action films. Although I am tempteted to give it an 8, 7/10 is the review. Don't deep six this one!

Reading the reviews here, it seems to be a love it or hate it movie - I don't understand why. I grew up watching the original Das Boot as TV series and went through all the submarine movies. Instead of comparing the incomparable and saying what is flawed etc., I simply want to point out what I liked watching this movie twice:

• refreshing actor set, no B-movie characters just like "could be your neighbour" type
• storyline that could happen, although we normal people would never hear about it
• great music/ambience perfectly fitting the setting
• straightforward effects, less is more
• happy end without happy end, evoked emotions
• overall a very refreshing, non-cliche Hollywood-type movie.