L'Atlantide a-t-elle vraiment existé ?
Titre original : Atlantis Rising
- Téléfilm
- 2017
- Tous publics
- 1h 33min
NOTE IMDb
6,3/10
819
MA NOTE
Ajouter une intrigue dans votre langueHollywood legend James Cameron and filmmaker Simcha Jacobovici go on an adventure to find the lost city of Atlantis by using Greek philosopher Plato as a virtual treasure map.Hollywood legend James Cameron and filmmaker Simcha Jacobovici go on an adventure to find the lost city of Atlantis by using Greek philosopher Plato as a virtual treasure map.Hollywood legend James Cameron and filmmaker Simcha Jacobovici go on an adventure to find the lost city of Atlantis by using Greek philosopher Plato as a virtual treasure map.
- Réalisation
- Scénario
- Casting principal
Avis à la une
This is an amazing documentary. No matter what people say. Very important and to me all new knowledge. I ended up so curious and not to long after that very sad that there was no next episode. Felt like an open ending. Dig it up, show us more.
Very interesting look at the origins / location of the city of Atlantis, based on the writings of Plato.
James Cameron only had a cameo in this, despite getting top billing. What this documentary does do, is analyse all the supposed locations of Atlantis, it's colonies across the Mediterranean and into the Atlantic.
It does systemically look at each proposed location, with some archaeological work being done, building a clearer picture of the civilisation until they reach a satisfying (to a degree) conclusion, with evidence, as to where the destroyed city should be.
They need to make a follow-up where they carry out some archaeological work in the final location!!
James Cameron only had a cameo in this, despite getting top billing. What this documentary does do, is analyse all the supposed locations of Atlantis, it's colonies across the Mediterranean and into the Atlantic.
It does systemically look at each proposed location, with some archaeological work being done, building a clearer picture of the civilisation until they reach a satisfying (to a degree) conclusion, with evidence, as to where the destroyed city should be.
They need to make a follow-up where they carry out some archaeological work in the final location!!
This doco is nothing but stupid speculation. They are looking at all the wrong places, trying to make unfitting pieces of puzzle fit. I went into this documentary film with great anticipation only to be disappointed.
Being in the Naval engineering profession I know people who have all the answers Cameron is looking for. They have tried tooth and nail to contact him and did not even receive a short reply as courtesy. Arrogance and celebrity-godship has blinded James Cameron to the point he is only in touch with celebrities and so called celeb-experts.
Used to be a fan of James Cameron; no longer.
Being in the Naval engineering profession I know people who have all the answers Cameron is looking for. They have tried tooth and nail to contact him and did not even receive a short reply as courtesy. Arrogance and celebrity-godship has blinded James Cameron to the point he is only in touch with celebrities and so called celeb-experts.
Used to be a fan of James Cameron; no longer.
... and could well start to rise again this year. As this cycle repeats itself regularly and as we are ushering into the "Age of Aquarius". Compare "Aquaman", King Arthur, Antichrist.
Atlantis sunk because of its decadent society and its reveling into black magic. But this coincides with cosmic cycles. Therefore, civilizations seem to develop according to the "Maya factor" (José Arguelles).
After the imminent pole shift (a geophysical event of global magnitude, expected for 2023), mankind will be made believe it has already surpassed Armageddon and that Christ has returned (supported by the arrivals of fake aliens), when in reality it is prone to the ultimate temptation (compare Mark 24).
Atlantis sunk because of its decadent society and its reveling into black magic. But this coincides with cosmic cycles. Therefore, civilizations seem to develop according to the "Maya factor" (José Arguelles).
After the imminent pole shift (a geophysical event of global magnitude, expected for 2023), mankind will be made believe it has already surpassed Armageddon and that Christ has returned (supported by the arrivals of fake aliens), when in reality it is prone to the ultimate temptation (compare Mark 24).
Another of the James Cameron documentaries that are on Disney Plus as part of the National Geographic strand, "Atlantis Rising" sees Cameron . . . away making Avatar sequels, whilst his collaborator, Simcha Jacobvici does the work and reports in.
Since it's mention in a book by Plato, the "lost continent of Atlantis" has been inspiration for fiction. Here, Simcha Jacobvici begins a quest leaping around the Mediterranean and the Atlantic, tracking down various leads to work out where it might have been. With a degree of speculation, Simcha makes some interesting discoveries and explores some theories. He reports back to James Cameron every so often on his progress and they analyse the ideas.
It's not much of a spoiler, as it might have made the news had he actually done it, but the team don't manage to find definitive proof of Atlantis. They do make some significate discoveries, mostly the discovery of anchor stones in various locations that they perhaps wouldn't have been expected, suggesting the location of islands that operated almost like weigh stations, before ships would move the actual ports. They also find some evidence that that distance travelled by people at various points in history might actually be much further than previously thought.
But, and I say this with the full acknowledgement that I don't have any significant studies of history, particularly cultural history - but some of the film's ideas felt like a stretch to me. Scratches in ancient rocks are taken to be pictures of Atlantis, or an odd shape is a boat. Trying to build links between the various disparate cultures around the Med' feels, to me more like coincidence - or best practice, rather than a proof of refugee's starting a new life.
But, unlike some of the other similar documentaries I've been watching recently, at least with this one I was entertained all the way though. A follow up, with the continued research, would be worthwhile.
Since it's mention in a book by Plato, the "lost continent of Atlantis" has been inspiration for fiction. Here, Simcha Jacobvici begins a quest leaping around the Mediterranean and the Atlantic, tracking down various leads to work out where it might have been. With a degree of speculation, Simcha makes some interesting discoveries and explores some theories. He reports back to James Cameron every so often on his progress and they analyse the ideas.
It's not much of a spoiler, as it might have made the news had he actually done it, but the team don't manage to find definitive proof of Atlantis. They do make some significate discoveries, mostly the discovery of anchor stones in various locations that they perhaps wouldn't have been expected, suggesting the location of islands that operated almost like weigh stations, before ships would move the actual ports. They also find some evidence that that distance travelled by people at various points in history might actually be much further than previously thought.
But, and I say this with the full acknowledgement that I don't have any significant studies of history, particularly cultural history - but some of the film's ideas felt like a stretch to me. Scratches in ancient rocks are taken to be pictures of Atlantis, or an odd shape is a boat. Trying to build links between the various disparate cultures around the Med' feels, to me more like coincidence - or best practice, rather than a proof of refugee's starting a new life.
But, unlike some of the other similar documentaries I've been watching recently, at least with this one I was entertained all the way though. A follow up, with the continued research, would be worthwhile.
Meilleurs choix
Connectez-vous pour évaluer et suivre la liste de favoris afin de recevoir des recommandations personnalisées
Détails
- Date de sortie
- Pays d’origine
- Sites officiels
- Langue
- Aussi connu sous le nom de
- Atlantide, la cité perdue
- Lieux de tournage
- Sociétés de production
- Voir plus de crédits d'entreprise sur IMDbPro
- Durée
- 1h 33min(93 min)
- Couleur
Contribuer à cette page
Suggérer une modification ou ajouter du contenu manquant