Ryû ga Gotoku ~Beyond the Game~

It was clear from the trailers that this wasn't going to be in any way related to the plot and characters of the games so I tried to watch it as a yakuza (lower case) series. It still didn't work. A main aspect of any film or TV show is that that the characters need to be engaging. I didn't care for any of them, one way or another.

The timeline jumps are confusing and there are far too many characters to keep track of.

There isn't even much going on or a plot to follow, it's just random scenes, one after another, which isn't helped by the flat characters. Nor is there much insight into Yakuza traditions, culture and procedures and of those there are, some of them are wrong.

Even Tokyo Vice does a much better job of portraying the Yakuza lifestyle.

I was hoping for something similar to the Fallout series which was brilliant: take the background/history/world from the games and tell a new story with it so you don't need to have played the games to understand what's going on. Everything looked like it did in the games.

In LaD:Y, all that atmosphere is missing. There isn't enough of Kamurocho (the real life Kabukicho). It just feels empty, nothing has character.

I played though yakuza 1 and i expected this show to be a little different from the game but it more like the halo show. The characters aren't how they are. The show is dark it hard to see things in it. The 2007 film was a better adaptation of the game. It was more faithful than this show. Some of the games plot is not here at all. In yakuza 1 kazama is in his late 30s early 40s in the show he like 25 or something it not faithful to the games. I was expecting something better then this but i was disappointed by this show for not being very faithful to the games it feels like the writers didn't play the games.

As an avid fan and player of the Yakuza games, I was surprised and a little cautiously optimistic when I saw this announced and being done by the creator of the game series. It has potential I will say that much. Although the casting leaves much to be desired. The role of Kiryu being played by a skinny little dude didn't fly for me and he just did not look the part. I also did not appreciate them glazing over Goro Majima's story arc in the span of 1/4 of an episode if that. Yakuza 0 is to date my all time favorite Yakuza game simply because of how fleshed out Majima's story arc is and what he had to go thru, his rise and ultimate fall within his clan was one of the best storylines in the entire franchise and yet it was just slapped together in a couple of scenes in the show for what I'm assuming is time constraints. But I digress. It is just one of the shows many issues. Another big one is in its pacing. The show time jumps between 2 eras, 1995 and 2005, respectively, yet for the life of me feels harder to follow at times than listening to a Scotsman talk after downing a keg of whiskey. What I did enjoy were some of the fight scenes and brawls when it felt a little bit like the Yakuza games in tandem with an interesting final episode when the culprit behind the attacks is revealed. Like I said there's potential here somewhere buried beneath its poor casting, pacing and execution. Also, who knows if this will even get renewed for a season two as it doesn't seem to be fairly well received I've noticed and I'm glad I'm not the only one who thinks so. I do not think I'll be returning if there is a second season since it has way too many issues than praises. In the end perhaps the Yakuza series is best left in video game form, where you play as beefy Japanese gangster studs who happen to occasionally infiltrate underground man baby dens who's fetishes are to dress up as babies and get coddled by women. Now that's what this show adaptation is truly missing. Overall, I can't recommend this one as much as I wish I could as it is yet another miss for the long list of video game to movie/TV show adaptations. The good ones are just few and far between. Just play the games instead.

Even as a big Ryu Ga Gotoku fan, I would've been fine with story changes, after all Yakuza games get really silly with their storylines and sudden plot twists. However, this show makes no sense and it doesn't respect the source material at all. Kiryu is shown to be a polar opposite of what he is in the games, like all other characters including Kazama, Yumi and Nishikiyama. I can understand trying to have the characters grow as the story progresses, but this was terribly executed.

Not only that but the lore changes are completely awful and pull you back from the story. For instance, Kazama being away from the Yakuza, instead of being this behind-the-scenes mastermind? Really?

The sets and the overall costume design are awful too. It simply doesn't look like the characters are in 1995 nor 2005. No visuals nor looks match the iconic first two decades of Japan's Heisei era. For instance, where is Dojima's mustache? Everyone looks like they walked straight from 2024. Tokyo Vice, another Yakuza Crime show that came out in the last few years, has no issues portraying this era with beautiful sets and having people wear correct attires. The set designs don't reflect the epic/grandeur locations of the games, which is a bummer, as this show would've benefited from those opulent locations.

Overall, I am torn that this came out as terrible as it did. I wish the writers took better care of this source material. I am not saying that changes weren't needed, but this is the complete opposite of how the games are, and even ignoring that, this story is simply not good to stand in its two feet. There are a lot of complete remakes, such as Scarface (1983) and Battlestar Galactica (2003), that manage to be their own thing without disrespecting the source material. Here, unlike those, the writers clearly thought they were improving upon the original story, instead of trying to reimagine/ make their own thing. Well, the overall result is as weak as watery grape soda. No, it's not grape juice, this is just water with some grape in it. Awful.

To be honest, if they had approached this like Judgment-setting it in the same universe but with new characters and a new story-I wouldn't dislike this series nearly as much. The cast for this show was very promising, all actors were prolific actors, the Director directed 100 yen Love and Naked Director.

The main issue is that they took characters from the original game, dumbed down their motives, and completely missed the mark. During an interview the director confessed that he wanted to create something more than the game, he ask everyone in the cast to not play the game beforehand. He wanted to make something that is favorable by audience that are not familiar with the game. Hence the second title "beyond the game"

It's clear that they don't grasp the depth and complexity of the Yakuza game, and because of that, they've created something that is shallow compare to the source material, yet they seem to believe they've somehow surpassed the source material.