ÉVALUATION IMDb
7,2/10
20 k
MA NOTE
Adaptation cinématographique de la tuerie de Montréal en 1989 où plusieurs étudiantes de polytechnique furent assassinées par un misogyne instable.Adaptation cinématographique de la tuerie de Montréal en 1989 où plusieurs étudiantes de polytechnique furent assassinées par un misogyne instable.Adaptation cinématographique de la tuerie de Montréal en 1989 où plusieurs étudiantes de polytechnique furent assassinées par un misogyne instable.
- Director
- Writers
- Stars
- Prix
- 17 victoires et 10 nominations au total
Martin Watier
- Jean-François
- (voice)
Natalie Hamel-Roy
- Jean-François' Mother
- (voice)
- (as Nathalie Hamel-Roy)
Avis en vedette
I've read many comments by people stating that this film is bias because it only reflects the point of view of the victims who were mainly female and that is just giving support to the feminist movement but that is not the case.
This film isn't about the shooter, it isn't about the families...it's about the victims/survivors of this horrific ordeal. It does not focus on the background of the killer, it does not explain in great detail why he committed this terrible act of violence... it depicts what the victims/survivors went through.
Some people tend to feel empathic for the shooter, commenting on the fact that he felt prosecuted for his gender and that he felt threatened and hatred for females who in his own opinion were taking jobs away from males who deserved them... Kind of like the two shooters from Columbine who to some people became a icon for anti-bullying, thinking that the only reason they committed these crimes was because they were prosecuted by their peers and the community. It doesn't change the fact that both the Columbine shooters and Marc Lepine took innocent lives and then so cowardly take their own.
Some people liken this movie to "Elephant" and I agree but it also reminds me of "April Showers" since both movies did not focus on the killer but on the people who suffered through the event.
This film isn't about the shooter, it isn't about the families...it's about the victims/survivors of this horrific ordeal. It does not focus on the background of the killer, it does not explain in great detail why he committed this terrible act of violence... it depicts what the victims/survivors went through.
Some people tend to feel empathic for the shooter, commenting on the fact that he felt prosecuted for his gender and that he felt threatened and hatred for females who in his own opinion were taking jobs away from males who deserved them... Kind of like the two shooters from Columbine who to some people became a icon for anti-bullying, thinking that the only reason they committed these crimes was because they were prosecuted by their peers and the community. It doesn't change the fact that both the Columbine shooters and Marc Lepine took innocent lives and then so cowardly take their own.
Some people liken this movie to "Elephant" and I agree but it also reminds me of "April Showers" since both movies did not focus on the killer but on the people who suffered through the event.
An amazing little French Canadian film about the Quebec massacre. Personally I recommend watching everything Denis Villeneuve has made. This guy is among the greatest living directors in the world right now and he is definitely making some of the most interesting films of our time...Incendies, Prisoners, Arrival, etc. This is one of the films Denis made before he became well known. I've seen everything he's made now except for his newest version of Dune, which I'll check out in the theatre when it opens in October. Every single one of his films was well worth the watch! Forget the overhyped Fincher and Nolan of the newer generation of directors, this guy easily wipes the floor with them. In my view, Denis is definitely the most interesting filmmaker alive today that hasn't made anything prior to the mid 1990's. 7/10.
As a piece of cinema, this is truly a sight to behold. The filming is beautiful in its ability to tell the story of a horrific shooting in Montreal in 1989. The black and white filming and the direction remind of the "Dekalog" by Krzysztof Kieslowski.
The acting is exceptional. The performance by a young Karine Vanasse is powerful in its understated subtlety.
The story is deeply moving. This type of plot isn't for everyone, but if realistic drama is enjoyable to you, as it is to me, then you will be impressed by the quality of this movie.
The acting is exceptional. The performance by a young Karine Vanasse is powerful in its understated subtlety.
The story is deeply moving. This type of plot isn't for everyone, but if realistic drama is enjoyable to you, as it is to me, then you will be impressed by the quality of this movie.
In contrast to the perpetrator's actions at the École Polytechnique in 1989, Denis Villeneuve's interpretation of the events is graceful, tactful and meaningful. Filmed in black and white, ostensibly in order to give the presence of blood a less invading quality, Polytechnique begins in the hours leading up to the attack and parallelly follows the killer and three of the affected students: two female victims and one male bystander who desperately tries to find the right course of action in the midst of the chaos. The film is narratively economical and passes no judgement explicitly. Instead Villeneuve lets the characters' actions speak volumes, and he gives his picture an extra zest by including some subtle jumps between timelines. An artistically fulfilled movie with a hard-hitting subject matter which would be Villeneuve's first stepping-stone towards larger projects.
Since I'm really really looking forward to seeing Dune in the future, I felt like checking out this early film from Denis Villeneuve's filmography. This movie's based on a real-life tragedy that occurred at the Polytechnique Montreal engineering school in 1989, and it dramatizes the event in a way that feels very humanistic. It doesn't make any comments or draw conclusions about the event and still leaves you feeling for most of the people involved. It does a great job of being ambiguous, something Villeneuve has mastered throughout his filmography. My heart goes out to the survivors, and my thanks go out to Villeneuve for being so great at making films like this.
Le saviez-vous
- AnecdotesDirector Denis Villeneuve was disappointed with his first two movies, Un 32 août sur terre (1998) and Maelström (2000), so he took a nine-year sabbatical as a stay-at-home dad. He vowed to return "when I was ready to make a film I could be proud of", which was Polytechnique (2009).
- Autres versionsIn addition to the French-Canadian language version, an English language version was also shot (back-to-back).
- ConnexionsFeatured in The Hour: Episode #7.83 (2011)
- Bandes originalesTainted Love
Written by Ed Cobb
Performed by Mark Arnell
Embassy Music Corporation
With permission of Music Sales Corporation
Meilleurs choix
Connectez-vous pour évaluer et surveiller les recommandations personnalisées
- How long is Polytechnique?Propulsé par Alexa
Détails
- Durée1 heure 17 minutes
- Couleur
- Mixage
- Rapport de forme
- 2.35 : 1
Contribuer à cette page
Suggérer une modification ou ajouter du contenu manquant