Shakuntala Devi
- 2020
- 2h 7m
ÉVALUATION IMDb
6,2/10
9,9 k
MA NOTE
Le parcours d'une mathématicienne pour devenir «The Human Computer» et sa relation avec sa fille.Le parcours d'une mathématicienne pour devenir «The Human Computer» et sa relation avec sa fille.Le parcours d'une mathématicienne pour devenir «The Human Computer» et sa relation avec sa fille.
- Prix
- 13 nominations au total
Jisshu Sengupta
- Paritosh Banerji
- (as Jishu Sengupta)
Avis en vedette
Such a farce! In the process of showing Shakuntala Devi's prowess they got Vidya Balan to overact quite a bit. The movie should have been a different kind of drama in the league of A Beautiful Mind, but it ended being a masala drama.
Bad mothers. Worse daughters. Occasional south Indian accents. Unnecessary songs.
It's not a movie about mathematics. It's a movie about dysfunctional mother-daughter relationship. Vidya Balan acts like a demented person, always giggling and snorting under uncomfortable or embarrassing circumstances. Sanya Malhotra keeps complaining about everything and is quite annoying. She is mad at her mother for being a psychotic obsessive person. Amit Sadh is exceptional once again. Everyone else is forgettable.
P.S. Mathematics is a lot more than multiplications.
P.S. Mathematics is a lot more than multiplications.
After a back to back disappointed Direct Digital Release from Prime Video looks like we kinda have the better one. Still, not the best!
Shakuntala Devi works only when you consider this as a pure Bollywood entertainer instead of looking it as a movie based on a real life person. The movie gets most of the things wrong, that's why the makers haven't claimed this to be a Biopic. Still, I felt they went too much with the "creative liberty"
Vidya Balan as Shakuntala Devi shines in a few moments but also wasn't that convincing, I'm not saying the performance was atrocious. Felt it was more of a "mothers & Daughters" conflict tale than the portrayal of a Mathematical genius.
Sachin-Jigar's music was okayish. Keiko's Cinematography and the color grading of the film was aesthetical and it went quite well with the layered narrative. The 127mins seems really long, especially after the first half of the movie. That's when the monotonous feel hits.
To sum up Shakuntala Devi is yet an another Bollywood Melodramatic Movie with the label of "Inspired by the true events." And definitely not a Re-Watchable worthy!
Shakuntala Devi works only when you consider this as a pure Bollywood entertainer instead of looking it as a movie based on a real life person. The movie gets most of the things wrong, that's why the makers haven't claimed this to be a Biopic. Still, I felt they went too much with the "creative liberty"
Vidya Balan as Shakuntala Devi shines in a few moments but also wasn't that convincing, I'm not saying the performance was atrocious. Felt it was more of a "mothers & Daughters" conflict tale than the portrayal of a Mathematical genius.
Sachin-Jigar's music was okayish. Keiko's Cinematography and the color grading of the film was aesthetical and it went quite well with the layered narrative. The 127mins seems really long, especially after the first half of the movie. That's when the monotonous feel hits.
To sum up Shakuntala Devi is yet an another Bollywood Melodramatic Movie with the label of "Inspired by the true events." And definitely not a Re-Watchable worthy!
Shakuntala Devi.Anu Menon.2020
Based on the life journey of profoundly known Human computer aka Shakuntala Devi, the film tries to fit in her 84 glorious years in 120 minutes screen time. The film stabs to touch major life milestones of her life from her genius mathematics career to conflict with her own daughter and to her dilemma in life to her flawed rapport with her husband.
But the film fails to bring out her psyche, mental vows and keeps spinning around her analogous achievements throughout. Many of her vital scenes are mere caricaturish portrayal to make it look breezy and to reflect her sense of humor with no depth in it. No doubt Balan tries hard with her accents, body language, hiatuses but still the film lacks in the clarity of thought.
Based on the life journey of profoundly known Human computer aka Shakuntala Devi, the film tries to fit in her 84 glorious years in 120 minutes screen time. The film stabs to touch major life milestones of her life from her genius mathematics career to conflict with her own daughter and to her dilemma in life to her flawed rapport with her husband.
But the film fails to bring out her psyche, mental vows and keeps spinning around her analogous achievements throughout. Many of her vital scenes are mere caricaturish portrayal to make it look breezy and to reflect her sense of humor with no depth in it. No doubt Balan tries hard with her accents, body language, hiatuses but still the film lacks in the clarity of thought.
Typical Bollywood masala movie. Overdramatic and bizzare script. Just like Bollywood ruined mission mangal they have successfully ruined the movie. At least the makers would have watched the man who knew infinity. Poor script and direction. Acting of Vidya Balan and all others except Santa Malhotra is top class.
How Shakuntala Devi Inspired Vidya Balan
How Shakuntala Devi Inspired Vidya Balan
Actress Vidya Balan tells IMDb which Shakuntala Devi scenes made her feel closer to the flamboyant character she was playing.
Le saviez-vous
- AnecdotesPrakash Belwadi who plays Vidya Balan's father in the film had said Kannada industry should have made a film on Shakuntala Devi.
- Citations
Shakuntala Devi: [Anu Menon says Indians hate mathematics on the contrary Indians love mathematics]
Meilleurs choix
Connectez-vous pour évaluer et surveiller les recommandations personnalisées
- How long is Shakuntala Devi?Propulsé par Alexa
Détails
- Durée2 heures 7 minutes
- Couleur
Contribuer à cette page
Suggérer une modification ou ajouter du contenu manquant