indirectpointer

I am enjoying this immensely. To date I have watched episodes 1-34.

It is an investment of time and energy if you choose to watch this. The plot is dense, not for the faint of heart or for those who do not like subtitles. Please don't let the botched attempt in the first few minutes to paint a historical backstory deter you. I almost stopped watching after those first few minutes. Fortunately I ignored it, hung in there, and waited to learn what was going on.

It is the complex plot and the acting which has my rapt attention. The intrigues at court are more convoluted and fascinating than any soap opera has ever been. Plots within plots, hidden motives and alliances. That said, the beautiful, ornate sets and fabulous costumes are superb and warrant an Emmy for that alone.

Great acting by the two main characters with marvelous support from other actors. The actor playing Ning Yi, the character who returns from banishment in the first episode, portrays him as complex, lovable, and relentless. The character reminds me of a historical character (described in the I Ching) that was caught like a fly in a complex, life-threatening web at court. He chose to dissemble, pretending to be insane in order to cloak his true purposes until it was safe to reveal his intentions. But Ning Yi is so clever and multilayered that I am not certain that he is ever clear on his own motives. The main female character, Feng Zhi Wei, who cross-dresses (new name Wei Zhi), so that she is able to become a scholar, an official, and eventually the Emperor's favorite advisor, was a joy. I was grateful to see a female character arising from modern Chinese culture who so much more intelligent and wily than her peers -- she ran circles around them and then enlisted them to help her. That made me smile.

My favorite secondary character is Xin Ziyan. He is head of the Qingming Academy, where young, capable, and ambitious men are trained scholastically, socially, and in the martial arts. He is subtle, nimbly jumping in and out of the centers of power. He never manages to bow quite as deeply as the others, and always enjoys himself with wine, wives and poetry. He is ambiguous. He admits the ferocity and importance of the political struggles but never takes it overly seriously. With bemused detachment he still manages to keep his prince Ning Yi focused on the important issues.

The character playing the Emperor Ning Shizheng does a great job of acting without acting. He uses a variety of techniques to portay an emperor -- an almost constant mask (a straight face), very occasional and careful explosions, showing how and what he chooses to attend to, and my favorite, placing and then watching the royal princes' behavior in various situations. He is able to suggest what it might have been like to be at the center of all those machinations. Seemingly the one with most power and yet the one most trapped in a role.

A brief sentence to note the performance of the Crown Prince , who is portrayed both diabolically and sympathetically. It is a rare thing for me to feel some empathy toward a character who is not above slaughtering 1/10 of the others. But he managed to show how his behavior arose not only out of unwanted ambition but misdirected desire to please this all-powerful father.

----------

For those who want a little bit more history with their historical drama, or if you find this sort of thing to be enjoyable, I strongly suggest watching the Korean historical drama series Queen Seondeok. It has much greater attention to historical detail and recounts the story of the first reigning queen of Shila, one of the three kingdoms of Korea. Queen Seondeok was described as "generous, benevolent, wise, and smart." The story was interesting, but I particularly liked its superlative female acting. The actress playing Queen Seondeok was wonderful and showed exemplary character development abilities. But it was the villainess, lady Mishil, who still wins my vote for the most clever and nefarious female villain ever. Best of all, that series has the best bad boy, of all time Bidam -- innocent, complex, devoted and a superb martial artist. (Although Bidam doesn't come into the story until the end of the 21st episode!).

!! I would definitely not allow young children watch this documentary. !! And I would only allow older children (particularly animal lovers or tender hearted kids) watch it with someone there to talk about it afterward. I am glad that I watched it because it was eye opening, but it was a painful film for me. My stomach hurt afterward because it was in knots for most of the film. I kept wanting to say, "OK! You had my sympathies after the first 10 minutes, quit beating me over the head with reality! I know what you think the facts are now and where to search on the Internet effectively on this topic now -- thanks -- but where is there a possible hopeful future?!" A documentary needs balance to be truly effective. I decided to stop watching it 3/4 of the way through because I'd already gotten the point and couldn't stand having it drilled into me more without anesthesia. I did zip to the end in case there was a change of tone, but to no avail. On the positive side: this was an eye-opening documentary, which gave interviews with the people who actually interact with Orcas (the film was one long collection of interviews). There were facts presented, which appear at first blush to be correct, and the OSHA perspective was a valuable counterpoint to the interviews with trainers (OSHA pushed to require trainers to be behind a barrier during the spectacles for safety reasons). It is unfortunate that Sea World did not give their perspective, and their silence is very damning. The biggest negative comment that I would make is that the documentary did a very poor job of finding hope in this situation. In documentary films "a spoon full of sugar helps the medicine go down." Some filmmakers use humor for that purpose but talk about better futures would have helped. -- If you are reading this review and happen to have been involved in creating the documentary, well kudos to you for a very thorough and effective job. But please watch some Jacques Cousteau before creating the next one. He had a real knack for creating beautiful, effective documentaries about difficult ecological topics, with hope. -- Finally, I couldn't help thinking, while watching this film, about the Indians who welcomed the Pilgrims to a new land, and what our ancestors did to them. Too close an analogy. What must Orcas think of us?