ibizahound

I'd heard about this film, passed the marquee daily to and from work and had wanted to see it in the theater but for whatever reason I didn't. Boy, am I kicking myself now! What a great film this is. And how much greater would it have been in the theater! The Dogma-style film-making, whether intended or not, was a wonderful surprise. I loved feeling like I wasn't really supposed to be there, that I was witnessing something so private and pure. I am a fan of Richard Linklater's Sunrise/Sunset as well as Julie Delphy's (obviously Linklater inspired) 2 Days in Paris and, of course, Lars Von Trier. But there was something so pure in Once that separates it from the others. Maybe it was because even though their relationship was complicated it played out so smoothly and without force. They loved one another enough to realize that no matter their pasts or their individual futures they had that week and even a tangible memory of it. Both actors were honestly believable. Highly recommended to anyone who loves a good story, good music and isn't afraid to let their emotions go.

I really wanted to like this film but it barely eked out a 3. It's surprising that equal amounts of the votes were 10, the other half 1. All the characters were entertaining and even talented but as a whole the film didn't pay off. Sebastian Hernandez is appealing; charismatic and likable (he even physically resembles Marc Anthony in a more approachable yet ultimately conscious sort of way...) but even he couldn't save this mess of a movie. Scenes dragged on far too long and points were ultimately beaten to death. The banana scene fringed on self-absorption, seemingly showing how much movement was in his boxers. But in his defense it was his first movie as director (that I'm aware of) and I appreciate his labor of love. It just left me empty despite what was trying to be said. Ultimately I think the story would have been better handled by a more experienced director. From what I've seen of the 'extras', there is a real story behind this and, perhaps when I finish watching them, I'll appreciate this attempt more.