SonOfSalem
mar 2011 se unió
Te damos la bienvenida a nuevo perfil
Nuestras actualizaciones aún están en desarrollo. Si bien la versión anterior de el perfil ya no está disponible, estamos trabajando activamente en mejoras, ¡y algunas de las funciones que faltan regresarán pronto! Mantente al tanto para su regreso. Mientras tanto, el análisis de calificaciones sigue disponible en nuestras aplicaciones para iOS y Android, en la página de perfil. Para ver la distribución de tus calificaciones por año y género, consulta nuestra nueva Guía de ayuda.
Distintivos2
Para saber cómo ganar distintivos, ve a página de ayuda de distintivos.
Calificaciones14
Clasificación de SonOfSalem
Reseñas5
Clasificación de SonOfSalem
If you are visually orientated and /or a fan of Ridley Scott, or Micheal Fassbender go see it now. Go. If however you like a bit more kick from your drug of choice, you might end up leaving the cinema with no more than a slight buzz..
Personally, I found the writing and structuring to be pretty bad. It feels like a rushed lukewarm patchwork of a plot, held together by largely disinterested actors. And I don't blame them. Micheal Fassbender does indeed stand out, and I am a big fan of his. His portrayal of the tragic Bobby Sands was both moving and visceral, and I always get a strong sense of professionalism from him; a kind of controlled efficiency that may or may not have helped land him the part of David.
Idris Elba, another excellent actor, capable of deep intensity, who has had two seasons of the British detective TV show Luther under his belt, completely wasted and unchallenged by his cookie cutter role as captain Janek, bewilderingly sporting a fake American drawl that took with it, the last chance for his character having any kind of possibility for the expression of depth, facilitated by his tough East London accent.
I thought Noomi Rapace was very good and stood out, but nothing like her form in The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo trilogy. When she is more comfortable with English speaking roles, I think her confidence and self expression will make her shine once more.
The characterization as mentioned above, sometimes slapped logic, feasibility and believability right in the nut-sack almost from the get go. I just felt very little for them and it barley changed for me all the way through the movie. So why am I so hard on this? It is just a movie right? It's because I don't like snake oil salesmen; they are far too numerous in my opinion and I certainly don't approve of one of my favorite directors working in their employ. Prometheus has been touted to be something it very much is not, what with the hyped deep philosophical nature of its subject matter, mass marketing, like Guy Pierce doing the Ted Talk, and clever trailer manipulation, (* but all movies do "the pitch"*) yet it fails to even come close to living up to said hype.
Instead, what we get is stilted dialogue dressed in all these metaphorical/pseudo intellectual fortune cookie snippets of wisdom and weak introspection tacked onto weird episodic structuring that sometimes, folds back on itself rather unnecessarily lending a feeling of repetition that keeps reemerging during the movie,(remind you of "Lost" anyone?).
And then there is the science...
In conclusion, If you are a fan of hard sci-fi from the likes of Ian. M. Banks or Isaac Asimov, Sagan or Clark you may be more critical and less forgiving than most. My rant about the writing is fuelled by my love of this hard sci-fi that unfortunately, I thought this was going to be. So it's probably my fault. I was after all, a willing participant in the con.
I give this 5/10 I hate giving any movie attached to Ridley Scott such a low score.
Personally, I found the writing and structuring to be pretty bad. It feels like a rushed lukewarm patchwork of a plot, held together by largely disinterested actors. And I don't blame them. Micheal Fassbender does indeed stand out, and I am a big fan of his. His portrayal of the tragic Bobby Sands was both moving and visceral, and I always get a strong sense of professionalism from him; a kind of controlled efficiency that may or may not have helped land him the part of David.
Idris Elba, another excellent actor, capable of deep intensity, who has had two seasons of the British detective TV show Luther under his belt, completely wasted and unchallenged by his cookie cutter role as captain Janek, bewilderingly sporting a fake American drawl that took with it, the last chance for his character having any kind of possibility for the expression of depth, facilitated by his tough East London accent.
I thought Noomi Rapace was very good and stood out, but nothing like her form in The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo trilogy. When she is more comfortable with English speaking roles, I think her confidence and self expression will make her shine once more.
The characterization as mentioned above, sometimes slapped logic, feasibility and believability right in the nut-sack almost from the get go. I just felt very little for them and it barley changed for me all the way through the movie. So why am I so hard on this? It is just a movie right? It's because I don't like snake oil salesmen; they are far too numerous in my opinion and I certainly don't approve of one of my favorite directors working in their employ. Prometheus has been touted to be something it very much is not, what with the hyped deep philosophical nature of its subject matter, mass marketing, like Guy Pierce doing the Ted Talk, and clever trailer manipulation, (* but all movies do "the pitch"*) yet it fails to even come close to living up to said hype.
Instead, what we get is stilted dialogue dressed in all these metaphorical/pseudo intellectual fortune cookie snippets of wisdom and weak introspection tacked onto weird episodic structuring that sometimes, folds back on itself rather unnecessarily lending a feeling of repetition that keeps reemerging during the movie,(remind you of "Lost" anyone?).
And then there is the science...
In conclusion, If you are a fan of hard sci-fi from the likes of Ian. M. Banks or Isaac Asimov, Sagan or Clark you may be more critical and less forgiving than most. My rant about the writing is fuelled by my love of this hard sci-fi that unfortunately, I thought this was going to be. So it's probably my fault. I was after all, a willing participant in the con.
I give this 5/10 I hate giving any movie attached to Ridley Scott such a low score.
OK... lets say, Stanley Kubrick and David Lynch smoked a sackful of 'Gaia Essence', a ripe ole bag of the stuff. Then, Andy Warhol dropped over with a flask full of 'Dream Mana' and the three had a right old time bouncing crazy ideas and concepts and decided after three straight days of inter-perceptionary travel, to make a movie... 'Beyond the Black Rainbow' is probably as close as you might ever get to seeing the labors from any such fictional collaboration.
I loved it. I can't wait to watch it again. If you believe you have an open mind, or consider yourself to be even remotely intelligent I would advise you to give this a chance. The devil is in the details. There is a new talent among us, and we as film fans should be grateful that someone like Panos Cosmatos has the balls to do things his way and present something that at the very least, is something f***ing different and refreshing.
I'll leave you with this, take from it what you will, I once showed one of my favorite sci fi's to a friend who is a die hard Star Wars fan, he hated it and thought it was stupid and slow; it was 'THX 1138' by George Lucas.
I loved it. I can't wait to watch it again. If you believe you have an open mind, or consider yourself to be even remotely intelligent I would advise you to give this a chance. The devil is in the details. There is a new talent among us, and we as film fans should be grateful that someone like Panos Cosmatos has the balls to do things his way and present something that at the very least, is something f***ing different and refreshing.
I'll leave you with this, take from it what you will, I once showed one of my favorite sci fi's to a friend who is a die hard Star Wars fan, he hated it and thought it was stupid and slow; it was 'THX 1138' by George Lucas.