It's a Christmas Thing

6.4 stars.

The story itself is wonderful and if I summarize it for you, you might say it sounds pretty good. It's nothing new for Hallmark or UP Family, or other Family networks, it fits right in. The only problem is the whole thing is a mess. The sets and scenes and cinematography are top notch, the acting is okay, the dialogue could be fine, but it's a jumbled mess, the whole production, the script it's all a big fat bunch of confusion.

A news reporter for a small town is looking for his big break. A single mother of one little girl is looking for love. He doesn't consider anything in his life but his goals, she is not looking for any relationships. They both are pursuing what they think they need, but what they really need is each other. Somehow, we get to the point, but it's so awkward and ill-timed all throughout, I was cringing more than usual, much more. 'It's a Christmas Thing' a.k.a. 'Peppermint and Postcards' is an utter failure in its attempt to tell a simple story. And who came up with the alternate title? Makes no sense. I feel bad for whoever produced the film, because I bet they had a different outcome in mind than this.

A Wish For Christmas (2023) -

Within the first five minutes I was unimpressed with Daughter Megan (Amelia Harrison), her Dad and his Girlfriend (I didn't catch their names) as actors. Ella Cannon seemed fine as Cara, but I only stayed with it for Christopher Russell, having never been disappointed by him before. He was great in 'Christmas 365/Forever Christmas' (2018).

But despite his presence in it I couldn't watch for long, because even his character Chet was behaving like an absolute "Richard" too. His pushy, career obsessed reporter and her laced up too tight, single Mum just weren't appealing enough for me to care how they would eventually get together.

As with many of the other films that I've tuned in to watch this year, this one might have sufficed previously and may yet in the future, but I have reached a point where I can no longer dedicate my time to such unimpressive matter, especially with so many other cinematic experiences being released each year. I might miss out on something great by persevering with this mediocre effort, so I turned it off.

Unscored as unfinished.

Christopher Russell is a rom/com veteran. I won't say he is the best actor in the genre, but he shouldn't be this bad. His start was terrible. This Chet is the epitome of the jaded reporter and Russell overplays his selfishness and insincerity. Suddenly a lot of that disappears as he begins to bond with Cara. But the man is still clueless and still putting his dream of fame first. Throughout the movie even until just before the end, he is bent on his promotion and he can't see how he is hurting Cara. I just didn't believe that this man could change.

Cara is a gem which it seems everyone else in the story knows. She accepts her ex-husband's new fiancé into her home so that the family can celebrate Christmas. She even makes Suzy her friend. She is generous to everyone. And she is sensitive. Much of the movie centers around setting Cara up with dates.

Except for Russell, the acting is ok and so is the dialogue. Amelia Harrison pulls off the young Megan without overacting.

The positive is I did get sucked into this movie and watched it all the way through. Classic Christmas decor in the background.

And I'm sorry but that's the only good things I can say about this movie. The acting is so stilted and the dialogue has me wondering if the writers actually were trying to sabotage the movie. Awkward, cringeworthy scenes. When an adult love story's ultimate culmination is a Christmas Dance, there's already a major flaw in the story: who cares?!? Literally two minutes before the end the main character still thinks he's going to take a job and then lo and behold he admits his love?!

Save yourself - this was terrible.

I'm not sure why it's called Peppermints and Postcards, but whatever you call it, it was pretty good.

Christopher Russell has been a busy guy this year. Here, he is a pushy small-town reporter looking for his ticket to the big time.

Ella Cannon plays a single mom so meek she is spending the Christmas holidays hosting her ex-husband and his new Parisian fiancee in her home. She says she is happy being single, but it's clear she is not. She bonds with the fiancee.

When her daughter's letter to Santa asking for a love for her mom somehow goes viral, our reporter seizes on the opportunity. He is still licking wounds from a previous relationship, and has no interest in another one, only his ambition.

The movie has a slightly tongue-in-cheek feel, but the feelings of the characters are evident to the viewer almost before they occur to the character. This is a step forward for GAF.

Russell has developed quite a range between this, his baker earlier this year and last year's colorblind schoolteacher.

Ella Cannon was the witchy sister in last year's A Maple Valley Christmas. Here she is very much more copacetic, and aims an acerbic wit at the reporter from time to time. They each become adept at administering the needle.

The chemistry develops slowly, through a sometimes convoluted plot, perhaps the weakest part of the story.

In all, it's a little different, but definitely worth a watch.