A Lifelong Love

This won't matter to many, perhaps most of you, but the movie starts off showing a teen couple dancing in what is clearly a malt shop from the late 1950s. Every feature period correct for a 50s malt shop is there down to the old-fashioned jukebox and the soda jerk (this is not a criticism--that's what they were called). After dancing and showing that they were clearly in love, we cut to the guy in uniform, obviously going off to war, the girl sad and upset. But guess what, he's wearing a uniform not adopted by the military until some years AFTER the Vietnam War ended. So there is what appears to be a thirty year oops. Cut to present day, and the guy, now a grandfather, is telling his granddaughter that this all actually took place in the 1970s. Well, as someone who went to high school in the early 1970s, we just didn't hang out in 1950s malt shops--because there weren't any! And as someone who went into the military afterward, I can tell you that if "grandpa" was supposed to be going to Vietnam, he was wearing a uniform not yet adopted. To add to the already ridiculous situation, he was wearing his pants over his boots--the Army and Marines bloused their pants. The Air Force did not, but they didn't adopt this uniform until the mid-1980s! Bottom line, it's really hard for some of us to get into a story when Hallmark makes NO attempt to get history remotely correct, making so many errors in the first five minutes!

Your enjoyment may vary, of course, depending on your willingness to suspend disbelief.

The premise is another quest story. The four main characters are seeking a lost love of Abe, Annika's grandpa.

Annika is annoying. She is just an over-planner, but she is kind of neurotic. Despite being a planner, she is also irresponsible. "Oh, it will be OK." Ryan is almost as bad to the other extreme. He has no plan for anything.

Ellie is fun but not enough to save the movie.

There is some banter between Andrea Brooks and Patch May but I don't think it translates into chemistry. There is a bit too much of an edge in the banter and the personalities of Annika and Ryan are like oil and water.

Annika is a poetry writer. She and Ryan tell all the prospects they meet that they are writing a book about love stories. Putting a love story into prose is one thing, but I don't understand how you do it in poetry, at least not with way too much work for a two week project. Ryan is set as a partner to Annika, but his contribution appears to consist solely of snapshots of the people they meet - no artistry at all. The whole development of the quest for Ruth is weird and doesn't really make sense.

A Lifelong Love had a great premise, two former college sweethearts where going to team up to write a book about romance as that track down the high school sweetheart of one of their grandparents, interviewing people they meet in the way about their love stories.

In probably the laziest writing I have ever seen on a Hallmark romance....they set up the interviews along the way, but then never share the live stories. That was a true bait and switch in my opinion...to walk you up to the story and then go to commercial never to follow up on the actual love story.

Also, very little time was given to either main love story...the grandparent's or the former college sweethearts. Then there was a poor twelve year old girl who is drug around for the process and struggling because her parents were separating? Was that necessary or pivotal to this romantic plot?

I am not going to waste anymore time on this hallmark romance and my advice is that you shouldn't either.

I love these types of movies but honestly, it was very poorly cast and directed. There wasn't much chemistry with any of the cast. It seemed as if they just pull these people off the street. I don't think I've ever given a back review but as much as I had waiting in much anticipation, it couldn't be over fast enough. The scenes from the past weren't congruent with the present, either. The woman and the man weren't old enough to have been of age in the 50's. It was just unbelievable from beginning to end. To be technical, the lighting wasn't realistic either. I didn't feel any passion or chemistry from the leading man, who o didn't find right at all for the part. I wish this had been finessed, it could have been a very sweet movie.

I started watching because the premise was interesting. However the execution was fifth grade. What a terrible cast and production. This movie expects the viewers to be 5th. Graders with no mentality. How Hallmark can put out this garbage is beyond me. Yes the network that features Lacey Charbet and Autumn Reeser putting out such junk. Hopefully Bill Abbott will make a go of it with GAC. It does not take a genius to compare Abbott's Hallmark with the current garbage they are including. I have no idea how they chose Andrea Brooks and Patch May to star in this "movie?". Although I don't think any actor could have saved this one. My advise don't even try to watch it.