CALIFICACIÓN DE IMDb
6.8/10
2.9 k
TU CALIFICACIÓN
Sigue la vida de Steven Stayner y su familia, sumergiéndose en el viaje de 50 años de la familia para desentrañar la historia de dos hermanos, uno considerado un villano y el otro un héroe.Sigue la vida de Steven Stayner y su familia, sumergiéndose en el viaje de 50 años de la familia para desentrañar la historia de dos hermanos, uno considerado un villano y el otro un héroe.Sigue la vida de Steven Stayner y su familia, sumergiéndose en el viaje de 50 años de la familia para desentrañar la historia de dos hermanos, uno considerado un villano y el otro un héroe.
- Premios
- 1 nominación en total
Explorar episodios
Opiniones destacadas
I remember this story and miniseries from back when. This had such promise as a revisit .. but having the actors read the interviews was borderline unbearable to watch. The story is so powerful in itself,and this show is done quite well... but the reading like an audition was somewhat embarrassing to see.
I think many of the low reviews for this are coming from people who expected something different than what this is trying to do. I think this series is trying to piece together how Steven Stayner's kidnapping and return along with the media attention had a psychological effect on Cary Stayner and possibly led him to become a murderer.
I think the psychological aspects of this incident and how the family was impacted are where the director wants the viewer's attention. We see this in how Kay Stayner describes her husband's opposition to therapy for Steven. The 1989 made for TV movie mentioned in this also alludes to the extra attention given Steven and seemingly taken form Cary. I also think that having the actors from that movie reading the scripted lines was an artistic move. Many are saying it is pretentious but the actual people aren't available to speak for themselves.
I think the psychological aspects of this incident and how the family was impacted are where the director wants the viewer's attention. We see this in how Kay Stayner describes her husband's opposition to therapy for Steven. The 1989 made for TV movie mentioned in this also alludes to the extra attention given Steven and seemingly taken form Cary. I also think that having the actors from that movie reading the scripted lines was an artistic move. Many are saying it is pretentious but the actual people aren't available to speak for themselves.
Instead of a straight up true crime documentary, which this story warrants, the director decided to make a mashup of news footage form 1972, interviews from 2022 and for reasons that are beyond me, extensive footage of the late 1980s made for TV mini-series. I cannot for the life of me figure how they thought the addition of the mini-series footage or act outs from the aged actors added anything to this narrative. I struggled through the first episode baffling at this choice. This is a poorly directed doc.
This wasn't the best true crime documentary but it gave us a look at a real family that survived hellish circumstances only to be hit one more time with a media avalanche and another tragedy. I saw the made for TV movie and I finally heard from the family that they weren't portrayed in the most accurate light but they were happy their story was told. Most people know who Steven is and what Cary did but I don't think anyone can really know what the impact of those events had on the members of the family. I see what the director asked the actors who portrayed Steven and Cary to step in and read excerpts from the interviews. It's a little off-putting at first but with the absence of those key people it keeps the viewer involved in the story instead of cutting to a still picture of the individual. I feel this could have been more involved but I asked away with a deep respect for Mrs. Staynor and her strength.
I've ripped on Hulu before, this one they got right.
Great storytelling of a tragic family. Producers did an excellent job of focusing on the important pieces. This is a family that goes from one traumatizing blow to the next. My deepest sympathy. I particularly liked having actors who portrayed the subjects in film reading the lines. Very well done it.
One avanue I didn't see explored was the tragic end to Steve. Any connection? They never really go into detail about how Steve died? Is it related to Cory? Was it random? I would genuinely like to know.
One critique... The modern day Geppetto calling himself a "mitigation expert" added very little.
Great storytelling of a tragic family. Producers did an excellent job of focusing on the important pieces. This is a family that goes from one traumatizing blow to the next. My deepest sympathy. I particularly liked having actors who portrayed the subjects in film reading the lines. Very well done it.
One avanue I didn't see explored was the tragic end to Steve. Any connection? They never really go into detail about how Steve died? Is it related to Cory? Was it random? I would genuinely like to know.
One critique... The modern day Geppetto calling himself a "mitigation expert" added very little.
¿Sabías que…?
- TriviaThe director later stated in an interview that despite allowing the mitigation specialist for Cary Stayner's defense statement that he found a history of abuse, mental illness, and alcoholism in the Stayner family to remain in, she chose not to address it or ask the interviewed family members about it. In reality, the series leaves out a large amount of information, including the fact that child molestation was rife in the family and the father was one of the perpetrators, along with an uncle and the maternal grandfather. The uncle was murdered in 1990, the case is still unsolved. The grandfather lived near Kenneth Parnell when Steven was kidnapped in 1972.
The private investigator who was interviewed is aware, as are many other people, that despite the narrative that has been fed to the public, Cary Stayner is only guilty of one murder and was railroaded and took the fall for the actual killers (the men who were initially arrested for the crime) in the three murders for which he was sentenced to death. There was a large amount of incompetence and corruption in local law enforcement, and the trial was rigged. Kay Stayner stated in an interview after the trial that she doesn't believe Cary committed those murders either, and pointed out that without his confession, which was full of major discrepancies, the state had no case, but has never fought for her son's innocence, perhaps because she fears the family secrets coming to light again.
- ConexionesReferenced in Film Junk Podcast: Episode 844: The Northman (2022)
Selecciones populares
Inicia sesión para calificar y agrega a la lista de videos para obtener recomendaciones personalizadas
- How many seasons does Captive Audience have?Con tecnología de Alexa
Detalles
- Fecha de lanzamiento
- País de origen
- Idioma
- También se conoce como
- Captive Audience: A Real American Horror Story
- Productoras
- Ver más créditos de la compañía en IMDbPro
- Tiempo de ejecución46 minutos
- Color
- Mezcla de sonido
Contribuir a esta página
Sugiere una edición o agrega el contenido que falta
Principales brechas de datos
What was the official certification given to Captive Audience (2022) in Germany?
Responda