Il était une fois Jean-Sébastien Bach

It's so easy to criticize a movie to its bone marrow, especially this one. Everything was wrong with it, the costumes, the historic details, the Francofication, the acting, the costumes, the absence of God in his life, the musical performances. But.. I have to say, I did finish watching the movie, while I usually am very quick hitting the stop button. Behind all the frivolous nonsense I saw a movie made by people who were madly in love with this man and his music. That's why they retraced his steps literally, because they were on a pilgrimage with a camera. It reminded me of The Mill and The Cross, which is about a painting of Pieter Breugel the Elder by that title. Although the historic depiction in this movie seems to be more accurate, that is not the point of the movie. The point is to literally enter the aforementioned painting. You can't 'enter' music like you can enter a painting, but, what these film makers seemed to be doing was to go to places where Bach was breathing hoping to inhale a few of the molecules Bach once exhaled. To me it felt that they were using the actors as a vehicle to get closer to their idol. It worked for me. Again, as a movie it wouldn't get a passing grade at any film school, but, as a means of transferring passion, it worked phenomenal, after wards I listened to Bach's music for many hours and I can't wait until Easter when the St Matthew's Passion will be performed.

J.S. Bach is my favorite composer and this movie explored his life in a way I never took the time to do myself.

I ran into this movie by accident and it was a pleasant surprise.

I now have a great appreciation of the man behind the music.

It also gives a hint of what it was like for people of his time - a nice period piece.

For example: I didn't even know he had married.

Another example: I didn't know he was incarcerated. Hmm... ex con? That's not really descriptive of his incarceration, but a fun twist on this footnote!

It's a must see for any J.S. Bach fan!

This film about one of the classical music world's genuine greats is a mostly factually accurate re telling of J S Bach's life starting at age ten . It hits most of the highlights and saddest lows of Bach's painful and yet interesting life with an attempt , usually successful , of being not only truthful but also modest . It is in stark contrast to other films about classical musical geniuses like Amadeus , which may be to some more entertaining , but also have multiple scenes that are , as far as historians know , pure fiction . Il etait une fois Jean Sebastien Bach is in French but the subtitles are both easy to read because of their large size print , and accurate translations into English . The music is wonderful ! Every single piece , as befits an entire film about one of the greatest classical music composers ever , is a J S Bach composition . Several of the locations , in the movie , are even the original spots that J S Bach himself was at . Another honest attempt by this filmmaker to be truthful and accurate to the facts of Bach's life . If you want to learn about J S Bach's life , joys and woes and , of course his wonderful music this film will give you that . Despite the criticisms of some reviewers it is a solid , admittedly not spectacular , but good film . Agreed none of the performances are award worthy but again it tells his story accurately and gives quality renditions of Bach's music . It achieves the reasonable if modest , but still worthwhile aims for a film about a musical great - to tell enough of the person's story truthfully that the viewer learns about the person's life and hears some of his music . Few other music composers have as many pieces of their music performed as often every year for over two centuries on different continents as J S Bach and this is a good introduction to the man , his life and a small , but good , sampling of his music .

(By advance, please excuse my bad and too scholastic English) This movie is a perfect example of all that one should not make. The picture is bad: no movement, no perspective. The photograph is bad: runny colours, grainy film. Actor & actress are without expression, without dynamic. NOTA: the superb hairstyle with streak hairs of Anna Magdalena (Like a bimbo girl in `Macumba Club' night dancing in far end of country side during the annual cattle market). Even the music is bad, not in respect with J.S.Bach. Comments with a voice out off picture is monotonous and encourage you to sleep. Dialogs are almost nonexistent and without interest. I don't know if the life of J.S.Bach is very thrilling (according this movie it seems that J.S.B. was a kind of civil servant attached to princes for write one cantata each week !), but his music is in domain of spirituality and it is perfectly concealed/ignored in this movie. Fortunately I suppose that the US audience shall has never the opportunity to see this very bad movie.

I have little knowledge about Johan Sebastian Bach, but I liked this movie anyways. Maybe it was because I wasn't critical? The costumes were nice and I liked the actors. It was interesting that he was such a humble man. And that he loved both his wifes. I also liked that he seemed like a good father. I think his brother was a little arrogant. I wonder what kind of music Bach would have listened to had he been transported with a time machine to our time? I wish there were movies about other famous people like this. I am happy I am not living in the 17th century, because I think it would be nasty to be operated on by a quack doctor.