The Secret Garden

By far my favorite version on film. Follows the book by Frances Hodgson Burnett very closely, with a few small changes, but even those maintain the character of the story, the time period, and the setting, very well. I am not as impressed by Hollywood flashiness as by respect for a much loved classic book. Care was taken here with the casting, authenticity of accents and props and settings. The story can be read on many levels - enjoyed just as a tale in its own right, or as a gentle allegory of healing and growth, where the only "bad guys" are the hard things in life or internal struggles that can be overcome. BBC did a wonderful job of keeping that sweet simplicity and subtlety, not trying to dress it up with needless melodrama as other versions have. I commend BBC for being faithful to so many classic books, which are, after all, classic for a reason.

Very impressive production! A simple story brought to life with superb acting, complex and consistent characters, and a believable and entertaining storyline. There's no "good" or "bad" characters. All the people have their good and bad sides and these are allowed to interact with other personalities.

Don't expect a multi-million dollar production, but this charming story is presented with much professionalism by the entire cast. An entirely enjoyable presentation for the whole family.

Frances Hodgson Burnett was best known for penning three children/family literary classics that have been beloved for decades and adapted numerous times. They are 'Little Lord Fauntleroy', 'A Little Princess' and 'The Secret Garden'.

Of the numerous versions of 'The Secret Garden', it is this adaptation from the BBC that is the most faithful, being often word for word and very close in detail with few changes (any that were made were very minor), which those who prefer films/television adapted from source material to be as faithful as possible will appreciate. With that being said, it is not my personal favourite version, judging all the adaptations from a standalone perspective my favourite is the 1993 film, which had more polish, a little more soul and very memorable music and performances.

'The Secret Garden' (1975) is not without its faults. There is an artificial, un-evocative and drably low-budget look to the sets, which do look like rather studio bound and not much is done to make it less obvious. This is especially true for the garden, which should have been far more wondrous later on.

David Patterson didn't do anything for me either as Colin, inexperience shows and his dialogue delivery is often rushed and stilted, plus character growth was not particularly convincing with him being too much of a brat throughout.

However, Sarah Holis Andrews makes for a spirited, suitably sullen and later quite charming Mary, with her unlike Colin here there is a real sense of character growth and evolution. Andrew Harrison is perhaps definitive as Dickon, with the most Yorkshire-sounding accent.

Hope Johnstone's Mrs Medlock is appropriately beastly while with a little humanity later, while the Lord Craven of John Woodnutt is as mysterious and melancholic as necessary. Tom Harrison and Jacqueline Hoyle fare well as Ben and Martha.

Lacking sets aside, 'The Secret Garden' (1975) is photographed pleasingly, and is lovingly costumed. Transfer is pretty good. The music is both sombre and uplifting, like the story itself, while the dialogue is like the book come to life. The story spaces itself out over the lengthy length with ease and rarely drags, displaying every ounce of the book's charm, mystery and sense of hope.

Overall, lovely adaptation and well worth watching. 8/10 Bethany Cox

Actually, it's sort of a tie between this and the '93 Kate Maberly one. The '93 one was quite lavish, and a visual feast, but in a way I'm more drawn to the '75 version. The acting is great, especially Sarah Hollis Andrews, who plays the spoiled Mary Lennox, and it followed the story exactly. I also liked Andrew Harrison, who played Dickon (he was really great in "The Littlest Horse Thieves"). He was, IMHO, the best Dickon of all the versions, as his Yorkshire accent was the thickest, and he looked exactly the way Dickon is described in the novel. My only complaint: parts of this seemed to obviously be filmed on a set, such as the garden, which was most disappointing. I could be wrong about the set thing, but it seems to me to be indoors. Still, the movie's just like reading the novel and quite a bit of the dialogue is taken directly from the book (I don't mind that at all). I've seen every version of "The Secret Garden" made, and this and the '93 one are, to me, the best by far.

Having recently had the opportunity to read the book "The Secret Garden" I was pleasantly surprised at how close this version is to the book. I now have four versions of this story, the 1947, 1975, 1987 and 1993 most of the other versions stray somewhat from the original story, even the majority of the script in this production is taken from the book. When I read the book I can visualise the actors in this production, the only change I could find was that Sarah Ann Medlock has been renamed Agnes. Sarah Hollis Andrews does a fine job as Mary and unlike other versions they used a genuine Yorkshire boy Andrew Harrison to play Dickon, David Patterson made a delightfully obnoxious (to start with) Colin. Of course this was a TV production so not in the same class as a Hollywood movie. Never the less full marks to the BBC on a great job.