En un año con 13 lunas

I watched this movie and after my first reaction wasn't that clear. sometimes boring perhaps? but then i was thinking about it, more and more and it touched me more and more and in a strange way i compared this one with the all time classic x-mas movie IT'S A WONDERFUL LIFE from Capra. in the mood way. Interesting to say, that also in 13 MOONS there is an angel like in the x-mas Movie. It's the character ROTE ZORA. While Capra's angel had success, it's will know, it will not happen in 13 Moons.

of course while you will learn by the Frank Capra movie how important each human being is in the world we live in, Fassbinder gives you here the lesson how hopeless life can be. So while you have tears in your eyes by watching IT'S A WONDERFUL LIFE, you see all the hope in this movie and you know there will be a happy end. From the first second on in this movie you know, there will be no happy end. And you will have no tears in your eyes at the end, but perhaps you will be a little bit speechless. From Hollywood a movie like this never will come. This movie don't want to entertain you in a Hollywood way. so be prepared!

This movie is the most personal Fasssbinder for sure. He lost some weeks before his boyfriend. then he wrote in three days the whole script. Unbelievable to tell that he ALSO was responsible for BOOK/EDITING/CAMERA (Michael Ballhaus was asked for, but he couldn't)/PRODUCING/IDEA/EQUIPMENT and of course DIRECTING it. The Music score is very good (classic meets suicide (the new wave band) meets sixties rock'n roll meets Connie Francis). A terrific Volker Spengler as the main character as also a stunning Ingrid Caven.

Almost impossible to understand the whole plot when you have to read the English subtitles, it's absolutely recommend when you can speak German.

Beginning with the written introduction about the 13 Moons, through the slaughterhouse scene (which is remarkable for the whole movie, because here he shows us the Life and the Death, the hopeless the movie is about in a short sequence), through the next scene where elvira is lying very depressed on the bed while the record player plays a x-mas song (it's a wonderful life......), but the song has a scratch (hopeless again) to the important scene where elvira tries to become erwin again (but failed), the two hours of this movie is very sensitive. It's not a movie to watch between Forrest Gump and Star Wars (...). It's a movie which brings you back to the ground of earth. So honest that you feel pain.

Everyone will have a time in life in which he falls in a hole. This movie is showing that. A tragedy. OR a horror trip.

Fassbinder's genius is making you feel as trapped and desperate as Elvira, you really feel empathy for the character. Only the visit with her family is there a brief respite from her pain. Kudos for Fassbinder for his good taste in using Suicide's "Frankie Teardrop" on the soundtrack--a song about a man who feels trapped, but directs his anger outward, rather than inward, like Elvira.

As some others have written or implied this film is absolutely exhausting. It doesn't abandon its character or his life at any time although at times we almost WANT relief. Mahler's music in films has been dutifully noted. It can be almost as depressing in concert version. As for Nino Rota's "happy" music, or "life just continues (joyfully)" score, the irony isn't lost either. This is a one-man job and therefore takes risks that few producers or companies would tolerate under normal circumstances. I was profoundly moved by the film; I just don't plan to see it again for a while.

Curtis Stotlar

I have to save my comments for later...I began watching this film last night and, as disturbing as the slaughterhouse scene actually is, I was only able to make it halfway through. I will return. It amazes me when a film disturbs me so much that I cannot watch it in one sitting. I had similar reactions to both Pasolini's "Salo" and to Cronenberg's "Crash".

But I'm curious to learn from anyone who might have a clue why Nino Rota's theme music from "Amarcord" (original orchestration) was put in this movie's first half and yet isn't credited on IMDb's list of "combined details".

Anybody who might offer some insight on this omission....thanks for posting it here....

In A Year With 13 Moons was directed rather late in director Werner Rainer Fassbinder's career, and in this film you almost get a whiff of life imitating art as you feel like you're watching the last days of Fassbinder as a director. In this film you can see the influence of films that Fassbinder admired, for example, Le Diable probablement, but In A Year With 13 Moons is bleak and impersonal in a way that the aforementioned film is not. It lacks the aesthetic obsession that French films often have and instead there is an emphasis on showing people and places as they truly are.

There are scenes that take place in darkened rooms where you almost get a contrived, science-fiction feel, and you're reminded that in all fiction the process of "world-building" occurs, but it's less obvious in contemporary drama because the viewer/reader is able to associate the names of places and people in the drama with real places and people, so the contrived nature and world-building are neatly tucked under the rug for no one to see. The film is remarkable in its tale of Elvira/Erwin who breaks up with her lover and then has to meet up with an old acquaintance after a misunderstanding. The actors totally inhabit their roles as they generally do in Fassbinder's films and this certainly is a testament to Fassbinder's brilliance as a director.

The primary weakness of this film is that it lacks naturalness and feels just a little too false, in contrast to, for example, Fassbinder's Fox and His Friends, which feels very natural. In A Year With 13 Moons is artsier, somewhat commedia-dell'arte-esque with its stereotypical characters, but after watching so many bad films recently this particular film felt like a breath of fresh air. A notable scene occurs at a butcher site or mechanical abattoir where cattle are being bled and slaughtered, which again was a little reminiscent of the scenes of environmental degradation in Le Diable probablement. In A Year With 13 Moons is a must-see. 8 out of 10.