Nan quan bei tui

This was one of the first ever Karate films ive seen and i got it from a video shop about 8 years ago. The film is dubded like most karate films of that time. The plot is good and has a man avenging the death of his family and the other is the son of a genaral and they are both after the same man the notorious "SILVER FOX" hes one of the best fighters around. Both the men have to enter a fighting tournement to get near him and the fights are brilliantly staged plus the two men have to fight the emperors guards who get in the way through the film. At times there are funny parts to the film. In the end the two main leads both like the same girl but she only likes one of them they try to fight each other twice in the film to see which one of them is best but both times they get interupted and then they team up together to take on the mighty "SILVER FOX". This is a good film for karate fans but its a fairly rare film and it would be very hard to get your hands on it.

I've been watching every martial arts movie ever made in chronological order. This movie is a milestone in the history of the genre. This movie stands out as different from every movie before it and affected many movies to come. The director started with the purpose of introducing real martial artists for the fight scenes and he scored three aces in a row with Don Wong, John Liu and Jang Lee Hwang. The difference was simply the kicks. It boggles my mind that is was so simple as kicks but read any review about this movie and count how many times kicks are mentioned. This is a martial arts movie all about the kicks and it's one of the best. The kicks can't be faked, they are real, they are focused, on target, and full of power. Who would have guessed that a kick to the head could be so entertaining? The storyline or plot has often been commented upon. This is a revenge plot but initially the plot appears to be a tournament plot or no plot at all. Let me point out when John Liu asks the little boy why he wants to learn martial arts the boy replies he wants to beat up the bad guys. John asks him how can he tell who is a bad guy? That's what the first part of the movie is all about, figuring out who are the bad guys and who are the good guys. The white eye brows villain had been around for years so Jang Lee Hwang did nothing new by putting on the makeup but once the makeup was on him, he totally owned that part for the rest of his career. Overall this one belongs on the top twenty of all time.

Secret Rivals doesn't have a great storyline, but the actors know their kung fu! The movie features a good deal of fighting, and some excellent practice sessions.

The version I saw had very poor picture quality and not all of the subtitles were visible. This is of course a shame, and contributed a great deal to the fact that I only enjoyed this movie moderately. But if it was available in DVD quality, with a clear and crisp picture and sound, it would be a great experience.

This is the kind of movie that Bruce Lee SHOULD have done. His presence here would have elevated this to a world-famous classic.

My rating: 7 out of 10.

THE SECRET RIVALS is a lively and solid kung fu film that helped launch the screen career of master villain Hwang Jang Lee. The film is set in ancient Korea and features a couple of kung fu fighters teaming up to bring down the Silver Fox, a wily master who has some high-kicking talent. You can guess which role Lee plays. The movie was directed by Ng See-Yuen, who has made some of the better entries in the martial arts genre, and is never less than entertaining.

One thing I did notice about this film is that it was made in the middle period between the success of the Bruce Lee and Shaw Brothers movies but before Jackie Chan came along and revitalised the decade at the end of the 1970s. Thus the fight choreography isn't quite as top notch as it would get to be later on in the decade and in the early 1980s, although the fights here are still pretty good and have a tendency to get better towards the end. There are some fun training sequences with a larger-than-life dummy and an Ennio Morricone score borrowed from an old spaghetti western. Lee is a delight as always and is well matched by the talents of John Liu and Don Wong.

I had high hopes for this film, especially after watching the vastly superior sequel: Secret Rivals II and had read a lot of good reviews here and elsewhere. Unfortunately, although I think many people disagree with me about this, it was a huge let-down and had little appeal what-so-ever, except for some unintentional hilarious bad English dubbing. The story, although generally non-essential to kung fu-movies of the era, was excruciating at times, with prolonged scenes about some side-plot involving a mutual love interest of our heroes, and the rest isn't much better. This wouldn't have mattered at all if we were treated with a lot of fighting in between the tedious story telling, but WE'RE NOT! I'm a huge fan of Jon Liu and especially Hwang Jang Lee, but they are never allowed to show off their skills properly since they hardly get to fight.

The choreography is really sloppy in the first half of the movie, but doesn't improve nearly as much as I had hoped even for the end fight, which is over really fast. I don't know what other reviewers saw in this movie.. naturally John Liu and Hwang Jang Lee are excellent fighters and their skill somehow manages to bear to movie to some extent, but I was honestly never entertained by any part of it.

If you, like me, are into Chinese classic Kung Fu flicks of the 70's and 80s, you are likely to either have seen this or be about to do so, but I can't recommend it, in spite of it's good reputation. See Secret Rivals II instead, it's a masterpiece, this one isn't.