3 opiniones
Firstly, let me correct the plot outline offered here in IMDb: in fact, Herculano (Paulo Porto) is a middle-aged, respectable, strict Catholic bourgeois and recent widower. Desperate with grief, he moves back to his brooding family house, with his 3 MacBethian spinster aunts and his sleazy no-good brother Patricio (Paulo César Peréio), who introduces him to prostitute Geni (Darlene Glória). At first disgusted by the idea of betraying his wife's memory, sex-starved Herculano can't help falling head over heels for Geni -- and, amazingly, vice-versa. They decide to marry, but Herculano's bilious teenage son Serginho (Paulo Sacks) is ready to do anything to prevent it. Geni becomes an involuntary weapon in the father/son war, with tragedy waiting around the corner.
Tied with Nelson Pereira dos Santos' "Boca de Ouro" (1963), "Toda Nudez..." is probably the best film adaptation of a text (in this case, a play) by the great, controversial, inimitable Brazilian playwright and journalist Nelson Rodrigues (1912-1980) -- who, by the way, heartily approved of this version. Director Arnaldo Jabor manages to translate to the screen Rodrigues' tragic, melodramatic and satirical universe: forbidden sex, incest, greed, hate, envy, sin, rape, homosexuality, violence, sadism, masochism, all caused by the "Great Trio of Evil" (Family, Guilt and Catholic repression). It's a film of excesses, and rightly so; subtlety was foreign to Rodrigues. His characters don't just love or hate; they love and hate to death. It's a world of doom, extravaganza, consumption. And also of comic relief, in a sarcastic mode: instead of criticizing society through comedy, Rodrigues uses tragedy.
Non-Portuguese speakers will lose the special flavor of Rodrigues' incomparably flamboyant dialog: imagine the emotional impact of Tennessee Williams + the precision of David Mamet (Rodrigues also wisely uses short sentences, pauses and repetitions) + the tragicomic effects of Almodóvar + Buñuel's unpredictability and you'll have a hint of Rodrigues' style. The DVD's English subtitles are OK, but can't translate Rodrigues' vernacular wealth.
The film has major assets: Arnaldo Jabor's direction values first and foremost the dialog but is wise enough to avoid staginess (though he's less fortunate when there's a lot of people in the frame -- q.v. the confusing street and jail scenes). The art direction and set decoration, with crumbling walls, washed-out paint and old heavy furniture, expertly convey the putrefying world of the decadent characters. On the other hand, there's the usual lot of technical problems of 1970s Brazilian films: shots out of focus, visible shadows of lighting/sound equipment, harsh lighting, and imprecise voice-looping (which in a film where dialog is so important can be really distracting). The musical selection is fine (especially the Piazzolla pieces, dramatically perfect) but overused -- there's hardly a scene without music.
Great performances by most of the cast, especially the two leads, who are sensational in their best film roles ever. Paulo Porto not once "loses" his character; he's Herculano from head to toe, all the time. Darlene Glória is a fascinating mix of whore and martyr, with her fake blond hair, big eyes, big smile, perfect teeth, unashamed nudity and sexy voice; her Geni is THE archetypal golden- hearted but doomed prostitute. As the sullen Serginho, Paulo Sacks is surprisingly effective, considering it was his first and only film performance. Elza Gomes and Henriqueta Brieba deliver their usual top-notch turns; sadly, the great Isabel Ribeiro is miscast, wasted in a non-role. Paulo César Peréio and Hugo Carvana shamelessly go for easy laughs; they do get the laughs, but their tongue-in-cheek performances are closer to farce.
If you're Brazilian and/or a fan of Nelson Rodrigues, you must see this one -- it's fun, hilariously overblown, hard to dislike. If you never heard of Nelson Rodrigues, let me just say this: if you liked Almodóvar's "What Did I Do to Deserve This?", or Saura's "Mamá Cumple Cien Años", or Buñuel's "El" or "Tristana", you'll certainly enjoy this one. My vote: 8 out of 10
Tied with Nelson Pereira dos Santos' "Boca de Ouro" (1963), "Toda Nudez..." is probably the best film adaptation of a text (in this case, a play) by the great, controversial, inimitable Brazilian playwright and journalist Nelson Rodrigues (1912-1980) -- who, by the way, heartily approved of this version. Director Arnaldo Jabor manages to translate to the screen Rodrigues' tragic, melodramatic and satirical universe: forbidden sex, incest, greed, hate, envy, sin, rape, homosexuality, violence, sadism, masochism, all caused by the "Great Trio of Evil" (Family, Guilt and Catholic repression). It's a film of excesses, and rightly so; subtlety was foreign to Rodrigues. His characters don't just love or hate; they love and hate to death. It's a world of doom, extravaganza, consumption. And also of comic relief, in a sarcastic mode: instead of criticizing society through comedy, Rodrigues uses tragedy.
Non-Portuguese speakers will lose the special flavor of Rodrigues' incomparably flamboyant dialog: imagine the emotional impact of Tennessee Williams + the precision of David Mamet (Rodrigues also wisely uses short sentences, pauses and repetitions) + the tragicomic effects of Almodóvar + Buñuel's unpredictability and you'll have a hint of Rodrigues' style. The DVD's English subtitles are OK, but can't translate Rodrigues' vernacular wealth.
The film has major assets: Arnaldo Jabor's direction values first and foremost the dialog but is wise enough to avoid staginess (though he's less fortunate when there's a lot of people in the frame -- q.v. the confusing street and jail scenes). The art direction and set decoration, with crumbling walls, washed-out paint and old heavy furniture, expertly convey the putrefying world of the decadent characters. On the other hand, there's the usual lot of technical problems of 1970s Brazilian films: shots out of focus, visible shadows of lighting/sound equipment, harsh lighting, and imprecise voice-looping (which in a film where dialog is so important can be really distracting). The musical selection is fine (especially the Piazzolla pieces, dramatically perfect) but overused -- there's hardly a scene without music.
Great performances by most of the cast, especially the two leads, who are sensational in their best film roles ever. Paulo Porto not once "loses" his character; he's Herculano from head to toe, all the time. Darlene Glória is a fascinating mix of whore and martyr, with her fake blond hair, big eyes, big smile, perfect teeth, unashamed nudity and sexy voice; her Geni is THE archetypal golden- hearted but doomed prostitute. As the sullen Serginho, Paulo Sacks is surprisingly effective, considering it was his first and only film performance. Elza Gomes and Henriqueta Brieba deliver their usual top-notch turns; sadly, the great Isabel Ribeiro is miscast, wasted in a non-role. Paulo César Peréio and Hugo Carvana shamelessly go for easy laughs; they do get the laughs, but their tongue-in-cheek performances are closer to farce.
If you're Brazilian and/or a fan of Nelson Rodrigues, you must see this one -- it's fun, hilariously overblown, hard to dislike. If you never heard of Nelson Rodrigues, let me just say this: if you liked Almodóvar's "What Did I Do to Deserve This?", or Saura's "Mamá Cumple Cien Años", or Buñuel's "El" or "Tristana", you'll certainly enjoy this one. My vote: 8 out of 10
- debblyst
- 4 may 2006
- Enlace permanente
"Toda Nudez será Castigada" is a good film and a very interesting one, especially for those that are not acquainted with Nelson Rodrigues's universe.
As for me, having read as a teenager many Nelson Rodrigues's plays I feel that this could have been a memorable film if a top-notch director had filmed it. As it is, the merits of the film lie much more with Nelson Rodrigues than with the film per se.
Nelson Rodrigues is the most important playwright of Brazil and one of the greatest in the world (if he is not better known in the rest of the world, this can be partly attributed to the language barrier). His plays portray the petite bourgeoisie and its conventions - the characters live tragic and insane lives in order to keep up appearances and follow social conventions - melodrama, comedy and surrealism .
Arnaldo Jabor is a good director. "Toda Nudez será castigada" manages to give us a good view of the world depicted by Nelson Rodrigues. The film's decor is excellent and the same can be said for the soundtrack, but the camera work doesn't help that much in building up the atmosphere, the editing is somehow slack and the acting is good, very good sometimes, but it could have been wonderful in the hands of a really talented director.
Many Nelson Rodrigues's plays (and books) have been filmed in Brazil. Some of them (that I remember) are "A Falecida" by Leon Hirszman, "Boca de Ouro" by Nelson Pereira dos Santos, "Perdoa-me por me traíres" by Braz Chediak, "O Casamento" by the same Arnaldo Jabor etc..
As for me, having read as a teenager many Nelson Rodrigues's plays I feel that this could have been a memorable film if a top-notch director had filmed it. As it is, the merits of the film lie much more with Nelson Rodrigues than with the film per se.
Nelson Rodrigues is the most important playwright of Brazil and one of the greatest in the world (if he is not better known in the rest of the world, this can be partly attributed to the language barrier). His plays portray the petite bourgeoisie and its conventions - the characters live tragic and insane lives in order to keep up appearances and follow social conventions - melodrama, comedy and surrealism .
Arnaldo Jabor is a good director. "Toda Nudez será castigada" manages to give us a good view of the world depicted by Nelson Rodrigues. The film's decor is excellent and the same can be said for the soundtrack, but the camera work doesn't help that much in building up the atmosphere, the editing is somehow slack and the acting is good, very good sometimes, but it could have been wonderful in the hands of a really talented director.
Many Nelson Rodrigues's plays (and books) have been filmed in Brazil. Some of them (that I remember) are "A Falecida" by Leon Hirszman, "Boca de Ouro" by Nelson Pereira dos Santos, "Perdoa-me por me traíres" by Braz Chediak, "O Casamento" by the same Arnaldo Jabor etc..
- andrabem
- 18 may 2007
- Enlace permanente
Famous adaptation to cinema of also very famous theatre play by Nelson Rodrigues, this is indeed an interesting melodrama about social taboo, perversion and psychiatric disturbs. It is the most famous piece in Arnaldo Jabor's (quite irregular) cinematography and, in my opinion, it is his second best (after Everything's Alright). However, it is far from perfect. There are several flaws, with pace problems (quite sleepy sometimes), some unbalanced moments which should be simply cut out (most of the 15 first minutes, for instance), presence of homophobia and racism (by the way, Cuzco is not in Bolivia...)... Paulo Porto and Darlene Glória go very well in the two leading roles (and so does Hugo Carvana in his minor one), but I definitely did not like Paulo César Peréio here. Despite all these criticisms, and the antipathy both Jabor and Rodrigues deserve, the film worth being watched anyway and has merits, including its art direction.
- guisreis
- 13 jun 2022
- Enlace permanente