Il coltello di ghiaccio

What's with the bullfighting footage, Umberto? Even when not making cannibal films, he throws in some real animal violence. What did he have against animals?

This giallo has a few different twists on the formula, and although it's okay, it doesn't quite have enough insanity in it either. It involves Ida Galli returning to the family home to meet her family, including a mute Carroll Baker (nice turn from her in this film). Everyone's happy to see her, but this also seems to trigger a series of killings which may or may not have something to do with a local Satanic cult.

Knife of Ice looks great and sounds great, but it's also kind of tame and treading the same ground at the same time. It's almost as if Umberto is kind of stuck in the late sixties way of making gialli.

The third Lenzi giallo I've watched after having attended screenings of ORGASMO (1969; incidentally another of his collaborations with star Carroll Baker) and SPASMO (1974) during the Italian B-movie retrospective at the 2004 Venice Film Festival; they're not the best examples of the genre by far, but neither are they among the worst.

I recall ORGASMO being pretty complex, while SPASMO was weird without being especially compelling (though I did watch it as part of an all-night marathon that ended at 8:00 and where the screening of Lenzi's film was interrupted a couple of times because of trouble with the print!). As for the film in question, it's basically a retread of Robert Siodmak's noir-ish masterpiece THE SPIRAL STAIRCASE (1946) - which Lenzi himself had singled out as his favorite film during one of the many Press Conferences he gave (along with colleagues Sergio Martino and Enzo G. Castellari) during the Festival: Baker plays a mute, the main setting is an upper-class household in a small rural town, the climax occurs during a thunderstorm and, of course, there's a serial killer on the loose! The narrative also takes in drug addiction and devil worship, but these emerge as mere red herrings.

Still, for a giallo, it's pretty bloodless and, to be honest, its attempt at psychology - demonstrated by frequent abrupt cutting in which Baker has flashes from her past, as well as the various victims at their moment of death, and the possible perpetrator - is not only unconvincing but becomes a repetitive device with little purpose (given the final revelation)! As a matter of fact, this particular twist was re-used in SPASMO; still, the obligatory explanation offered here is a little weak but, then, this form of coda seldom worked within the confines of the giallo subgenre! Besides, the score is undistinguished and the casting merely okay: Georges Rigaud (as Baker's ageing uncle, who has a heart condition which he ultimately uses to his own advantage!), Eduardo Fajardo (as a sinister-looking chauffeur), Evelyn Stewart, etc.

I agree that "Knife of Ice" is one of director Umberto Lenzi's classier movies, but I didn't find it one of his more interesting ones (it's certainly one of his least sexy). The mystery is well conceived, the editing well done, and Carroll Baker turns in a good performance, no doubt aided by the fact that since her character is a mute she's spared the stilted post dubbing suffered by the other actors. But the pacing is a bit sluggish and some of the devil worship symbols laughable (dig the cartoon goat head "medallion" found by the police). Personally, I found other Lenzi-Baker thrillers like "Paranoia" (a.k.a. "Orgasmo") and "A Quiet Place to Kill" (a.k.a. "Paranoia"--confused yet?) a lot more hopping. Guess I prefer my giallos on the trashy side. Still, for fans of the genre, "Knife of Ice" is worth a look.

Fourth (and final) giallo collaboration between director Umberto Lenzi and US star Carroll Baker. Martha (Baker), a young woman rendered mute as a child by the shock of seeing her parents killed in a train crash, lives with her Uncle Ralph (George Rigaud) in his villa in the Spanish mountains. One day her cousin Jenny (Ida Galli, here under the pseudonym 'Evelyn Stewart') - a successful singer - comes to stay. But that night Jenny is murdered by an unseen attacker, her body discovered the next morning by Martha. The police believe the killing is connected with the recent death of another young woman of similar type - blonde, slim, pretty. The police warn Martha to be careful as she also matches that description. A few days later a cat belonging to the daughter of a family friend is found dead with its throat cut, and soon after that Uncle Ralph's housekeeper Annie (Silvia Monelli) is found murdered in woodland, with a satanic goat symbol painted on a tree nearby; however, she's a different physical type (pretty, but slightly older, and darker haired and complexioned). As the killing continues Police now realise anybody could become a victim...

This differs from Lenzi's other work with Baker in that there's no sex/nudity, there's very little blood or gore, and the killings all occur offscreen (although we do see the aftermath). However, the film scores well on atmosphere (fog during the day, thunderstorms at night) and the locations are suitably gothic (sprawling villa, creepy cemetery). There's no shortage of suspects; Uncle Ralph (who spends all his spare time reading books on the occult); Ralph's creepy, looming chauffeur; the local doctor (whose movements couldn't be more suspicious if he tried); a devil-worshipping, drug-addicted, rough-sleeping, crazy-eyed hippy (based on Charles Manson - subtly named 'Mason')... and more. The problem is, once you discount all the way-too-obvious red herrings there's really only one person it can be. And sure enough... However, the performances (bar the wooden doctor) are good, with Baker definitely stealing the show. 6/10.

Don't hesitate to pick this one up, It might not be gory or filled with naked women but it's got a pretty damned fine central mystery. I don't think it's available in a letter boxed form on video, which is a real shame because Lenzi do have a way with pictures and this one is no exception. Also there are some really cool editing tricks, especially in the first half of the film. Over all it's a rather convincing story with some really original moments and fine acting. Bar the dubbing of course (as always!). 8/10 if you are a genre fan. 6/10 if you are a new arrival. You know what I mean...