General improvisado

I noticed one reviewer disliked the movie because it wasn't funny. Well, technically I guess it is sort of a comedy...but if you stop expecting laughs, you'll likely enjoy it much more.

The story begins sometime during WWII after the allies have invaded France (sometime June 1944 or later). A bunch of American Army soldiers are having a tough time, as the Germans are counter-attacking with tanks. So, a General goes up to the front lines to fight with the troops and inspire them with his bravery. Unfortunately, the man is soon killed. Sergeant Savage (Glenn Ford) is mistaken for the general by one of the men...and then he gets the idea to continue pretending to be him. Why? Because he notices how much better then men fight when he's there with them.

This is not a laugh out loud film. But it is clever and diverting...and that was more than enough for me. Add to this that the story is unique and you have a nice film, well worth your time.

This is a great 1958 film that is very hard to find! It stars Glenn Ford who plays a Master Sergeant in the army who impersonates his fallen General to boost morale for his troops in France 1944. There is one soldier ,brilliantly played by Tige Andrews, who was once Master Sergeant Hutchmire but now Private Hutchmire "Hutch", who is out to get Murph (Ford), and knows nothing about Murphs charade to be the General. There is great humor and a lot of action. It may be even more enjoyable if you know French because they speak French some of the time when speaking to a beautiful French woman (Taina Elg - who reminds me of a French Helen Hunt) who's house they confiscate as their headquarters. A lot of fun. A true piece of Hollywood masterpiece. There is a plot to kill the Nazi's and a sub plot to not let Fords identity be found out by the only soldier who knows his true identity

Glenn Ford and Red Buttons take a mighty big chance trying to impersonate a general. It's a court martial offense if they're caught.

Although the film goes overboard in silliness at times, Imitation General is a pretty good comedy from the talented director/actor team of George Marshall and Glenn Ford who also did the riotously funny The Sheepman that same year.

Sergeant Ford and Corpoal Buttons are assigned and driving General Kent Smith in a forward area that gets a bit too forward and cut off from the main allied lines. They're surrounded and Smith is killed.

Deciding that leadership is needed in the area Ford takes off his master sergeant stripes and puts on the late general's stars and pretends to be him. He and Buttons manage to pull it off all the time trying to avoid Private Tige Andrews who has a grudge against Ford.

The action in Imitation General is fast and furious and Ford deadpans his way through another comedy triumph. Though I have to say that it should only have been so easy to take out German tanks as is shown here.

Look for good performances by Dean Jones as a combat fatigue suffering soldier that Ford due to his ersatz rank gets back into shape. Also Kent Smith is very good even though he's killed off in the first twenty minutes. His performance is quite moving and it does explain why he was a beloved figure and why Ford and Buttons are doing the crazy things they are.

Imitation General, a good comedy not to be missed when shown on TCM because it's not out on VHS or DVD.

When the general is knocked off, master sergeant murphy (ford) puts on the general's helmet and takes command. But there are many obstacles... that's an arrestable offense, and one of his old enemies could recognize him at any time. And of course, his old nemesis is trying to steal a girl from him. To top it all off, there are german soldiers all around them. With german tanks coming towards their position. It's fun, in spite of the serious subject; ten years had gone by since the end of ww two, and we're caught up in the light story line as much as the military action going on. Red buttons is here as the sidekick. It's okay, if you overlook a few things. Directed by george marshall, who did some great comedies. Which probably explains why he was chosen to direct this, as it is more of a light comedy than a serious war drama. Even the director and writer have military-ish names: marshall and chamberlain. Entertaining.

Immediately after The Teahouse of the August Moon, Glenn Ford's military comedic talents were utilized again in Imitation General. The premise wasn't exactly funny, but the film took a dark comedic take on the war. It's very hard to make a total comedy in a war background, since war isn't funny, but this movie takes its best chance.

Glenn and Kent Smith, a general, are isolated together after a particularly bloody battle, and when Kent dies saving Glenn's life, he's extremely humbled. He holds the helmet of the late general, and that's when another unit finds and rescues him. They assume he's holding his own helmet, and Glenn doesn't correct them. He thinks it will inspire the troops if he pretends to be the general and tells them what a great job they're doing. However, he doesn't count on Red Buttons, the only soldier of the bunch who has met him before. Mixing situational comedy, fast timing, and the somberness of war, Imitation General does its best to make audiences laugh while they're watching soldiers. The Teahouse of the August Moon is a rarity, but keep in mind it takes place during post-war reconstruction, not during active battles.