Un favor muy especial

There is a lot to like about this Rock Hudson film, but also a lot that just didn't work. Aside from being wildly uneven, it's just not that good a film.

The movie starts off quite well. Rock plays a womanizer who is absolutely irresistible to women--and he soon wins a legal case simply because the judge thinks he's a hunk. His opponent (Charles Boyer) is impressed with Hudson's sex appeal and befriends him. Soon, however, their friendship is tested when Boyer asks Rock to seduce his VERY proper and seemingly unhappy daughter (Leslie Caron). However, instead of doing this directly, when Rock finds out she's a psychologist, he decides to concoct some stupid disorder and tries to trick her into loving him. This and the rest of the film is VERY contrived--never making any sense and at times being rather offensive. My ULTRA-feminist college-age daughter kept having an apoplexy as she watched Rock's shenanigans--and she felt he was more like a date rapist than a hero! I didn't feel quite that strongly but could understand how someone could be very turned off by him--he WAS a jerk and the film stopped making sense towards the end. A FAR cry from the great films he made with Doris Day, that's for sure! Unlikable characters and poor writing make this a chore to watch at times. Very skippable.

I am reviewing the DVD I saw, which combined two "Rock Hudson" movies under the heading "Rock Hudson collection". 2 movies for the price of 1? Bring'em on! The first film: "Any Body Seen My Gal", is a Douglas Sirk comedy I had never heard of. Yet…I found this film to be a pleasure from beginning to the end! It is 1952 and Rock Hudson is very handsome and so young, and the whole movie (story, 1930s setting, colors, the ensemble cast of actors) is a delight to watch. What an enchanting piece of movie-making, with dark existential realities behind the apparent lightness. The second film ("A Very Special Favor") is a mixed bag. Because it was made in 1965, its first 30 minutes are a must-see priceless candy bordering on parody (except it is the real stuff, ah ah!): 60s decor, 60s orchestral music, Pink Panther-style opening credits, rear view projections in "Paris" or "New York", sexual banter, witty dialogue, split screens, Yves Saint Laurent dresses. After these first 30 minutes, however, the story line veers off into a war of the sexes theme that makes a modern viewer cringe, even though the film still has some very funny scenes. Rock Hudson, Charles Boyer and Walter Slezak are excellent. Leslie Caron is probably miscast.

"A Very Special Favor" has a very clever idea for a movie plot. Oh, sure, it's strange, even weird, and hardly believable. But that's the kind of stuff that often makes for wonderful comedies. And, this could have been such - with the screenplay and very funny dialog, and supporting cast. But there's a big problem with the film that actually detracts from the humorous schemes and dialog of Charles Boyer's Michel Boullard. It may be two parts of a problem, or two separate problems.

The first and biggest one is Leslie Caron as Dr. Lauren Boullard. In her women's suits, professional demeanor and wise, controlled persona, Caron is about as attractive as a mackerel in the market. And she is as exciting, alive, and believable as an alluring pursuit of Rock Hudson's Paul Chadwick, as a wet fish. She never loses this persona at any time, so that in each scene with Chadwick, any attraction seems impossible. The second minus for the film is related to the first - there is absolutely zero chemistry between Hudson and Caron.

Again, there is very funny dialog between Hudson's and Boyer's characters and others. And Boyer's schemes and reversals are hilarious. Doris Day would have been perfect for the part of Dr. Lauren Boullard. With a couple of strokes of the pen, she could have been the American-born daughter of Michel's American wife who left him or who died.

As is, the unattractive, cold fish character of Caron's Dr. Boullard is a real turn-off for this film. The absence of any spark between her and Hudson's Chadwick is all over the screen, and his slight show of interest isn't at all believable. Leslie Caron had a marked beauty about her, and she was very attractive in many films. But not so in this one. Universal really needed to do a makeover of the leads for the cast here.

The ending of this film is a surprise and almost shouts for the female lead to have been Doris Day. It could have been a real funny and good closing. Instead, it puts a nail in the coffin of disbelief in the story.

But for the superb script and very good comedy provided mostly by Hudson, Boyer and Walter Slezak as Etienne, this film wouldn't even rate four stars. When fans had been flocking to Rock Hudson movies, especially his comedy romances, this film had just $4.5 million in box office ticket sales. It barely covered its budget, if that, in a year that had blockbuster films such as "The Sound of Music" ($145 million box office), "Doctor Zhivago" ($127 million box office), and four comedies that had $20 to $38 million at the box office.

I don't think that Rock Hudson's scheme of pretending to be gay (which he was in real life) had anything to do with this film almost tanking. In 1959's "Pillow Talk," Hudson's Brad Allen schemes over the phone with Doris Day to make her think the Texan she has met and is dating (a role he assumed when he met Day's Jan Morrow by chance) is an effeminate momma's boy. It was done with great humor and didn't stop that film from being a box office hit.

I'm not one who thinks of movies as occasionally miscast. But this one surely is an exception. Here are some funny lines from this film.

Arnold Plum, "I was a mess. And the sad thing is, I never knew it. She had to point it out to me."

Paul Chadwick, "What does she look like now... today... this minute?" Michel Boullard, "How does one describe inner beauty?" Paul, "Forget the inside. Let's stay on the outside for a while." Michel, "I feel safe in saying she's attractive..." Paul, "YOU feel safe? Would it be risky for anyone else to say it?"

Paul Chadwick, "She's a skinny, flat--chested girl with buck teeth. And so far, you've only been talking about her good points."

Paul Chadwick, "Oh, doctor, it's a curse, a nightmare. Do you know what it feels like to be wanted just for your body?" Dr. Lauren Boullard, "Nooo." Paul, "Ah, how I envy you. What I'd give to have a body nobody'd want..."

Paul Chadwick, "I had just enlisted in the Marine Corps that morning.... Wanda was a decent girl, but in a moment of patriotism, she offered herself to me." Dr. Lauren Boullard, "She offered herself to you." Paul, "I said, 'No!' I was a Marine now. I didn't want to do anything to besmirch the honor of the Corps. But, if I hadn't said no, she never would have jumped."

Dr. Lauren Boullard, "Mr. Chadwick, not all women destroy themselves when a man refuses to make love to them." Paul Chadwick, "I can't risk another woman."

Dr. Lauren Boullard, "Believe me, Mr. Chadwick - you can accomplish just as much within a group." Paul Chadwick, "Mmm, yeah, but it makes it a little more difficult."

Dr. Lauren Boullard, "And what is the next step? Even if a woman is standing there with no clothes on, you will be able to walk out on her." Paul Chadwick, "That'll be the day."

Etienne, "But you said he had to be destroyed." Michel Boullard, "I was thinking of a normal revenge. In France, what happens? The woman shoots the man. That's civilized."

Etienne, "Michel this is madness. Your daughter cries, so you break down and tell her the truth. In the hands of an outraged woman, that's a dangerous weapon."

Michel Boullard,, "For what she did, make her suffer, my son - marry her." Paul Chadwick, "I'm being broadsided. You said 'my son' again and my stomach didn't turn. There's something evil going on and I don't know how to fight it."

I've been reading the other reviews with interest. I saw this film on TV about 45 years ago when I was about 8 years old. Around this time I used to watch two back-to-back films on a Saturday or Sunday and I remember this film because it was absolutely hilarious. All the other good films have been repeated on TV - but I have only ever seen this once. I remember laughing and laughing when watching the film. I didn't know anything about sex at that age. I just saw it as a father trying to get his daughter to 'lighten up', to 'live', and to have an interest in finding a male companion in life, instead of an existence of continual work. I didn't see anything odd about Rock Hudson's character pretending to be a patient with his 'problem'. This subterfuge was a key part of romantic comedy films of the time. I certainly didn't see the 'set-up' scene as anything to do with sex - I just remember it as a slightly naughty prank. In some ways the film does remind me of 'pillow talk' and this isn't surprising as one of the writers is the same. I am very pleased to hear that it is now on DVD and I will be very interested to see it again.

Rock Hudson is at his best when it comes to romantic comedy. Their is excellent chemistry with the cast of this film. This movie should be on everyone's agenda to see if ever it becomes available. There are a lot of enjoyable laughs and you come away from it feeling good. It will definitely lift your spirits.