Masterson of Kansas

Masterson of Kansas (1954)

** (out of 4)

Decent, if by the numbers, Western has Bat Masterson (George Montgomery) and Doc Holliday (James Griffith) about to shoot it out when Wyatt Earp (Bruce Cowling) breaks it up. Soon a friend to the Indians is convicted of a crime he didn't commit and the Indians are threatening violence if the man dies for the crime. Now it's up to Bat, Doc and Earp to try and figure out who the real killer is. William Castle will always be remembered for the cheap horror movies he made at the end of his career and it's pretty funny to look back on his earlier days because you'll see countless Westerns that he did for Columbia. This here is one of them and it's certainly a lot better than some he made but at the same time no one is going to confuse this for the work of John Ford. I think for the most part the film remains childish and fun as there's never anything for you to take too serious. If you're into history then it's best to skip this film as there are many liberties taken but I guess that should go without saying. I thought mixing up the three characters made for an entertaining picture and I think the stuff with the Indians also made for some mild entertainment. The majority of the running time is dialogue with the three men constantly arguing with one another and making threats that you know will never happen. I did enjoy the cast with Griffith easily stealing the film as Holliday. He brings a certain toughness to the role but also handles some of the quieter moments dealing with his illness. Montgomery is a tad bit stiff but this actually helps the character and Cowling is fun as Earp. There have been countless films with Doc and Earp so if you want something serious then it's best to look elsewhere. This film here is just 72-minutes worth a "B" fun. Nothing serious. Just mindless entertainment.

Once more, I had to endure a Sam Katzman's production, this time a western, supposed to tell the story of Bat Masterson, a conquest of the West figure, authentic character, who would have deserved better than being evoked by this awful Sam Katzman producer. William Castle, the future horror gimmick films genius, could not do anything against this plague named Katzman who condemned him to mediocrity in the studio; such a talented, gifted director. It is a good time waster though, but you have to keep out of your head the idea that such a plot would have been ten times better, produced by an Harry Joe Brown or Howard Christie. Well, we have to deal with it, we have no choice.

Bat Masterson (George Montgomery) is a gunslinger. Masterson, Wyatt Earp (Bruce Cowling) and Doc Holliday (James Griffith) work together to protect an impending land exchange between honest rancher Merrick (John Maxwell) and peace-seeking Indian chief Yellow Hawk (Jay Silverheels) against the crooked chicanery of land baron Clay Bennett (David Bruce). Nancy Gates ( Comanche station) is the daughter of Merrick, who is sentenced to hang, but believes him innocent ...

A fairly good shoot-em up, which does what it says on its tin and offers good entertainment. James Griffith as Doc Holliday is a scene stealer, and gives this nifty B-programmer some gravitas, and Montgomery is his usual likeable and stalwart self as Bat Masterson.

I've admired James Griffith as a shady character actor for some years but he shines in this little B western. He appeared in around 200 film & TV shows but this is the best I've seen him. He plays Doc Holliday, friend of Wyatt Earp, but this time he's mainly squaring up to Bat Masterson, played by George Montgomery. William Castle directs and Nancy Gates is the romantic interest. The plot is formular for this period in Hollywood -1954- famous lawman meets famous gunslinger meets pretty girl. Bad guys try to act menacing but fail miserable. George Montgomery plays George Montgomery again and in wide screen which is nice. Some poor acting from supporting cast and weak script lines keep this from ever becoming a good western. OK for 10 year old children though.

William Castle Directed this Awful Story that Never Seems as Urgent as the Screenplay Pretends.

It is a Talk-Fest Interrupted at Regular Intervals with a Lot of Gun-Fire.

But the Whole Movie seems Off.

George Montgomery Delivers Every Line with the Same Inflection and Two Facial Expressions...Not Smiling and Smiling.

It's a Slog that Tries to Ramp Up the Story of a Murder-Trial that may Result in an Indian War.

Wyatt is taken Out of the Action by a Thrown Rock.

None of this is Convincing.

The Trial is Stiff and Boring as is most of this Misfire.

Bat Masterson, Wyatt Earp, Doc Holliday, Virgil Earp...it's one of those "Name-Droppers" that Proliferated Pictures in the 1950's.

It Takes More than Famous Name-Tags to Make a Movie Entertaining.

Filmed in Technicolor so that's Something.