Paradise in Harlem

This movie is by far one of the best in Black Cinema, an all star cast consisting of Percy Verwayen, Edna Mae Harris, Francine Everett, Babe and Eddie Matthews, Norman Astwood, Frank Wilson, Madeline Belt, Lucky Millander, Alec Lovejoy, and Mamie Smith. This movie is about a performer who wants to do Shakespeare but no one wants to give him a chance, they rather see him in "blackface." He gets caught up in trouble when he sees a murder committed by gangsters and they do all they can to ruin his life and career, but he finally gets his chance to do Shakespeare and its almost ruined by the audiences until the saints and the sinners join together and bring jazz and gospel together. The Othello scene is the best. The entertainment is wonderful. You get to see why Harlem became a household name and why black performers were called the best entertainers. Babe Matthews is electrifying, Francine Everett is as wonderful as an actress can be, Edna Mae Harris is vibrant as ever, Madeline Belt is sweet and hot, Percy Verwayen is the man you'd love to hate. You can't go wrong with this, Black filmmakers should check this one out and try to make movies like this.

MAMIE SMITH has second billing, but her tiny part as a boarding house keeper is a background character with brief scenes. She sings two songs: (1) LORD, LORD; and (2) HARLEM BLUES (a modernized version of her signature song, "CRAZY BLUES" which had been recorded in 1920 and touted as the "first" song recorded by a black woman; not entirely true). She is another show business mystery. Hollywood filmmakers should have employed her (as they did her contemporaries, ETHEL WATERS and HATTIE McDANIEL) in major drama, musical and comedy productions.

Singing, dancing and music performances by veterans of the colored vaudeville and nightclub circuit is the main attraction. The film probably the only scene from Othello with the dialog delivered in the a cappella gospel style. The acting is quite acceptable as are the sets, though the rock bottom budget shows through in places.

Paradise in Harlem was one of 50 films in one of those big packs of older movies. Perhaps it's not a good idea to sit down and watch the whole pack, without watching something completely different just to clear the palate. I had watched 4 or so of the films in the pack, and most were excruciatingly awful. Then I hit Paradise in Harlem, and it was like a breath of fresh air. Real people doing real things. Yes, there were stereotypes. On the other hand, John Candy could have been considered a stereotype. The characters were varied and had ups and downs. They didn't just stumble into good luck through deus ex machina. I just really liked this film. I could watch it and enjoy it and appreciate it. One little thing that I really liked--the filmmakers did not put us through Lem's no doubt silly, embarrassing vaudeville act; you saw only his makeup, which told you all you needed to know about his act.

The director, Joseph Seiden, started as a cinematographer in silents. In the 1930's and 40's he was the leading producer of Yiddish films in the United States. This was the first film that he directed. Seiden gets excellent performances from his cast. Some of it is stereotyped, but a great deal is honest, raw and human.

The movie is low budget, but has a documentary feel that adds to the realism. The story mixes gangsters with a Church trying to put on a version of "Othello," It isn't realistic, but it works as melodrama.

Frank H. Wilson is the star. He starred with Paul Robeson in the "Emperor Jones" in 1932 and with Rex Ingram and Eddie Rochester Anderson in "Green Pastures" in 1936. Sadly, he only played a few bit parts after this. He really creates a touching character as Lem Anderson, a vaudevillian trying to become a serious actor. He brings off the role with intelligence and sweetness.

Edna Mae Harris also stands out in a small but important role.

I believe that Orson Welles staged an all Black Othello in Harlem around the time that this movie was made. I'm pretty sure this film was partially based on that event.