El camino trágico

In 1945, Roy Rogers had become Republic's King of the Cowboys. His films were shown not only across the country, but in allied countries which were depending on US films for entertainment. In major cities, like New York, Roy's films got booking dates in first run theaters. Studio president Herbert Yates was in New York City when he saw the Broadway production of "Oklahoma." Taking note of the musical western elements, he decided that the Rogers' pictures would all feature a musical production number at the end. This is why the entire cast, including Gabby Hayes and a flock of sheep, perform on stage before a group of townspeople. This would be the agenda until 1946 when William Witney, Republic's serial director, took over the helm. It was his idea to "toughen up" the King of the Cowboys and add some realistic and bruising fight scenes.

Dale Evans is starring in a musical in Chicago that loses it's backers right before opening. She owns a ranch in Utah that she inherited from her grandfather, so she decides to go there and sell it. She'll use the money to back the musical herself.

Roy Rogers, Gabby Hayes and the Sons of the Pioneers work on her ranch. They know that if she decides to sell it, a local sheep farmer will buy it immediately and the land will become overrun with sheep. (This is the 2nd western I've watched this month built around the animosity between sheep farmers and cattle ranchers.) Rogers develops the not-very-smart plan of lying to Evans and telling her that Hayes' dilapidated shack is her ranch. This naturally makes her MORE eager to dump it and crooked real estate dealer Grant Withers is more than willing to help her sell it for 1/20 of it's real value.

This isn't a bad Rogers western, but it's not very good either. The plot really requires him to be dumb and dishonest, and then ties everything up with some completely arbitrary plotting that sort of makes him out to be the hero anyway. It's not very convincing.

These movies are all delightfully weird anyway. Rogers, Evans and the Sons of the Pioneers find a LOT of opportunities to sing in the barely-over-an-hour running time, Hayes spends the entire film complaining about how terrible women are, and the whole thing ends in a huge musical number that's literally on a stage where the whole cast plus a flock of sheep re-enact the film you just watched.

"Utah" is a light Roy Rogers Western with the whole gang - Dale Evans, Gabby Hayes, and of course Trigger. Except for some nice scenery, it is undistinguished, but it is a good way to pass a pleasant hour.

The picture begins with Dale as a member of a singing and dancing troupe in Chicago, whose act might have to disband because of lack of backing. Dale remembers that her grandfather left her a ranch in Utah - she has never seen the ranch, but decides that selling it might be a good way of raising money to keep the show afloat. So she heads west, taking the women in her show along for the ride. It turns out that the Bar-X Ranch is run by Roy and Gabby, who do not want to see it sold, since they know a big land speculator who has been just waiting to grab the Bar-X and replace the cattle with sheep.

From there, events get pretty far-fetched, but entertaining. There are of course some cowboy songs, and there is a lot of cornball humor centering on the incongruity of a group of women from the city having to associate with a group of cowboys. Some of the humor is lame and dated, but the good-natured feel of the movie keeps it from becoming too annoying.

One less routine aspect of "Utah" is the scenery - there are a lot of good background shots (for example, during the horse chase scenes) that remind us of Utah's rugged grandeur.

"Utah" is good light entertainment for any fan of old Westerns.

It all begins on a stage in Chicago, where Dale Evans is rehearsing a song for a forthcoming musical. Unfortunately, the show's backers have pulled out, so the production is shut down. Miss Evans, however, owns a ranch in Utah she has never seen, so she packs up the chorines and takes them out there. She intends to sell the ranch for enough money to produce the show, and if she can't, she figures they can eat until the next season begins. Her foreman, Roy Rogers, doesn't want her to sell the well maintained and profitable ranch. After some ill-natured sparring, he hits on the idea of taking her to Gabby Hayes' run-down spread. Unfortunately for his plans, she sells her ranch to some bad guys for a fraction of of its value.

This one doesn't rate as high as most of the Roy Rogers-Dale Evans movies, and I can see why. The musical numbers run the gamut from the usual western numbers by the Sons of the Pioneers -- who play Miss Evans' cow hands -- to southern numbers, to blues. I thought it was a well-produced movie, with some nice twists in the plot, and lots of good humor. See if you can spot Richard Farnsworth among the stunt men.

Another Roy Rogers movie when Republic Studios had his movies loaded with songs and music which I love.You must get the uncut version of this movie to really appreciate it. Bob Nolan and the Sons of the Pioneers sing some very good songs along with Roy. Gabby Hayes has some good lines when fighting with the women who he wishes would leave the west and go back to Chicago. There is an excellent musical stage ending where they all sing the title song and several others. The one scene where Roy, Dale and the Pioneers sing Utah against a backdrop of scenes from that beautiful state is a highlight of this movie. Again watch the uncut version.