Soup to Nuts

I first caught this movie at four a.m. one night and found it to be insane, pure insanity. The first half hour or so is pretty slow and not very funny, but full of shouting and sight gags. But things get going when the Stooges (with Shemp, of course) go to a restaurant and annoy the waiter. Then their peformance at a firemen's ball is a lot of fun and starts the movie with some good laughs that continue as the Stooges try to fight a blazing fire. A lot of the Stooge elements of later shorts can be found here (the fixed coin tosses, the slapping, the big fat lady) but the movie doesn't focus enough on the Stooges' personalities to create the hard laughs that the shorts have, and the lackluster performances by the supporting cast cause this movie to lag at times. But the slap fight between Shemp and Moe is hilarious.

Probably the only reason anyone watches this today is to see the first film appearance of The Three Stooges; and any viewer looking for Stoogic brilliance will necessarily be disappointed. But taken on its own terms, there's a good deal to appreciate in this bizarre little number. The attempt to translate Rube Goldberg's comics to a cinematic format results in some hilarious moments. There are also some big laughs from a comedian named Freddy Sanborne, who ludicrously overplays his role as a gay slapstick fireman (this movie was made prior to the Hayes Code, when the character's obvious homosexuality was permissible comedy fodder). The Stooges themselves are disappointing. Their number included Shemp at this time (this was PRE-Curly), and Larry gets more dialog than Moe. They generate a few nyuks, but if you're after great Stooge viewing, you've come to the wrong place. I give this one 6 stars out of 10.

Ted Healy was one of vaudeville's most popular performer. His talents were so great in the 1920s he became the highest paid act in vaudeville, pulling down an astronomical $9,000 a week on the stage. A childhood friend, Moses Horwitz (a.k.a. Moe Howard), had briefly joined Healy, born Ernest Nash, on the stage in the mid-1910s when both were just teenagers before they split. Healy developed a revue with a cast including his wife, acrobats and singers. When the tumblers left his act, Healy thought of a comedy routine where hecklers in the audience were invited on the stage. Moe answered an ad Healy placed in the local paper, and the pair's working relationship was renewed. Moe's older brother, Shemp, later joined Healy's act in 1924 after he too proved to be a great heckler. The trio's on and off schtick eventually brought a fourth comedian to the team, Larry Fine, the lead performer at a popular Chicago nightclub. Called "Ted Healy & the Southern Gentlemen," they were hired by Fox Films to star in September 1930's "Soup to Nuts." The movie was the film debut for Healy and the soon-to-be-named 'The Three Stooges.'

Healy is a costume attire salesman who likes to hang out at the local fire station, where the stooges work. A love triangle develops between Healy and businessman Carlson (Stanley Smith), vying for the interests of a bankrupt inventor's niece, Louise (Lucile Browne). Wedged amongst a number of comic sketches at the fire house with the stooges and the finale where they respond to a fire in which Louise is trapped in, Healy and Carlson battle one another for her loving cup.

Fox Films loved the Howards' and Fine's repertoire in "Soup to Nuts" so much the studio offered them a contract. Healy, left out of the offer, argued with the studio the three comics were under his employ. And he refused to release them. The trio split from Healy and went on their own way. Performing as 'The Three Lost Soles' and 'Howard, Fine, and Howard,' they joined the RKO vaudeville circuit, taking on Jack Walsh as their straight man. Meanwhile, Healy hired three replacements, which weren't nearly as talented as the Howards/Fine package.

Two years later, with Moe as the act's business manager, Healy, not happy with the stooges' replacements, ate crow and approached them to appear in a Jacob Shubert's theatre revue. Moe, crunching the numbers, saw Healy's financial position was strong with the Shubert contact. The three joined Healy in July 1932, only to see Shemp walk out after several rehearsals. Moe's older brother was tired of Healy's temper, drinking and abusive behavior and accepted an offer with Vitaphone Studios. Moe and Larry stuck with Healy, and convinced Moe's younger brother, Jerry, to join them. In the next year, Healy inked a movie contract with MGM, where he and the three sidekicks, including newbie Jerry, who took the stage name Curly, began to really gain the attention of a nationwide audience.

What we appear to have here are some vaudeville comedians trying to bring their acts to the screen assisted by a story from comic strip artist Rube Goldberg. It doesn't seem likely that any of them knew much about making movies no matter how good they may have been at making people laugh in their normal venues. The result is a mostly haphazard collection of lame gags with a few totally inane scenes thrown in for "plot" development. It isn't a total loss, however, because this fundamental weakness turns out also to be the film's greatest strength. Not knowing what they were doing, they manage to create a movie with a truly unusual and unique approach to film comedy. No matter how bad it may be, there are a few moments of hilarity delivered in a style you'll not see anywhere else.

What really makes this worthwhile for most viewers, however, is it being the film debut of the 3 Stooges. Their skit near the end of the movie is basically a filmed vaudeville routine and is quite a bit different from the familiar act they eventually developed for their later shorts, but it's probably the closest we'll ever come to seeing what they originally looked like when performing on stage (and our only chance to see bizarre "fourth stooge" Fred Sanborn). No 3 Stooges fan should ever consider passing up the opportunity to see this.

Let me also say that many of the other reviews here seem very unfair to Ted Healy, the Stooges original leader. From what I've read, the Stooges always thought very highly of his talents, but eventually got tired of his drunken binges and not being given the credit (or money) they deserved. In fact, it was after an early split with Healy that Shemp refused to return to work for him, thus requiring younger brother Curly to be brought in as a replacement (although much maligned by Stooge fans, Shemp does go on to be the only one of them with a successful film career independent of being a stooge). Healy, a big vaudeville star, seemed on his way to becoming a big film star before being killed in a bar fight during one of his drunken binges. Having never had the chance to see him in vaudeville, it hardly seems fair to judge him based on a few movies he made while still learning how to make the transition.

Everybody commenting here seems to forget about the fine character actor Charles Winninger, who unfortunately is one of the best things about this mediocre picture. Yeah, we Stooges fans only watched this to see our favorite slapstick guys in their very first exposure to film, and most of us already knew that Healy's semi-popularity as a comedian was a mystery. But there are indeed other things going on here, most notably the aforementioned Winninger, who's the funniest person in this film, most assuredly. Watch out for that gigantic boot!