The Sacred City

Excellent documentary film. As a researcher historian, Dan Gibson has all that is neccessary to take on such project: he is thorough, honest, studious, unbiased, hard working, and highly dedicated to his research subject. The film is very well produced, great photography, and very clear narration.

Before watching leave your biases behind. it doesn't insult islam just reevaluates historical facts. i am ex-muslim myself and i can understand negative reviews but take it as a documantary. if you didn't like it than try to find proofs that corrects the infos given in this doc.

i suggest it to everyone who has interest in history.

There are two reviews here as of this writing one has 10 stars and the other 1.

The negative review comes with the hard statement that the Qibla never moved...and for that you need to present proof that it didn't move. You can't really state it as faith.

And you can't do it because this is about history, not faith. I'm Catholic, I don't practice, but I still have faith in God and Jesus. Faith enough where I am going to question it, because I want to know what happened. I want to know the truth, and there really isn't any piece of evidence that archeology and history can produce that will change the core of my belief.

Now, the history of my faith, how it came to be, that has been changed time and again, and I hope it will continue to be changed until we have the best possible picture of how we came to be as possible.

This is also how I can believe in evolution. It doesn't test my faith. Nothing about it calls my faith in God into question.

I really believe that we have to take the same approach with everything. Including the Petra/Mecca debate.

At its heart, this is a theory. But it is a theory that has enough heat behind it to warrant further investigation. It's compelling enough to call history into question as it stands now...

....and that is really the type of thing that I love. The questions that could re-write history, the conjuncture that is enough to make you really question everything you know. Makes me drool with anticipation.

Amazing.. This is so valuable film It is more logical to consider Petra as the sacred city of Islam, as it fits the Islamic description of the original holy city of Islam rather than Mecca.

It seems logical and compelling documentary and has been remained unanswered from Islamic figures. None of religious branches of islam has been able to prepare an answer in defense of the old and ordinary view of Islam history. Therefore it sounds that the finings of Dan Gibson, the researcher, stays profound, impressive and without any rejection.